Past exam of the chemistry B course of the University of Cambridge / 2025 / Paper 1 / B3 / b / Solution

Reduction makes stereogenic centres at C2 and C3 of the indan-1-one framework. The four products are the cis pair $(2R,3S)$ and $(2S,3R)$, and the trans pair $(2R,3R)$ and $(2S,3S)$. Each pair consists of enantiomers; any cis member is diastereomeric to either trans member. There is no meso product because the carbonyl-containing and aromatic sides of the ring do not make C2 and C3 symmetry-equivalent.

For checking the Cahn-Ingold-Prelog priority rules, at C2 the order is carbonyl-side carbon $>$ phenyl $>$ C3 $>$ H. At C3 it is fused aromatic carbon $>$ phenyl $>$ C2 $>$ H. The fused aromatic path outranks the separate phenyl path because it reaches the carbonyl-containing part of the framework.