For continuous subharmonic function on the unit disk, let be the Poisson integral of its values on , evaluated inside that disk. Harmonic comparison gives for . The Harnack inequality for harmonic functions makes their limit either finite and harmonic everywhere or everywhere infinite. In the finite case every harmonic majorant dominates every , so their limit is the least harmonic majorant. The supremum must restrict ; the Poisson expression evaluated outside its circle does not have this interpretation.
Use the Nevanlinna proximity function and the Nevanlinna integrated counting function for poles, counting multiplicity. If the pole order at zero is , then
Boundedness of the Nevanlinna characteristic refers to , equivalently to a uniform bound on for any fixed . This avoids the harmless origin normalization when .
The Nevanlinna first main theorem states, for every fixed finite value and every nonconstant meromorphic function on the disk,
For , this is the definition of . The error is bounded independently of . Translation changes by , while Jensen's formula gives when near zero; these observations explain the first theorem.
The Nevanlinna second main theorem in the unit disc states that for distinct values on the Riemann sphere,
as outside an exceptional set satisfying . The truncated Nevanlinna counting function counts each distinct preimage once. The boundary-distance error cannot simply be suppressed: on the disk it need not be . The disk error and exceptional-set estimates follow from the logarithmic-derivative estimates in mathweb.tifr.res.in/Documents/Publications/Lectures/tifr17.pdf .
Suppose first that is bounded. Since , its poles satisfy the Blaschke condition, counting their orders: let in their integrated count and use . Let be their Blaschke product, including the origin factor if necessary. Then extends to a holomorphic function on the whole disk, and gives
Here the last bound follows from bounded and the uniform lower bound on .
The nonnegative subharmonic function has a finite harmonic majorant. Indeed its Poisson integrals on expanding disks dominate it by the maximum principle for subharmonic functions, increase with , and have . The Harnack inequality for harmonic functions bounds them on every compact subdisk, so their increasing limit is a finite harmonic function . Since the disk is simply connected, has a harmonic conjugate, giving a holomorphic function with . Consequently
This proves the constructive half of the quotient characterization of bounded characteristic.
Conversely, if with bounded holomorphic functions and , each pole of is a zero of of at least the same order. The elementary inequality and the Nevanlinna first main theorem give
Any cancellation at an origin zero contributes only a bounded multiple of on , which is included in this . The zero function is immediate; constant nonzero is handled directly. Thus bounded characteristic is exactly a quotient of two bounded analytic functions.
An unbounded example with bounded characteristic is
It is a ratio of the bounded holomorphic functions and . More explicitly, Jensen's formula gives the mean of as zero, so , although .
Finally, set . Pointwise . Jensen's inequality for the concave logarithm gives
There is no pole term because is holomorphic. Hence the stated integral bound implies bounded characteristic. This argument in fact works for every .
On a connected Riemann surface , a Perron family of subharmonic functions is a nonempty family of real continuous subharmonic functions closed under pairwise maxima and under harmonic lifting on every relatively compact coordinate disk. A harmonic lifting of a continuous subharmonic function replaces its values inside such a disk by the harmonic Poisson integral of its boundary values, leaving the function unchanged outside. Harmonic comparison shows that the lift dominates the original function. The lift is continuous and remains subharmonic by harmonic comparison across the circle.
Write . Because the family is nonempty and its members are finite, cannot be minus infinity. Suppose first , and choose a relatively compact coordinate disk containing . Choose approaching at . Lift on to get , and recursively lift to get . These are members of the family, harmonic on , and increasing. Also .
The nonnegative harmonic functions are bounded at . The Harnack inequality for harmonic functions, on chains of compact subdisks, bounds them uniformly on every compact subset of . The Poisson integral then bounds their derivatives on smaller subdisks. Compact convergence and the mean value property show that their increasing limit is finite and harmonic; denote the limit of by .
Fix an arbitrary , and let be the lift of on . These functions increase, are harmonic on , and satisfy . They are bounded at , so the same Harnack inequality for harmonic functions argument gives a harmonic limit . At , , whereas on . The nonnegative harmonic difference has an interior zero, so the strong maximum principle for harmonic functions gives . Since , we have . Taking the supremum over gives , and gives the opposite inequality. Thus on .
The finite locus of is open by this argument. It is also closed: if a point is a limit of finite points, choose a coordinate disk around it and a finite point in that disk; the preceding argument applied with that finite point shows that is finite on the entire disk. Connectedness now proves the dichotomy
Both occur. The family of all continuous subharmonic functions bounded above by zero is a Perron family of subharmonic functions, since the maximum principle for harmonic functions keeps every lift below zero; it contains zero, so its supremum is zero. The family of constant functions with positive integer values is also a Perron family of subharmonic functions, and its supremum is everywhere infinite.
For the final application, the radius must enclose the evaluation point. For set
This is the harmonic lifting of a continuous subharmonic function on the radius- disk. Hence there. If , on the radius- boundary, so harmonic comparison gives throughout the smaller disk. The increasing limit is either everywhere infinite or finite and harmonic, by the preceding Harnack argument and propagation across overlapping disks. In the finite case it dominates . Any harmonic majorant of dominates by boundary comparison and therefore dominates their limit. Thus the precise conclusion is
provided a finite harmonic majorant exists. This is the least harmonic majorant by expanding disk lifts.
There are two necessary qualifications to the printed formula. First, the supremum cannot include . For example, if and , the kernel has normalized integral for and for . The displayed integral is consequently in the first case and in the second. The unrestricted supremum would be , although the least harmonic majorant is ; at the kernel is undefined. Second, a finite harmonic majorant need not exist. The continuous subharmonic function
has . If were harmonic, its centered circular means would equal and dominate for every , an impossibility. In this case the limit formula holds only in the extended sense, with value and no finite least harmonic majorant.
Let , which is finite because is bounded, and put . Then is harmonic. Choose points with . For any fixed , choose large enough that . Since is harmonic on all of , the Harnack inequality for harmonic functions on gives
The comparison factor is independent of the growing radius, which is essential. Thus for every and
This proves the Liouville theorem for harmonic functions in every dimension. In fact the argument only needs an entire harmonic function to be bounded below; changing its sign gives the corresponding bounded-above result.
A local form of the Harnack inequality for harmonic functions is: if is harmonic on a neighbourhood of , then
For , the triangle inequality gives . The ball mean value property for harmonic functions and nonnegativity therefore imply
Taking the supremum over and infimum over proves the inequality, including the case where the infimum is zero. No strict positivity assumption was used.
On a connected domain , the equivalent compact-set statement is that for each nonempty compact there exists with
Here is the passage from balls to this statement. Cover by finitely many small balls whose quadrupled closed balls lie in . Join their centres to a fixed centre by paths in . Each of the finitely many paths has compact image and positive distance from the boundary, so subdividing it gives a finite chain of overlapping small balls whose quadrupled closures also lie in . The local inequality compares any two points in each ball; using a point in each successive overlap propagates comparisons along the chain. The number of comparisons is bounded uniformly over this finite collection of chains and covering balls. Multiplying the factors gives one finite constant for all pairs , proving the compact-set inequality. In particular a nonnegative harmonic function vanishing at one interior point vanishes throughout a connected domain.
The local Harnack inequality for harmonic functions states that if is harmonic on a neighbourhood of , then
More generally, for any compact in a connected open domain , there is such that for every nonnegative harmonic on . Positivity is essential; the assertion is not for arbitrary sign-changing functions.
First prove the mean value property for harmonic functions. For a smooth harmonic function the spherical mean has derivative
so it equals ; integration in the radius gives the ball mean property. The preceding Weyl lemma supplies smoothness if harmonicity was initially distributional.
For the inclusion and nonnegativity give
Taking the supremum over and the infimum over proves the local estimate directly. To obtain the compact-set form, connect centres of a finite ball cover of to a fixed interior point by paths in . The compact union of those paths stays a positive distance from the complement of . Subdivide the paths into finitely many steps small enough that the local estimate applies at consecutive points. Multiply the finitely many comparison constants, first from one point of to the reference point and then to any other point of . This gives a constant independent of . In particular a nonnegative harmonic function is either everywhere positive or identically zero on each connected component.
For , the open balls satisfy . Nonnegativity and the mean value property for harmonic functions give
Taking the supremum over and the infimum over proves the Harnack inequality for harmonic functions:
This includes a zero infimum, which forces on the smaller ball.
Shift by a constant and, if necessary, change sign to obtain an entire nonnegative harmonic function . The Harnack inequality for harmonic functions on arbitrarily large balls centred at gives for every . Thus is globally bounded. The interior derivative estimate for a harmonic function now gives on balls of arbitrarily large radius . Letting proves , hence is constant. This proves the one-sided harmonic Liouville theorem in every dimension.
A nonempty collection of real continuous subharmonic functions on a connected Riemann surface is a Perron family if it is closed under pairwise maxima and harmonic lifting of a continuous subharmonic function on every relatively compact coordinate disk. Its pointwise supremum is either everywhere infinite or a harmonic function on a Riemann surface. At a point where the supremum is finite, take increasing disk lifts approaching that value. The Harnack inequality for harmonic functions gives a finite harmonic limit on the disk. Lifting their maxima with any other member gives a larger harmonic limit with the same value at the chosen point, hence the same limit by the strong maximum principle for harmonic functions. The supremum is therefore harmonic on that disk; connectedness propagates finiteness to the whole surface.