For planar parabolic coordinates and , the multivariable chain rule gives and . Differentiating once more and adding cancels the first partial derivatives and the mixed partial derivatives:
Consequently, on every local coordinate patch away from the origin, is a harmonic function if and only if is a harmonic function. The Laplacian changes by a positive scale factor, so solutions of the Laplace equation are preserved. The restriction away from the origin is needed to divide by the Jacobian determinant.
Maxwell relations 2026-10-14
Maxwell relations turn pressure, volume and temperature measurements into information about entropy. For example, the pressure rise when heating a rigid sealed vessel determines the entropy change when expanding the same sample isothermally:
The quantities on the two sides describe different experiments, yet both are mixed partial derivatives of one Helmholtz free energy. This is the useful surprise: a mechanical measurement can reveal a thermal property. Similarly, the coefficient of thermal expansion gives . [ref]
For a simple compressible system, hold particle number and composition fixed, and allow only pressure-volume work. Write for internal energy, for enthalpy, for Helmholtz free energy, and for Gibbs free energy. Their natural-variable differentials are
Thus the first partial derivatives, with the subscript recording the variables kept fixed, are
The symmetry of second derivatives produces all four standard Maxwell relations, including their signs:
For a brief derivation of the relation, differentiate with respect to and with respect to : . Each other row follows in the same way. Assume continuous second partial derivatives of the relevant thermodynamic potential in the region considered. At a phase transition, the equilibrium potential may lose this smoothness; apply the identities within each smooth thermodynamic phase, and handle latent heat and phase coexistence separately. If particle numbers vary, the potential differentials acquire chemical potential terms, so the fixed- constraints must remain explicit. [ref]
For an ideal gas with fixed , the ideal gas law gives . At fixed volume, heating changes the pressure at rate . Consequently an isothermal expansion at positive temperature has
For one mole with and , this is . At , a reversible isothermal expansion absorbs and performs equal work, since its internal energy is unchanged. The entropy difference is a state function difference: the same equilibrium endpoints give the same in an insulated free expansion, although there and the process is irreversible.
Figure 1.
Ideal gas entropy slopes equal measured pressure responses to heating
. Left: entropy relative to one common reference state for a classical monatomic gas, , with . Each fixed-temperature curve gains on doubling the volume. Right: both partial derivatives, multiplied by , equal ; circles are independent finite differences of entropy, while the line is the pressure response. Details.
The same Maxwell relations let thermal measurements determine the difference between constant-pressure and constant-volume heat capacities. In a smooth single thermodynamic phase,
using heat capacity at constant volume, heat capacity at constant pressure, coefficient of thermal expansion and isothermal compressibility. Along fixed pressure, , so
Thus measured expansion and compression responses determine a heat capacity difference without measuring both heat capacities separately. They do not determine the absolute heat capacities or absolute entropy by themselves; an independent thermal measurement supplies that missing information. For an ideal gas, and reduce the result to , which is Mayer's relation.
When the necessary higher partial derivatives exist and commute, differentiating the Maxwell relations once more also gives
Integrating these slopes determines how a heat capacity changes with volume or pressure at fixed temperature. For an ideal gas, both right-hand sides vanish because the ideal gas law is linear in temperature at either fixed volume or fixed pressure. Consequently and depend only on temperature at fixed , although they need not be constant in temperature. [ref]
Historically, James Clerk Maxwell's Theory of Heat, first published in 1871, presents these connections using the geometry of isothermal processes and reversible adiabatic processes. His fourth edition, page 167, explicitly relates expansion on heating at fixed pressure to heat emitted during an isothermal compression: the modern relation gives . This explains why a substance with positive coefficient of thermal expansion emits heat when compressed isothermally, whereas one with negative coefficient absorbs it. [ref] [ref]
Write , and . Differentiating twice and cancelling the mixed partial derivatives gives
A convenient set of six three-dimensional Saint-Venant compatibility equations is
They follow by inserting and commuting derivatives. They form the six symmetric components of the incompatibility tensor , up to the indicated signs and permutation of components.
They obey the three differential identities , because a symmetric pair of derivatives contracts with an antisymmetric Levi-Civita symbol. Thus there are three independent differential constraints, represented symmetrically by six component equations; they are not six unrelated constraints on the six strain functions. For example, at a nonzero wavevector directed along the third axis, compatibility imposes while can arise from the three displacement components. This confirms rank three. One cannot simply discard the same arbitrary three component equations in every direction; their independence is differential, with the stated identities. On a simply connected domain these are the local Saint-Venant compatibility equations for strain to be a symmetric displacement gradient, while domains that are multiply connected regions require global closure conditions as in the screw example. This is Saint-Venant strain compatibility and differential identities.
For antiplane displacement the only nonzero strain components are and . Commutation of mixed partial derivatives gives the necessary local compatibility condition
The supplied stress is symmetric, independent of and trace-free. Its first two equilibrium equations are automatic; its third gives
away from the origin. Antiplane shear has zero trace, so isotropic Hooke's law reduces to . Hence
Locally this integrates to , represented on a suitable branch by . The strain condition is satisfied at every point of the punctured plane, but the displacement cannot be made globally single-valued there:
A gradient of a globally single-valued smooth displacement would instead integrate to zero around any closed curve. Local compatibility is therefore not sufficient on this multiply connected region.
A physical construction is a Volterra screw dislocation: cut the cylinder along a radial half-plane ending on its axis, shift one cut face relative to the other parallel to the axis, and rejoin. The axial mismatch is the Burgers vector. In the given normalization its magnitude is ; with a dimensional mismatch one uses . An intact pristine solid cannot reach this state by a smooth single-valued elastic deformation alone. The axis is a dislocation core where the continuum elastic field is singular and must be regularized by microscopic structure or plastic deformation. On the punctured domain the differential condition holds locally; globally its nonzero circulation detects the defect. In a distributional description, that incompatibility is concentrated on the axis. This is local strain compatibility versus screw-dislocation circulation.
The mixed partial derivative measures how the slope changes as varies while is fixed:
when this limit exists. For a small rectangle, the cross-difference is approximately if the second derivatives are continuous. It measures a change of transverse slope, rather than either first slope alone. Mere continuous differentiability does not ensure that this second derivative exists; equality with follows under the usual hypotheses of Clairaut's theorem.
For an exact differential , equality of the mixed partial derivatives requires . Here these are and , so . Integrating with respect to gives . Comparison with gives , and the specified value fixes the integration constant. Therefore
Differentiating recovers both coefficients, and . The explicit potential function also proves exactness globally, without relying only on a local compatibility test.
Assume so that the change of variables is invertible. The chain rule gives and . Commuting the mixed partial derivatives for a twice continuously differentiable solution gives
Thus the wave equation is . Integrating once says that depends only on ; integrating again gives
The two arbitrary twice differentiable functions are waves moving in opposite directions at speed . This is D'Alembert's formula, on a product domain in or globally on the usual full line.
Integrating the mixed partial derivative successively gives . The first boundary value gives . Substitution at then gives . Therefore
Its mixed derivative is , and direct evaluation checks both boundary values. Their common corner is compatible: both prescribe .
Set . The bound and give . Hence at the origin, proving continuity, and , proving Fréchet differentiability there with derivative equal to the zero linear map.
Along the coordinate axes, direct difference quotients give
These formulas include the origin. Therefore the two mixed partial derivatives differ:
The explicit operator order removes any ambiguity about the notation for mixed derivatives. Also , since the first derivatives restricted to their own axes vanish identically.
All four second-order partial derivatives are discontinuous at the origin. Away from it,
Along these are one and minus one, rather than their zero values at the origin. Meanwhile for , whereas its value at the origin is minus one; and for , whereas its origin value is one. This gives a concrete unequal mixed partial derivatives example despite differentiability of the original function.
The canonical anticommutation relations realize the internal states as a fermionic Fock space . Choosing a Clifford vacuum annihilated by all , the states are functions multiplying , , with , or . Thus the four fermion-number sectors in supersymmetric quantum mechanics are
with internal dimensions . The fermion number operator has value on . The sectors have even fermion parity, and have odd fermion parity.
Write , so that the supercharge is . The commutator is zero because the two mixed partial derivatives of agree. The canonical anticommutation relations then imply and
The Hamiltonian operator preserves each sector, while raises and lowers its degree by one. For a state in its operator domain, , so the spectrum is nonnegative. If with , then is a state of the same energy and opposite fermion parity, and . This is an odd involution pairing bosonic and fermionic states and proves equal even and odd multiplicities at every positive eigenvalue.
There is also a more precise adjacent-sector pairing. On the positive-energy eigenspace,
The two summands are orthogonal since . A state in the image of obeys , , so maps it to a normalized partner in the next sector, with inverse . Thus positive-energy doublets lie in , , or . In particular, every positive-energy state of has a partner in , and every one of has a partner in ; the remaining middle-sector states pair with each other. There is no requirement that all four individual sector spectra coincide. Zero-energy states satisfy and can be unpaired. No confinement assumption was given: a continuous spectrum is possible, with the same even/odd pairing on its positive spectral subspaces.
For real , the adjoint operator is . In , every vanishes; in the one-dimensional internal space of , it equals . The two scalar Hamiltonian operators are consequently
These are the extreme sectors of the gradient superpotential Hamiltonian in supersymmetric quantum mechanics.
For radial and a normalized state with , and . The radial superpartner in three-dimensional supersymmetric quantum mechanics therefore has the simple form
It belongs to ; follows from , and its wavefunction normalization follows from . Also . At the origin the formula is interpreted by regular extension; its degree-one components carry the radial unit vector rather than being three independent radial scalars.
For a zero mode in the fermion-vacuum sector, the factorization of gives . Hence , or . The requested wavefunction is
A nonzero normalizable wavefunction exists only if this integral is finite. The positive sign in the exponential is fixed by the given convention .
For a continuously differentiable vector field on all of , the necessary and sufficient condition for a conservative vector field is . Necessity follows from equality of mixed partial derivatives of a potential; sufficiency uses the being a simply connected space. On a general domain the topology cannot be omitted.
Here the relevant mixed partial derivatives are
Thus the curl vanishes. Integrating the first component in gives . Matching the second component gives , hence . Matching the last component forces . A potential of a conservative vector field with the convention is consequently
If a physical potential is defined instead through , it is .
Fix and a sufficiently small rectangle inside . Its rectangular increment
can be evaluated twice using the fundamental theorem of calculus, giving
Divide by and let . Continuity of the mixed partial derivatives makes the two limits and . They are equal everywhere on .
Repeated interchange of adjacent partial derivatives reduces every order- derivative of a smooth function to , . Hence there are at most distinct functions. This maximum is attained by , whose listed partial derivatives are the distinct functions . The answer is , rather than the possible written orders.
For the supplied , for , whereas . It is not even continuous at the origin, so is neither differentiable nor infinitely differentiable there.
For , . Thus , proving Fréchet differentiability at the origin with derivative zero. However,
including zero at the origin. Therefore and . is differentiable but not infinitely differentiable at the origin: it cannot have continuous second partial derivatives near that point.
Use the inverse change of variables and . The chain rule gives the differential operators
The mixed partial derivatives cancel, assuming the twice continuously differentiable solution appropriate here. Consequently .
The transformed equation is
The factors of belong to the inverse Jacobian matrix; using the forward transformation instead would give an incorrect factor.
The multivariable chain rule first gives
Taking a second partial derivative in each variable, with the partial derivatives of evaluated at , gives
The mixed partial derivatives cancel even without using their equality. Hence the Laplacians satisfy
Away from the origin the factor is positive, so is a harmonic function if and only if is a harmonic function on the corresponding local coordinate patch. This is the Laplacian in planar parabolic coordinates.
If for a twice continuously differentiable potential , then and . Equality of mixed partial derivatives gives the necessary condition for an exact differential:
This condition alone does not ensure global exactness on a domain with holes.
For the Helmholtz free energy , use the stated identity for internal energy and the product rule:
Thus and . Equality of mixed partial derivatives yields the Maxwell relation
The temperature and volume are the independent variables here, with composition and amount of gas fixed.
Next express and substitute its total differential into :
Matching the coefficient of gives
This is the thermodynamic internal pressure identity: an equation of state determines how internal energy changes under an isothermal change of volume.
For the Dieterici equation, set while differentiating at fixed . Then
Substitute into the thermodynamic internal pressure identity. The term proportional to cancels , leaving
The physical gas domain has and .
For the ideal gas instead, gives . Therefore is independent of volume at fixed amount of gas. Integrating the remaining condition , with constant heat capacity at constant volume, gives
where is independent of both and and fixes the reference for internal energy.
Differentiate with respect to , remembering that its coefficients also depend on . The product rule and multivariable chain rule give
For a twice continuously differentiable , equality of mixed partial derivatives gives . Hence
The first-order terms come from differentiating and themselves; treating as an operator with constant coefficients would miss them.
At fixed particle number, the differential of the internal energy identifies and . Equality of continuous mixed partial derivatives gives the first Maxwell relation:
For the enthalpy, . Thus , , and the same argument gives the enthalpy Maxwell relation
The smoothness and independent thermodynamic coordinates are understood within a single phase.
First and . Differentiating again gives the four second-order partial derivatives:
The two mixed partial derivatives agree, as expected for this smooth polynomial.
The relevant mixed partial derivatives agree:
The vector field is smooth on the entire simply connected plane, so this condition establishes that it is a conservative vector field. We can also construct its vector-field potential explicitly. From , take an antiderivative in :
Then requires . Hence
The fundamental theorem for line integrals checks the previous answer: .