Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2005 / iii / Paper 81 / 4 / ii / Solution

Let the positive undisturbed surface tension be $\bar{\sigma }={\sigma }_0-A{\Gamma }_0>0$. An insoluble surfactant perturbation $g$ produces ${\sigma }_1=-Ag$. The tangential Marangoni stress changes the surface condition to $\mu u_z(h)={\sigma }_x$. Solving the lubrication theory momentum equation now givesAt leading order, conservation of insoluble surfactant on a moving interface reduces to ${\Gamma }_t+(\Gamma u_s{)}_x=0$. Corrections from the changing circumference are smaller by $h_0/a$. Likewise the normal-pressure contribution $-{\sigma }_1/a$ gives a coupling smaller by $h_0/a$ than the retained tangential Marangoni stress, so it is omitted at the same order.

For thickness and concentration amplitudes $H,g$ proportional to $e^{\beta t+ikx}$, put $D=a^{-2}-k^2$ and use $p_1=-\bar{\sigma }DH$. The two conservation equations becomeSet $s=k^2{a}^2$, $\lambda =h_0^3\bar{\sigma }/(3\mu a^4)$ and $\alpha =h_{0}A{\Gamma }_0/(\mu a^2)$. The uncoupled capillary growth and elastic relaxation rates are $L=\lambda s(1-s)$ and $S=\alpha s$. The off-diagonal product is $3LS/4$, so the determinant is $(\beta -L)(\beta +S)+3LS/4$. Thus the surfactant stabilization of an annular liquid lining relation isThis proves the dispersion relation before its lettered deductions. The physical assumption $\bar{\sigma }>0$ is needed for the claimed capillary instability band.