Past exam of the mathematical methods II course of the University of Oxford / 2021 / 3 / Solution

The arc length of the helix follows from its parametrization:Thus ${\ell }_h=15\pi \sqrt{5}\mathrm{m}$. Its endpoint is $(0,20,15\pi )$, at height $h=15\pi \mathrm{m}$.

Under the usual intended interpretation that the descending quarter of a circle drops through one radius, its radius is $R=h$. Its arc length is ${\ell }_c=\pi R/2=15{\pi }^2/2\mathrm{m}$, givingThe printed smoothness condition is inconsistent. The terminal tangent vector of the helix is ${\mathbf{r}}^{\prime }(3\pi )=(-10,0,5)$. Every tangent vector to a curve confined to the $yz$ plane has zero $x$ component, so no such regular curve can join this helix with a common tangent line. Moreover, the helix is still rising at that endpoint. Thus no smooth ride satisfying all the literal conditions exists.

Even after allowing a corner, a quarter of a circle reaching the ground does not alone determine its radius: the orientation of its endpoint radii must also be specified. For example, in the $yz$ plane, the circular arctraversed toward decreasing $\theta$, descends monotonically for $0\le {\theta }_0\le \pi /2$ and reaches $z=0$ when $R=h/(\sin {\theta }_0+\cos {\theta }_0)$. Choosing ${\theta }_0=\pi /4$ gives $R=h/\sqrt{2}$, whereas ${\theta }_0=\pi /2$ gives $R=h$. The numerical answer above is conditional on the intended $R=h$ geometry; it does not repair the impossible smooth join.