Conjugate point to a spacelike surface 2026-10-06
A conjugate point to a spacelike surface occurs where normal geodesics develop a focal degeneracy: the transverse Jacobi field map from initial points on the surface ceases to be invertible. Collapse of the transverse area makes the null expansion diverge. Beyond a first such point, the normal null geodesic cannot continue as a generator of the achronal boundary of the surface's future.
For future-complete generators of an event horizon, the null convergence condition and hypersurface orthogonality reduce the Null Raychaudhuri equation to . If , integration gives focusing within affine distance . The null focusing theorem identifies this with a conjugate point to a spacelike surface. A null generator cannot remain on an achronal boundary beyond such a focal point, contradicting future completeness on the horizon. Thus , and gives the second law of black-hole mechanics. New horizon generators may join toward the future at crease sets, adding area, but generators have no future endpoints on a regular event horizon under these assumptions.
// Target: quantum-field-theory.bigb
Future horismos 2026-10-06
The future horismos is the part of the causal future outside the chronological future. For a compact set in a globally hyperbolic spacetime, it equals the boundary of the chronological future. Its normal null geodesic generators cannot have passed a conjugate point to a spacelike surface when the initial set is that surface.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 iii Paper 63 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
The black-hole area theorem is a statement about classical future event horizons, with both a local focusing condition and global horizon regularity assumptions. Assume the null energy condition, an appropriately predictable exterior and no future termination of horizon generators before the focusing argument can be applied. Future-complete generators provide a particularly direct sufficient version of the last assumption. Strong asymptotic predictability is the usual global condition used to exclude the pathological alternatives; the energy condition by itself is not the whole theorem.
On a smooth part of the horizon, choose a future-directed affinely parametrized generator and affine parameter . Its expansion is the fractional rate of change of an infinitesimal transverse area element:The horizon is a null hypersurface, so its generator congruence is hypersurface-orthogonal and has zero twist. The transverse screen metric is positive definite, hence . In four dimensions the Null Raychaudhuri equation isThe Einstein field equations and the null energy condition imply the null convergence condition , so .
Suppose at . As long as the congruence remains smooth, integrating shows focusing within affine distance at most . Equivalently, comparison with the equality solution givesIts denominator tends to zero at finite future affine parameter. The corresponding transverse area collapses, giving a conjugate point to a spacelike surface. Beyond a focal point a generator cannot remain on an achronal boundary, since nearby points can then be joined by a timelike curve. But a regular future event horizon is such a boundary, and its generators cannot leave it to the future. With the stated future-extension assumption this is a contradiction. Therefore on the smooth horizon.
Following generators from one horizon cross-section to a later one now gives a noncontracting area map. Generators entering at past endpoints or merger crease sets can add area, whereas the global hypotheses exclude generators disappearing from the future horizon. ConsequentlyThis is the future-complete horizon focusing proof of the area theorem. In spacetime dimensions, the coefficient is replaced by and the same proof gives a focusing distance at most . It therefore also applies to the three-dimensional horizon cross-sections of the preceding five-dimensional example.
A cosmological constant does not invalidate the local focusing step. Contract the modified Einstein field equations with the null generator. Since , both the scalar-curvature term and the term disappear:Thus a cosmological constant preserves null convergence, whatever its sign. Under suitable global assumptions for the relevant asymptotic region, the black-hole area argument still works. A nonzero changes the asymptotic geometry and can introduce cosmological horizons, so the statement concerns the appropriate future black-hole horizon; it is not an assertion that every horizon-like surface automatically obeys the same area ordering.
A classical real canonical massless scalar field also preserves the area theorem's energy condition. Its stress tensor hasThis proof is independent of whether the field gradient is spacelike, timelike or null: the metric term vanishes and the remaining real square is nonnegative. It is the null energy condition for a canonical scalar field. Adding this field to other matter satisfying the null energy condition retains null convergence. With the same global regularity assumptions, area still cannot decrease; when the derivative along a generator is nonzero, it supplies an additional nonnegative focusing source.
The conclusion uses the given minimally coupled classical stress tensor. A wrong-sign kinetic term or a nonminimal curvature coupling would require another calculation. Likewise, a renormalized quantum stress-energy tensor need not obey the classical pointwise condition; the quantum radiation considered next is not covered by this classical proof.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 56 3 e Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
The second law of black-hole mechanics states that the total area of a classical future event horizon cannot decrease toward the future, under the appropriate causal and energy assumptions. Use the null convergence condition ; in general relativity the Einstein field equations imply it from the null energy condition. Assume, as allowed here, that the horizon's null generators remain on the horizon and are complete to the future. The horizon is an achronal boundary, and its smooth generators are hypersurface-orthogonal, so their null twist is zero. The Null Raychaudhuri equation therefore givesIf some smooth horizon point had , then while the optical description remains regular, stays negative andThusforcing focusing no later than .
The assumed geometrical result is that this focusing produces a conjugate point to a spacelike surface, namely a focal point relative to a small spacelike horizon cross-section through the original point. A null geodesic beyond such a focal point ceases to generate an achronal boundary: a timelike variation connects the cross-section to points just beyond it. Since the cross-section and the generator lie on the achronal horizon, this is impossible. Future completeness ensures that a singular endpoint cannot terminate the generator before the finite focusing parameter. This future-complete horizon focusing proof of the area theorem rules out .
Therefore on smooth horizon pieces, and the transverse-area identity givesIntegrating over generators proves area nondecrease between later cross-sections. At crease sets, new generators may enter the horizon from the past, adding area; horizon generators do not leave it toward the future under the stated assumptions. Hence the statement also applies to total horizon area through black-hole mergers. Hawking's area theorem is classical: quantum stress-energy can violate the null energy condition, so it does not forbid a shrinking evaporating black hole.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 52 2 b iv Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
One standard form of the Penrose singularity theorem assumes a time-oriented globally hyperbolic spacetime with a noncompact Cauchy hypersurface, the null convergence condition for every null vector , and a closed future trapped surface. It concludes future null geodesic incompleteness: some future-inextendible null geodesic has a finite upper endpoint of its affine parameter.
The focusing mechanism is the Null Raychaudhuri equation. The normal generators have zero null twist, soAn initial therefore gives a conjugate point to a spacelike surface within affine distance at most , assuming the generator can be continued that far. Such a generator ceases to lie on the achronal boundary after its first focal point. Compactness of the trapped surface supplies a uniform bound for all normalized initial null normals. Future completeness would consequently make its future boundary compact. Projection along timelike curves to a connected Cauchy hypersurface is injective on the achronal boundary and has open image. Compactness makes the image closed as well; the nonempty image must therefore be the entire hypersurface, contradicting its noncompactness. This explains why the global assumptions supplement local focusing.
For Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime, the Maxwell stress-energy tensor satisfies the null energy condition; the Einstein field equations imply the required null convergence condition. The spheres in the band just found are closed and trapped. Apply the theorem to a maximal Cauchy development with a noncompact Cauchy hypersurface and containing one such sphere. That globally hyperbolic spacetime must be future null-geodesically incomplete.
The Penrose theorem at a Cauchy horizon needs care: the full maximal analytic Reissner-Nordstrom spacetime has inner Cauchy horizons and is not globally hyperbolic. It does not satisfy every hypothesis of the displayed theorem. In the exact solution some incomplete geodesics of the globally hyperbolic development reach a smoothly extendible Cauchy horizon in finite affine parameter. The theorem asserts incompleteness of the development, not that every such endpoint is a curvature singularity. The separate curvature singularity at does not justify silently dropping the theorem's global hypothesis.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 311 4 a ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The second law of black-hole mechanics says that the total area of future event horizon cross-sections cannot decrease toward the future, assuming the classical Einstein field equations, the null energy condition, suitable global predictability and regularity, and here the stipulated future completeness of its generators.
A future event horizon is an achronal boundary generated by null geodesics. If a smooth generator had , the null focusing theorem would produce a conjugate point to a spacelike surface within finite affine parameter. Future completeness lets the generator reach it, but beyond such a point it could no longer remain on the achronal boundary, a contradiction. Hence wherever the null expansion is defined. A transported area element obeysEvery generator present on an early cut continues to a later cut without decreasing its area contribution. New generators can join at past endpoints, adding area; future endpoints in a regular spacetime are excluded. ThereforeThis argument also covers the sum of initially disconnected event horizons of the black holes in a merger. Nonsmooth crease sets require the standard regularity treatment; they do not provide a classical area-decrease loophole under these hypotheses. Quantum negative-energy flux can violate the classical null energy condition, so this is a classical black-hole area theorem, not an unconditional law for evaporating black holes.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2017 iii Paper 311 2 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The Einstein field equations and the null energy condition imply the null convergence condition:The scalar-curvature and any cosmological constant terms vanish because . For generators of the null hypersurface, the supplied twist-free property gives . The null shear squared is nonnegative on the screen. Thus the Null Raychaudhuri equation impliesStarting from , the null expansion remains negative for as long as the regular congruence exists. HenceBefore the right-hand side reaches zero, inversion of the negative quantities givesSince the inverse of a finite negative null expansion cannot be nonnegative, the regular congruence cannot continue through the proposed upper limit. The null focusing theorem therefore givesProvided the geodesic itself extends this far, the transverse area collapses and at or before this bound. An earlier end of the affine geodesic would instead be geodesic incompleteness. A divergence of the null expansion marks a caustic or a conjugate point to a spacelike surface; it does not by itself establish a curvature singularity.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2017 iii Paper 311 2 d Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The relevant Penrose singularity theorem states: a connected time-oriented four-dimensional globally hyperbolic spacetime with a noncompact Cauchy hypersurface, a nonempty compact orientable boundaryless trapped surface, and the null convergence condition is future null-geodesically incomplete. Under the Einstein field equations, the null energy condition supplies the curvature hypothesis. A trapped surface here is spacelike and has both future normal null expansions strictly negative. The conclusion is an incomplete null geodesic, not necessarily a divergent curvature invariant at an identifiable point.
Suppose, for contradiction, that every future null geodesic is complete. Write for the trapped surface andThe equality follows because the causal future of a compact set is closed in a globally hyperbolic spacetime. This future horismos is a closed achronal boundary. It is nonempty: the restriction of a Cauchy time function to compact has a minimum, and a point at that minimum cannot be chronologically preceded by another point of .
Normalize the two future null normal directions along against a smooth future timelike field, fixing the affine scale continuously. Their initial null expansions are continuous and strictly negative. Compactness of the normalized normal bundle gives a uniform with everywhere on . The preceding null focusing theorem forces a conjugate point to a spacelike surface along each normal generator within affine length .
By the supplied boundary-generator result, every point of is reached by an orthogonal future null geodesic which has no earlier conjugate point. No such boundary generator can remain on the boundary beyond its first focal point. Every point of therefore lies inThe parameter set is compact. Future null completeness makes its geodesic flow defined throughout this common finite interval, and smooth dependence on initial data makes its image compact. Since is closed and contained in , it is compact. This is the compactness of the future horismos of a trapped surface step; a merely pointwise finite bound would not suffice without compactness and uniform normalization.
Choose a smooth complete timelike vector field, obtained if necessary by positive rescaling against a complete auxiliary Riemannian metric. Its inextendible integral curves of a vector field meet a chosen smooth Cauchy hypersurface exactly once. Projection along those curves defines a continuous map . The achronal set property makes this map an injective function: two boundary points on the same timelike integral curve of a vector field would be timelike related.
An achronal boundary is a topological hypersurface without boundary, even at nonsmooth generator junctions; the submanifold property allowed in the question supplies this fact. Thus domain and codomain are both three-dimensional topological manifolds without boundary. Invariance of domain makes open in . Compactness makes it closed in the Hausdorff space , and it is nonempty. Connectedness of the spacetime gives connectedness of , so this image is all of . That would make compact, contradicting the noncompact Cauchy hypersurface hypothesis. The completeness assumption is false, proving the theorem.
The noncompactness hypothesis and strict trapping are essential to this version. Global hyperbolicity cannot simply be omitted in the compactness and projection steps, and nonpositive initial expansion with zeros does not supply the uniform focusing bound used here.