The surprise was a pulsar whose apparent period would not stay fixed. Russell Alan Hulse's Arecibo search used a multichannel receiver, pulsar dedispersion and computer searches over period and pulse width. Follow-up at higher time resolution retained the changing period, excluding inadequate sampling as its explanation. The observed variation exceeded the expected terrestrial Doppler shift; a predicted reversal from decreasing to increasing period appeared on 16 September 1974.[ref]
The 1975 analysis fitted an eccentric Kepler orbit to Doppler shifts inferred from about 200 five-minute period measurements over ten days. That discovery fit was not yet the later precision arrival-time experiment.[ref] An orbit explains both signs of the apparent period change without requiring the stellar rotation to alternate between speeding up and slowing down.
PSR B1913+16 2026-10-18
Russell Alan Hulse and Joseph Hooton Taylor Jr. discovered this binary pulsar at Arecibo in 1974; their January 1975 paper reports a roughly pulse period and orbital period. Its unseen companion was not detected as a second radio pulsar. Discovery of the orbit preceded the later binary-pulsar orbital decay test.[ref]
The 1993 Nobel Prize in Physics recognized the discovery.[ref]
By 1993, the system was interpreted as a pair of neutron stars.[ref]