Hadronic tensor 2026-10-05
The inclusive product of hadronic-current matrix elements, summed over final states with a Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure. Electromagnetic current conservation makes both indices transverse to the exchanged four-momentum.
The tree-level two-body decay width from is
above the on-shell threshold. The charged pair is distinguishable, so no identical-particle factor divides this result. Below threshold, physical multi-particle decays through virtual W bosons require a different Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure.
When the full Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure treats identical final particles as labeled, each physical final configuration is counted times. The unlabelled relativistic scattering cross-section therefore includes . For two identical scalars, this divides the full-angle result by two; equivalently, integrate over a region containing only one representative of each exchanged pair.
With relativistically normalized external states, is the reduced S-matrix element after removing the four-momentum conservation distribution. A relativistic scattering cross-section combines with the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure and the invariant flux factor. Identical-leg factorials in Feynman vertices and the identical final-state symmetry factor in the event integral have different roles.
The invariant future mass-shell measure is , up to fixed normalization factors absorbed in . Its relation to the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure follows by integrating over in a local orthonormal tetrad. A particle carries four-momentum and crosses a local spatial surface with velocity . Integrating the associated momentum flux gives the displayed stress-energy tensor. For photons, and .
Use Minkowski metric signature and natural units. With no lepton mixing, choose the weak charged current convention
Its conjugate convention exchanges and without changing the interaction. The relevant four-fermion interaction gives the muon decay amplitude, up to an overall phase,
Here is the Fermi constant; the factors are twice the left chiral projector, so there is no additional factor of two to insert.
For the final-spin sum let , where . It already describes the specified initial polarization; there is no further initial-spin average. The two gamma matrix traces are
The electron-mass term vanishes in its chiral trace. In the muon trace, anticommutation with gives
For the chiral fermion trace contraction, define
The supplied trace conventions imply and , where . The factor four in the second trace follows from the polarization projector. The symmetric parts contract to . The Levi-Civita symbol contraction, including , contributes . Mixed symmetric-antisymmetric contractions vanish. Thus , and
Now neglect as well. Put and . The given moment integral over two-neutrino relativistic two-body phase space yields
In the muon rest frame, , , and . Substitution gives
Combining this with the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure, whose one-particle denominator is , and , gives the polarized muon decay distribution
Consequently , , . Integration over the electron direction removes the polarization term, and , recovering .
The spin vector is axial and the momentum direction is polar: under parity, stays unchanged while reverses. Their scalar product therefore changes sign. Its nonzero coefficient demonstrates parity violation in polarized muon decay, arising from the left-chiral weak charged current. At the upper endpoint the negative muon's electron is preferentially emitted opposite the spin, providing a sign check on the result.
Use an incoming spacelike momentum transfer , so the physical absorption process has , , and . There is a sign inconsistency in the original PDF: its delta function has , while its positive Bjorken x definition and target formulas use incoming . With that literal delta function and , the final-state invariant would be
which becomes negative in the stated high-energy limit and cannot represent a physical hadronic final state. We therefore use , preserving the printed and structure-function conventions. Equivalently, keeping an outgoing momentum variable requires reversing the signs in those definitions as well.
Assume an unpolarized target, incoherent scattering from effectively free spin-one-half partons, and the massless collinear parton approximation. In the Bjorken scaling limit, take at fixed , neglecting target and quark masses and intrinsic transverse momentum relative to . Write the incoming struck-quark momentum as in the leading lightlike-reference approximation. Let and be quark and antiquark parton distribution functions, counting all colours. For the naive scaling result also neglect radiative scaling violations; in full QCD these distributions depend logarithmically on the hard scale.
The outgoing struck quark has momentum . Its on-shell condition gives
Average its initial spin and sum its final spin. The spin-averaged electromagnetic parton tensor has numerator
The supplied three-gamma identity gives this directly: contract its middle index with and trace with ; the trace vanishes. Thus no antisymmetric term survives the unpolarized spin average.
Define transverse tensors
On the cut, , so . Expanding the two transverse terms gives
This also explicitly verifies electromagnetic current conservation, .
The one-particle final-state Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure obeys
Including the current's charge factor and the given normalization, a single quark therefore contributes
An antiquark has the same unpolarized tensor and the same squared charge .
The parton convolution normalization for a hadronic tensor is
The is important: the distributions count parton numbers, whereas covariantly normalized one-particle responses carry the state normalization . The incoherent sum of normalized responses is ; in the collinear frame , giving the factor above. There is no extra colour multiplicity because it is already included in the distributions.
On the physical cut,
Comparing the two transverse coefficients in the hadronic tensor gives, with ,
Therefore the requested deep-inelastic structure functions are
The notation here is the question's with its flavour index made explicit. The calculation proves the Callan-Gross relation, , rather than merely citing it. Finite masses and radiative corrections modify this leading approximation; at leading QCD order the same formulas use scale-dependent parton distribution functions.
The quark number sum rule follows because a distribution is a number density. Integrating counts quarks and integrating counts antiquarks; their difference is the net conserved flavour charge:
Every sea quark-antiquark pair contributes zero to this difference. More formally the flavour-vector charge counts quarks minus antiquarks and has a fixed eigenvalue on the hadron state. Thus is the valence or net quark number, not the total number including the sea.
Use both final assumptions printed in the question: only up/down flavours and no antiquarks. The second does not follow just from restricting the flavour list. Then , , with squared charges and . The proton has and the neutron . Hence the valence-only proton and neutron structure-function moments are
The integral limits assume the scaling approximation is valid for the indicated weighted moments, for example by dominated convergence of the weighted integrands. The same net-quark sum rule alone would not fix these individual moments in the presence of antiquarks, since involves the sum of quark and antiquark distributions.
Use natural units and the Minkowski metric , and work at tree level with on-shell final particles. Write and, for a final particle of mass , . In the Higgs boson rest frame the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure reduces to
To obtain this, integrate the momentum delta function to set ; the energy delta function is , whose radial Jacobian is . Hence for an angle-independent final-state spin sum ,
There is no initial-state spin average for a scalar, and neither charged-particle pair here requires an identical-particle factor of .
For Higgs decay to two W bosons, the Feynman vertex gives , up to an overall phase. Contracting the two massive vector polarization sums gives
The constant 2 follows from in the contraction, with the last term coming from the two momentum projectors. Putting , the full massive result is
The on-shell two-body width is zero below this threshold; decays through off-shell W bosons into more particles are different channels.
For Higgs decay to a fermion pair, put . The amplitude is , up to an overall phase and a color Kronecker delta. The fermion spin sums and gamma-matrix trace give
The color multiplicity in a decay width is : only a quark and antiquark with matching colors contribute, so the factor is three rather than nine. Therefore
Again the on-shell two-body width is zero below threshold. This is a partonic tree-level answer with every mass retained; hadronization is outside the specified calculation.
The W boson channel dominates for large within the tree-level comparison. The widths scale as and , respectively, and
The enhancement comes from longitudinal polarization of a massive vector boson: its polarization vector grows as momentum divided by . Thus the longitudinal pair survives the apparently small factor in the interaction. At masses so large that the scalar sector is strongly coupled, the tree-level extrapolation itself needs corrections.
For an unpolarized initial fermion, average over its two spin states and sum over the unobserved final spin:
The initial scalar has only one spin state. One can evaluate this sum directly from normalized Dirac spinors, or use consistent fermion spin sums to express it as a trace. It is the squared sum of both tree scattering amplitudes, not the sum of their separate squares.
The relativistic scattering cross-section is obtained by integrating the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure and dividing by the invariant flux factor:
There is no identical-final-particle factor, because the outgoing scalar and fermion are distinct. All energies are positive, with and .
Equivalently, in the centre-of-momentum frame set . Integrating the energy delta function in the relativistic two-body phase space gives
For this elastic process , so integrate over the full solid angle. This supplies the requested prescription without evaluating the angular integral.
Use the metric and the usual Dirac basis, with and . In this solution the sign of the chirality matrix is the one specified in the paper, . Define and , with no summation in componentwise transformation formulas.
Complex conjugation changes the explicit to . Three spatial gamma matrices each contribute another minus sign, so
Also and by the Clifford algebra.
The quantum time-reversal operator is antiunitary: it conjugates numerical coefficients, including the Dirac spinors and plane-wave exponentials in the mode expansion of a Dirac field. To fix the spin phase explicitly, put and use
This convention gives on a one-fermion state, since . In the transformed expansion, change variables from to . The Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure is unchanged, and . The coefficient of is therefore
The same calculation applies to the antiparticle coefficient. Thus, with this explicitly fixed spin convention,
The spin phase in the Dirac time-reversal matrix matters here: a common change of the one-particle time-reversal phase replaces by ; the phase-independent relation is . It changes neither the defining conjugation property nor any bilinear result below. Normalize to be a unitary matrix. In the Dirac basis, is real and commutes with , so transforming the Dirac adjoint gives
Here complex conjugation of the matrix defining the Dirac adjoint is essential. An explicit realization consistent with the sign of used here is and ; it has , so conjugation by and by coincides. The usual changes of Dirac spinor basis by unitary matrices carry the adjoint and time-reversal matrix with them.
For the charge-conjugation matrix, the gamma matrix adjoint and transpose identities give . Consequently . Since in the chosen phase convention,
This proof uses a temporal Hermitian matrix and spatial skew-Hermitian matrices explicitly; the transpose identity is preserved when is transformed appropriately with the gamma matrices.
For the Fermi interaction, let and . In the displayed Dirac basis, the inverse version of the conjugation relation also holds. Antiunitarity, and give
The leptonic weak charged current has the same component signs. In the contraction of leptonic and hadronic currents, the two factors cancel. Its two independent operators thus keep their form while their coefficients become and . The Hermitian-conjugate term transforms separately; its presence does not remove a relative complex phase between the vector and axial couplings.
With all intrinsic phases fixed to one and a real positive Fermi constant, invariance requires real coefficients in that convention. A common phase of and can instead be absorbed into a rephasing of the nucleon fields, and hence into their intrinsic time-reversal phases. The convention-independent condition, for , is
This is the relative weak phase condition for time reversal. If one coefficient vanishes, there is no relative phase to constrain; the remaining common phase can be removed. A nonreal ratio violates time-reversal symmetry even though the Lagrangian density includes its Hermitian conjugate.
The strong-interaction matrix element between two spin-zero pseudoscalar mesons has only and available. The product of the two intrinsic parities is positive. An axial current would require a pseudovector constructed from these momenta, but an expression involving the Levi-Civita symbol needs three independent four-vectors and therefore vanishes. This is a consequence of parity conservation in the hadronic matrix element, not of parity conservation in the weak interaction. The vector current can have the two independent structures and . Its coefficients are Lorentz scalars; with and fixed, their only varying invariant is . Hence
These are the pseudoscalar-to-pseudoscalar form factors. With relativistically normalized states they are dimensionless. The vanishing axial matrix element and this decomposition explain the two equalities separately.
Write and for the outgoing electron and antineutrino momenta. From the Fermi interaction, an invariant scattering amplitude, up to an irrelevant overall sign or phase, is
The CKM matrix element multiplies the quark current in the convention of this interaction. Let . For massless leptons, the massless Dirac equation and chirality matrix anticommutation give
In the second term move through the chiral projector before applying . Since , this transverse massless leptonic current gives
The disappearance of uses the massless approximation; for a massive charged lepton its contraction is proportional to the lepton mass.
Use the fermion spin sum and the supplied gamma matrix trace identities. The symmetric part of the leptonic tensor is
The Levi-Civita symbol term is antisymmetric and drops out when contracted with . Thus
There is no initial-spin average because the kaon is spinless. For the integrated massless leptonic tensor, keep every factor of explicit and define the unnormalized two-lepton Lorentz-invariant phase space
The leptons are massless, so . Its trace is . Therefore
The three Lorentz-invariant phase-space measures and their momentum delta function contribute , in addition to in the decay rate. Combining them with the spin sum gives
This massless semileptonic pseudoscalar decay rate uses a two-lepton integral over future-timelike and the pion integral is restricted to the physically allowed region. The null endpoint follows by continuity. The coefficient has mass dimension , so the complete expression has mass dimension one, as a decay rate must in natural units.
In the kaon centre-of-momentum frame, put and . Then
The dimensionally consistent Källén function is
The pion-only mass term must have fourth power: the second power printed in the PDF is dimensionally inconsistent. This repair also follows directly from squaring . Angular integration and the change of variable give
where the negative sign reverses the endpoints. Combining this with the bracket yields
Thus . The lower limit is the minimum invariant mass of two massless leptons; at the upper limit the pion is at rest. The coefficient has mass dimension , while has dimension eight. The Källén function also shows why the differential decay rate vanishes at zero pion momentum.
Use the momentum-space Feynman rules with the scalar Feynman propagator . The four-leg vertex of a factorial-normalized scalar interaction has weight for the positive interaction sign printed here. There are Wick contractions assigning four external legs to its four fields, cancelling the factorial in its coefficient. A negative interaction sign would give ; its squared tree amplitude is the same.
At each vertex include with all incident momenta taken incoming. Assign an internal momentum to each line and integrate each independent loop with . Divide a graph by its Feynman-diagram symmetry factor, sum the graphs at the chosen order, and omit disconnected vacuum graphs from normalized amplitudes. For an S-matrix element, amputate external propagators and put the external momenta on shell as in the LSZ reduction formula; the external one-particle residues are one at tree level.
Define the invariant amplitude by the relativistically normalized matrix element
with . The lowest-order connected four-point graph is one contact vertex:
There is no exchange graph at this order because there is no three-field interaction.
Figure 1.
Tree-level contact diagram for two incoming and two outgoing real scalar particles
. Details.
For the elastic scattering from a quartic scalar contact interaction, write for the total centre-of-mass energy and for the energy of each incoming particle. The incoming and outgoing spatial momentum magnitudes both equal , with . The invariant incident flux is
The Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure for two outgoing particles is
In the centre-of-mass frame, the spatial delta function sets , while the energy delta function has radial derivative . Therefore the relativistic two-body phase space satisfies
The two outgoing real-scalar particles are identical. Integrating over the full solid angle counts each unordered pair twice, so include the identical final-state symmetry factor . This gives
This is isotropic. When denotes each particle's energy, and the full-sphere event density is . If denotes the total energy of the pair, and it is . Stating the answer in removes that energy-label ambiguity.
An equally valid angular convention selects one outgoing particle in a hemisphere, so each event is represented once. In that convention omit and use on the hemisphere, or . Both conventions give at this order. The identical-state factor concerns counting final states and is separate from the vertex factorial.
Assume a complete relativistically normalized basis of scalar momentum eigenstates transforms as
This states both reversal of spatial momentum and preservation of the normalization of basis quantum states. Antilinearity alone would not suffice: multiplying a conjugation operator by two gives an antilinear operator that multiplies squared norms by four.
Expand and similarly for , with . This Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure is unchanged under . The antilinearity of the quantum time-reversal operator gives conjugated expansion coefficients. Orthogonality of the momentum eigenstates and cancellation of their unit-modulus phases yield
Since momentum reversal is a bijection of the complete basis, is also onto. Thus
This proves antiunitarity, with the normalization hypothesis explicitly included. For scalar multiparticle quantum states the same argument uses the complete occupation-state basis and reverses all momenta; it is not restricted to a single-particle wave packet.
The authoritative PDF has , not the dimensionally incorrect in the TeX conversion. The two identical Z bosons give the vertex factor two, so the scattering amplitude for the decay is
up to an irrelevant overall phase. Apply the massive vector polarization sum, identifying the hint's with :
Since , putting gives
No initial-spin average is needed for a Higgs boson. In its rest frame the two-body momentum is . Integrating the energy and momentum delta functions in the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure gives , hence .
The printed generic width formula treats the daughters as labelled. Here the identical final-state symmetry factor is , without which the same physical configuration is counted twice. Thus the Higgs decay to two Z bosons has
Equivalently, gives the prefactor . The threshold limit is zero and the large-mass limit is . The additional factor for identical daughters is a required specialization of the PDF's generic phase-space formula, not an extra factor in the vertex.
Use a local orthonormal tetrad and units in which the speed of light is one. A particle has four-momentum and moves with velocity . Thus its energy density contributes , its momentum density contributes , and its momentum flux contributes . Integrating the phase-space distribution function gives the kinetic stress-energy tensor. The measure is the future mass-shell Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure, so the same expression transforms as a spacetime stress-energy tensor; fixed state-counting or polarization factors are understood to be included in .
Define . The photon momentum measure is , so every component of the kinetic stress-energy tensor has a radial factor . An isotropic background has and . Hence
This radiation pressure equation of state requires isotropy and masslessness, not a thermal spectrum.
The distribution perturbation is . Assume finite energy density and endpoint behavior at zero and infinity, as for the Planck photon distribution. Integration by parts then gives
Consequently the perturbed energy density and momentum density are
Since , the photon angular temperature moments give and .
The sign of anisotropic stress must be specified. Direct kinetic integration gives the conventional trace-free spatial stress . The PDF uses the opposite sign, , equivalently . With that convention, all requested moments are
Taking the spatial trace also gives
The angular temperature description assumes is independent of photon energy; independent spectral distortions would require additional energy-dependent moments.
Use the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure from the original PDF, including the and factors missing from the local TeX. In the center of mass frame put and , assuming . The spatial Dirac delta distribution sets , leaving
Since , the radial integral gives
The invariant flux factor is , using the Källén function. Dividing the phase space by this flux yields , with the final-state labels retained as in the printed formula.
Let . Of the Mandelstam variables, is
The azimuthal integral contributes , and the angular endpoints are therefore
Changing variables gives the requested expression from the formula supplied in the paper:
There is a normalization qualification: the displayed starting formula integrates over labeled final momenta and contains no . For the physical cross-section of two indistinguishable outgoing quanta of this real scalar field, the identical-particle factor in a final-state phase-space integral divides the full integral by two. With that convention ; equivalently, integrate only one representative of each exchanged pair. The boxed value follows the given formula exactly.
The deep inelastic scattering process contains a virtual photon exchanged between the electron and the hadron:
Use an electromagnetic vector current containing the dimensionless quark charges, with the coupling factored out. The scattering amplitude, up to an irrelevant phase, is
To match the printed prefactor, define the leptonic tensor with a spin sum over both electron spins and keep the initial spin average outside it. The gamma-matrix trace gives
For a stationary target and massless electron, the invariant flux factor is . The inclusive final-state Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure and target spin average are contained in . Thus the differential scattering cross-section is
Here means . If the initial spin average is instead built into the leptonic tensor, its normalization is and the displayed cross-section prefactor must be doubled. The two conventions give the same observable.
In the simple box-state counting used here, the final three-momentum lies in a spherical shell: , where the common constant contains the normalization volume and angular factor. Momentum conservation fixes the other final particle's momentum. Hence the density of states is
Combining parts (a) and (b) gives
With the paper's rounded masses,
By Fermi's golden rule, equal squared matrix elements make the rate ratio equal to this density ratio. Thus the naive constant-matrix-element estimate is , which favours the electronic decay by about to one.
This is the particular noncovariant state-counting convention in the question. A calculation with the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure places factors in the measure and correspondingly normalizes its decay amplitude differently. Only the complete product of phase space and squared matrix element is convention-independent; mixing the two conventions would give a wrong rate.
The momentum space Feynman rules use the scalar propagator and two Dirac propagators
The cubic scalar field interaction vertex is . Each of the two flavour-changing Yukawa coupling interaction vertices, and , has factor in Dirac spinor indices. A fermion flow arrow continues through each interaction vertex, but its species changes. There is no or interaction vertex.
Every interaction vertex carries with inward four-momenta. Integrate each independent loop momentum with , divide by the Feynman-diagram symmetry factor, and include a minus sign and a gamma-matrix trace for each closed fermion loop. The is the Feynman i-epsilon prescription.
For an amputated scattering amplitude, incoming fermions supply and outgoing fermions supply ; incoming antifermions supply and outgoing antifermions supply . An external real scalar field particle supplies . Use the standard relativistic normalization of a one-particle state; the external factors belong to that normalization and the Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure, rather than an additional factor in the invariant scattering amplitude.
The printed integration labels need correction. The parent's four-momentum is fixed, so the two Lorentz-invariant phase-space measures must integrate and , rather than the printed and . Write and , . The physical decay width is
The spatial Dirac delta function sets . Performing the angular integral in spherical coordinates, with , gives the integrated two-body decay phase space
The positive root is . Since , the Dirac delta function integration yields . Thus
The two final particles have different species, so there is no identical final-state symmetry factor. The result tends to as and vanishes at the two-particle decay threshold.