Newell–Whitehead–Segel equation ($A_T=\mu A+({\partial }_X+i{\partial }_Y^2/2{)}^{2}A-|A{|}^{2}A$)

The Newell–Whitehead–Segel equation is an amplitude equation for slowly modulated stationary rolls in an isotropic pattern-forming medium. With the displayed sign convention, a roll $A=R{e}^{iqX}$ has $R^2=\mu -q^2$. A transverse phase modulation has linear growth rate $q{k}^2-k^4/4$, so long-wave transverse instability occurs for $q>0$. Reversing the carrier-wave convention reverses the sign attached to its detuning $q$; one must derive the stability sign from the operator actually used.

At a nonzero critical wavenumber in an isotropic medium, a small transverse wavevector changes its magnitude only at second order. Balancing radial detuning therefore requires the displayed unequal slow-space scales. With the positive carrier $e^{i{k}_{c}x}$, the leading Newell–Whitehead–Segel equation spatial term is $\xi ({\partial }_X-i{\partial }_Y^2/(2k_c){)}^{2}A$. A roll detuning $q$ has transverse phase growth $-\xi q{p}^2/k_c-\xi p^4/(4k_c^2)$; negative $q$ permits a zigzag instability. Changing the carrier convention changes the accompanying sign of $q$. Replacing this operator by an isotropic second-order Laplacian misses the critical circle's geometry.