Past exam of the condensed matter physics course of the University of Oxford / 2015 / 2

The structure factor is the coherent scattering amplitude of the contents of a unit cell at a specified momentum transfer. Contributions from its atoms add with phases fixed by their positions. At a reciprocal lattice vector indexed by Miller indices, the crystal basis structure factor isChanging every phase sign conjugates the amplitude for real scattering factors and leaves the intensity unchanged. The positions here are fractions of the chosen cell edges. An atomic basis of a crystal should not be confused with a set of primitive translation vectors.

In kinematic elastic scattering the diffraction intensity of a Bragg reflection is proportional to $|S_{hkl}{|}^2$, after including geometrical, polarization, thermal-displacement and experimental factors. Powder integrated intensities also include multiplicity. The many-cell interference factor selects reciprocal-lattice vectors satisfying the diffraction geometry; the unit-cell factor determines their relative amplitudes and additional extinctions. Ring positions determine spacings through Bragg's law, while intensity patterns and systematic absences constrain lattice centering and atomic arrangements. Intensity loses the overall complex phase, so structure determination is not a direct measurement of every individual atomic phase.

X-rays scatter from electron density, giving an atomic factor that changes with momentum transfer and chemical charge distribution. Neutrons scatter coherently from nuclei with bound coherent scattering lengths, which need not track atomic number; magnetic neutron scattering is an additional channel in magnetic materials. Their different elemental/isotopic contrasts make the two probes complementary.

For the four conventional face-centered cubic lattice sites $000$, $0\frac{1}{2}\frac{1}{2}$, $\frac{1}{2}0\frac{1}{2}$ and $\frac{1}{2}\frac{1}{2}0$, their centering factor isThis is the face-centred cubic selection rule. Enumerating the nonzero representatives with $h^2+k^2+l^2\le 16$ givesSymmetry-related permutations and signs belong to the same powder ring, not additional rings. For Al, the basis contains one atom, $S=F_{\mathrm{fcc}}{f}_{\mathrm{Al}}$. ThusFor the stated KCl basis,The all-even reflections add the two atomic factors; all-odd reflections subtract them. Ionic $K^{+}$ and $C{l}^{-}$ each have 18 electrons, giving similar X-ray amplitudes. Their difference is much smaller than their sum, so the 111 and 311 rings are weak. Consequently the four strong rings areThis is an accidental diffraction extinction from equal atomic scattering factors in the equal-factor limit, not an extra exact fcc selection rule. Isoelectronic ions can have different radial electron distributions, so real odd reflections need not vanish exactly. Even the cruder neutral-atom estimate $f_K\simeq 19$, $f_{\mathrm{Cl}}\simeq 17$ makes the odd/even basis-intensity ratio only $(2/36{)}^2\simeq 0.0031$, before other ring-intensity factors.

For Si's displaced identical basis atoms,For all-odd indices, the bracket is $1\pm i$, with squared magnitude 2. For all-even indices it vanishes when $h+k+l=2(\mathrm{mod}4)$, and has squared magnitude 4 when the sum is a multiple of four. Thus 200 and 222 vanish, whereas 111, 220, 311 and 400 survive:These are the basis extinctions of the ideal diamond cubic structure. Intensity strengths within each surviving set can still differ because of atomic factors, multiplicity and geometry.

Replacing X-rays by neutrons of the same wavelength keeps the geometric Bragg positions, but replaces electron-density amplitudes by nuclear coherent scattering lengths. For Al all sites still carry the same nonzero amplitude, so its six reflections remain. For Si the identical two-site basis still has the same destructive-interference conditions, so its four reflections remain. Isotopic randomness can add diffuse/incoherent scattering but does not create a new periodic basis with different systematic Bragg absences.

K and Cl, however, have different nuclear amplitudes despite their isoelectronic ionic electron clouds. For natural isotopic composition, $b_K=3.67$ fm and $b_{\mathrm{Cl}}=9.577$ fm. The all-odd/all-even basis-intensity ratio becomeswhich is no longer the strong X-ray cancellation. The two odd rings should therefore be observable with suitable sensitivity, givingThe numerical contrast uses the NIST bound coherent lengths.^[ref] Counts here mean allowed and reasonably observable rings in the specified range, assuming sufficient angular coverage and resolution; no theory alone fixes an instrument's intensity threshold. These nonmagnetic examples use nuclear elastic scattering, not magnetic scattering.