Past exam of the chemistry course of the year 3 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2021 / Paper 1 / 10 / a / Solution

Strong ligand-to-metal pi donation is favoured by an occupied ligand p orbital and a suitable empty metal d orbital of matching symmetry, with reasonably similar energies and good spatial overlap. Small donor atoms such as O or N can supply short bonds and efficient overlap; oxo, imido and nitrido ligands are familiar examples. Early transition metals in high oxidation states, often $d^0$, are particularly favourable because the metal acceptor orbitals are vacant and relatively low in energy. More spatially extended $4d$ and $5d$ orbitals can strengthen the overlap.

Metal-to-ligand pi backbonding is the complementary case: electron-rich, low-oxidation-state metals donate occupied d orbitals into low-lying ligand antibonding orbitals, as for CO. In both directions, filling a metal–ligand pi-antibonding orbital offsets the multiple-bond stabilization. The relevant prediction is orbital occupancy and overlap, rather than the presence of a formal double-bond line in a drawing.