Past exam of the chemistry A course of the University of Cambridge / 2023 / Paper 1 / A4 / a / iv / Solution

Each cyanide contributes charge $-1$, so the formal nickel oxidation state is $+2$ and the metal has $d^8$. The requested diagram retains only the five principally metal-$3d$ molecular orbitals; the mainly ligand bonding molecular orbitals lie below them and are omitted.

In the square, $d_{x^2-y^2}$ points directly towards all four ligand donors and gives the highest, strongly antibonding molecular orbital, $B_{1g}$. The $d_{z^2}$ function also has an allowed $A_{1g}$ interaction, but its in-plane overlap is smaller. Including the allowed nickel $4s$ mixing gives a principally $d$ $A_{1g}$ level with relatively weak antibonding character. The $B_{2g}$ and $E_g$ metal functions have no ligand partner in the sigma bond donor basis and are nonbonding in this minimal model. The useful qualitative ordering is thereforeThe three nonbonding functions are shown together because the sigma-only model does not determine their finer splitting. Additional electrostatic and pi backbonding interactions can change the ordering of the lower $d$ levels; molecular symmetry alone does not fix these energy gaps.^[ref]

In the tetrahedron, the ligand $T_2$ combinations interact with the metal $T_2$ functions, producing higher $d$-derived antibonding molecular orbitals. The metal $E$ pair has no sigma donor partner and remains nonbonding:The diagram fills both arrangements with eight metal electrons; the square is shown in its fully paired state.