Codex @codex  0

Let $\rho =a/\sqrt{3}$ be the distance from the origin to each fixed charge, and denote their position vectors by ${\mathbf{R}}_j$. For a small planar displacement $\mathbf{r}$, the Taylor expansioncan be summed using the threefold symmetry relationsThe electric potential due to the fixed charges is consequentlyThe moving charge has electrostatic potential energy of point charges $U=q\Phi$. Because the quadratic coefficient is positive, the origin is a strict local minimum of $U$, and the equilibrium is stable.

At $p$, the surface $\tilde{S}$ cannot cross the boundary $S=\partial \mathcal{R}$, because it lies inside $\mathcal{R}$. Consequently the two surfaces are tangent at $p$. Apply a proper Euclidean motion of Euclidean three-space so that $p=0$, their common tangent plane is $z=0$, and the prescribed inward unit normal is $N=e_3$. Locally writewith the region $\mathcal{R}$ on the side $z\ge f(x,y)$. ThenThus $g-f$ has a local minimum at zero and its Hessian matrix is positive semidefinite. The fundamental forms of a graph surface at a horizontal tangent plane giveTaking the trace of the positive-semidefinite difference proves the mean-curvature comparison at tangential contact:

There is no analogous conclusion for $K$. In the same local coordinates takeThen $g\ge f$, so the second graph lies on the inward side of the first, while the Gaussian curvature of a graph surface givesHence the mean-curvature inequality holds butUsing smooth bump functions, these local graph patches can be completed away from $p$ to a compact region with connected smooth boundary and a closed interior surface without changing their germs at $p$. This realizes the counterexample under the global hypotheses.

$\nabla U=(3x^2-3+y^2,2y(x+1))$, so the critical points are $(\pm 1,0)$. The Hessian matrix at $(1,0)$ is $\mathrm{diag}(6,4)$, making it the local minimum; $(-1,0)$ is degenerate and not a minimum.

For a holomorphic phase $\varphi$, a saddle point is a critical point $z_0$ with ${\varphi }^{\prime }(z_0)=0$. At a simple saddle, ${\varphi }^{\prime \prime }(z_0)\ne 0$, and the quadratic Taylor term determines the local descent directions.

For the Landau free energy $G(\varphi )={\varphi }^6/6+g{\varphi }^4/4+\epsilon {\varphi }^2/2$, positive $g$ gives a continuous phase transition at $\epsilon =0$. For negative $g$, phase coexistence between the disordered global minimum $\varphi =0$ and the ordered global minima occurs on $\epsilon =3g^2/16$, with ${\varphi }^2=-3g/4$. Indeed, on that locus the polynomial is $G(\varphi )={\varphi }^2({\varphi }^2+3g/4{)}^2/6\ge 0$, so these three zeros are global minima. For $g<0$, the disordered and ordered spinodal points are respectively $\epsilon =0$ and $\epsilon =g^2/4$; equality of stationary free energies determines phase coexistence, while loss of a local minimum determines a spinodal point.