Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2006 / iii / Paper 2 (Noetherian Algebras)

Suppose first that $M$ is a Noetherian module. An ascending chain of submodules of $N$ is also a chain in $M$, so it stabilizes. A chain in the quotient module $M/N$ lifts to a chain in $M$, so it also stabilizes. Thus both $N$ and $M/N$ are Noetherian modules.

Conversely, let $M_1\subseteq M_2\subseteq \cdots$ be a chain of submodules of $M$. If $N$ and $M/N$ are Noetherian modules, both $M_i\cap N$ and $(M_i+N)/N$ stabilize, say for $i\ge i_0$. For $x\in M_{i+1}$, equality of the images gives $y\in M_i$ with $x-y\in N$. Then $x-y\in M_{i+1}\cap N=M_i\cap N$, and hence $x\in M_i$. This proves the extension direction of Noetherian modules in a short exact sequence.

The left regular module $R$ is Noetherian because $R$ is a left Noetherian ring. Applying the extension result inductively makes each finite direct sum $R^s$ Noetherian. Every finitely generated module on the left is a quotient module of such a direct sum, so it is Noetherian.

A poly-(cyclic or finite) group has a finite subnormal serieswhose factors are cyclic groups or finite groups. We prove that the group ring $R[G_i]$ is a left Noetherian ring by induction. Put $A=R[G_{i-1}]$. A finite factor makes $R[G_i]$ a finite free left $A$-module, using a coset transversal. Its left ideals are $A$-submodules, so finite-module extension preserves Noetherianity handles this case.

If the factor is infinite cyclic, choose a lift $t$ of a generator and let $\sigma (a)=ta{t}^{-1}$. The group ring is the skew Laurent polynomial ring $A[t,t^{-1};\sigma ]$. Here is the required left-sided skew Hilbert basis theorem. For a left ideal $L\subseteq A[t;\sigma ]$, defineEach $I_n$ is a left ideal of $A$. Left multiplication by $t$ gives $I_n\subseteq I_{n+1}$. The ascending chain condition makes these ideals constant for $n\ge n_0$; choose finitely many generators for each $I_n$, $0\le n\le n_0$, and lift them to polynomials $f_{nj}\in L$.

If $f\in L$ has degree $d\ge n_0$ and leading coefficient $a_d$, writeSubtracting ${\sum }_j{\sigma }^d(r_j)t^{d-n_0}{f}_{n_{0}j}$ cancels the leading coefficient. For $d<n_0$, use the lifts for $I_d$ instead. Induction on polynomial degree shows that the finitely many $f_{nj}$ generate $L$. Thus the skew polynomial ring of an automorphism is a left Noetherian ring.

Finally, for a left ideal $K$ of $A[t,t^{-1};\sigma ]$, its intersection with $A[t;\sigma ]$ has finitely many generators. Every $f\in K$ satisfies $t^{m}f\in A[t;\sigma ]$ for some $m\ge 0$, so those same generators generate $K$ after multiplication by $t^{-m}$. This completes the induction and proves that $R[G]$ is left Noetherian, the left-sided form of group rings of poly-(cyclic or finite) groups are Noetherian.

The Jacobson radical is $J(R)={\bigcap }_{L}L$, where $L$ runs over the maximal right ideals. Every proper right ideal $I$ lies in such an $L$: the union of a chain of proper right ideals containing $I$ is a right ideal and remains proper because it omits $1$. Thus Zorn lemma applies.

The right-module form of Nakayama lemma says that a finitely generated module $M$ with $MJ=M$ is zero. More generally, if $N$ is a submodule and $M=N+MJ$, then $M=N$. To prove the first statement, suppose $M\ne 0$ and take a generating set $m_1,\dots ,m_s$ of minimal size. Since $MJ=M$, there are $a_i\in J$ withThe unit criterion for the Jacobson radical makes $1-a_s$ a unit. Hence $m_s$ is generated by the other $m_i$, a contradiction. Apply this result to the quotient module $M/N$ to obtain the general form.

For an injective module endomorphism $f$ of an Artinian module $M$, the descending chain condition givesfor some $n$. Given $x\in M$, write $f^n(x)=f^{n+1}(y)$; injectivity of $f^n$ gives $x=f(y)$. Thus $f$ is surjective, as asserted by Artinian modules are co-Hopfian.

Now $R$ is a semilocal ring and $\overline{V}=V/VJ$ is a finitely generated module over the right Artinian ring $\overline{R}=R/J$. A finite direct sum of copies of $\overline{R}$, and hence its quotient module $\overline{V}$, is an Artinian module. The module endomorphism $\alpha$ induces $\overline{\alpha }$ on $\overline{V}$, and the given inverse-image condition says precisely that $\ker \overline{\alpha }=0$. The preceding argument makes $\overline{\alpha }$ surjective, soThe quotient module $W=V/\alpha (V)$ is finitely generated and satisfies $WJ=W$. Applying Nakayama lemma yields $W=0$. Therefore $\alpha$ is surjective, by surjectivity from injectivity modulo the Jacobson radical.

An essential right ideal intersects every nonzero right ideal nontrivially. A regular element of a ring is a two-sided non-zero-divisor: both $cr=0$ and $rc=0$ imply $r=0$. Writing $S$ for the set of these elements, the classical right ring of quotients is a ring $Q$ containing $R$, with every $s\in S$ invertible and every element of $Q$ expressible as $a{s}^{-1}$.

Goldie theorem states that a semiprime ring has a semisimple Artinian classical right ring of quotients if and only if it is a right Goldie ring: it satisfies the ascending chain condition on right annihilators and has finite uniform dimension. In particular, every semiprime ring that is a right Noetherian ring satisfies the theorem. We prove the requested case directly using the supplied assumption about essential right ideals.

First let $c\in S$. If a nonzero right ideal $B$ had $B\cap cR=0$, the sumwould be direct. Indeed, a finite relation $b_0+c{b}_1+\cdots +c^m{b}_m=0$ gives $b_0\in B\cap cR$, hence $b_0=0$; cancellation of $c$ repeats the argument. Each $c^{j}B$ is a nonzero right ideal, so the partial sums form a strictly ascending chain. This contradicts right Noetherianity. Thus a regular principal right ideal in a right Noetherian ring is essential, and every right ideal containing $c$ is essential.

For $r\in R$ and $c\in S$, putThis is an essential right ideal. To check this, take a nonzero right ideal $B$. If $rB=0$, then $B\subseteq E$. Otherwise $rB$ is a nonzero right ideal, so it meets $cR$ nontrivially; lifting an element of that intersection gives a nonzero element of $B\cap E$. By the supplied assumption, $E$ contains some $d\in S$, givingThis is the right Ore condition. The set $S$ is multiplicatively closed, and the denominator cancellation condition holds because its elements are non-zero-divisors. Therefore Ore theorem constructs $Q$ and embeds $R$ in it.

For every right ideal $J$ of $Q$,Indeed, if $x=a{s}^{-1}\in J$, then $a=xs\in J\cap R$. Contracting an ascending chain of right ideals of $Q$ to $R$ therefore proves that $Q$ is a right Noetherian ring.

Suppose $J$ is an essential right ideal of $Q$. For a nonzero right ideal $B$ of $R$, choose $0\ne x\in J\cap BQ$. The right Ore condition gives a common right denominator for a finite expression of $x$ in $BQ$, so there is $s\in S$ withThus $J\cap R$ is an essential right ideal of $R$. It contains a regular element of a ring, which becomes a unit in $Q$, and consequently $J=Q$.

Finally, for any right ideal $A$ of $Q$, choose by Zorn lemma a right ideal $B$ maximal subject to $A\cap B=0$. Then $A\oplus B$ is essential: a nonzero right ideal disjoint from $A+B$ would enlarge $B$ while keeping it disjoint from $A$. Hence $A\oplus B=Q$. Every submodule of the right regular module has a complement, making it a semisimple module. Since it is also Noetherian, it is a finite direct sum of simple modules. It is therefore Artinian, and $Q$ is a semisimple Artinian ring. This is semisimplicity of a classical quotient from regular elements in essential ideals.

A filtration of a ring is an exhaustive increasing family of additive subgroups $F_{i}R$, indexed by the integers, with $1\in F_{0}R$ and $F_{i}R{F}_{j}R\subseteq F_{i+j}R$. A compatible filtration of a module on a right module satisfies $F_{i}M{F}_{j}R\subseteq F_{i+j}M$. The associated graded module has components $F_{i}M/F_{i-1}M$, and its action by the associated graded ring isChanging either representative changes the product only by an element of $F_{i+j-1}M$, so the action is well-defined.

The subspace filtration on $N$ is $F_{i}N=N\cap F_{i}M$. The quotient filtration is $F_i(M/N)=(F_{i}M+N)/N$. Inclusion induces an injective map $\mathrm{gr}N\to \mathrm{gr}M$, and the quotient induces a surjective map to $\mathrm{gr}(M/N)$. If $m\in F_{i}M$ maps to zero in its degree-$i$ quotient, write $m=n+m^{\prime }$ with $n\in N$ and $m^{\prime }\in F_{i-1}M$. Then $n\in N\cap F_{i}M$, so the kernel is exactly the image of $\mathrm{gr}N$. We have the short exact sequencewhich is exactness of associated graded modules for induced filtrations.

For the negative case, $F_{i}R=R$ for $i\ge 0$. Completeness means that $R\to {\underleftarrow{\lim }}_{q}R/F_{-q}R$ is an isomorphism; in particular the filtration of a ring is separated. If $x\in F_{-1}R$ and $r\in R$, then $(xr{)}^q\in F_{-q}R$. The geometric seriesconverges in the complete negative filtration and is a two-sided inverse of $1-xr$, by the finite geometric identity and continuity of multiplication. The unit criterion for the Jacobson radical now gives

Let $I$ be any right ideal. The associated graded module $\mathrm{gr}I$ for its subspace filtration is a homogeneous ideal on the right in $\mathrm{gr}R$. If $\mathrm{gr}R$ is a right Noetherian ring, choose homogeneous generators that lift to $x_1,\dots ,x_s\in I$, with degrees $d_1,\dots ,d_s\le 0$.

For $x\in I\cap F_{d}R$, cancel its degree-$d$ symbol by a sum ${\sum }_i{x}_i{a}_{i,0}$ with $a_{i,0}\in F_{d-d_i}R$. The remainder belongs to $I\cap F_{d-1}R$. Repeat the cancellation in each succeeding degree. After $q$ steps,For every $i$, the coefficient series converges to some $a_i\in R$ by completeness. Passing to the limit gives $x={\sum }_i{x}_i{a}_i$. Thus these finitely many $x_i$ generate the actual right ideal $I$; no assumption that $I$ is closed is needed. Since every right ideal is finitely generated, $R$ is right Noetherian, by complete negative filtered-graded transfer of Noetherianity.

The prime radical of a noncommutative ring is $N(R)={\bigcap }_{P}P$, with $P$ ranging over all prime ideals of a noncommutative ring. Here primeness means that for two-sided ideals $A,B$, $AB\subseteq P$ implies $A\subseteq P$ or $B\subseteq P$. A minimal prime over an ideal $I$ is a prime ideal containing $I$ with no strictly smaller prime ideal containing $I$.

The ascending chain condition on left ideals also applies to two-sided ideals. We first prove by Noetherian induction that every proper $I$ contains a finite product of prime ideals, each containing $I$. If there were counterexamples, choose a maximal one. It is not prime, so there are strictly larger two-sided ideals $A,B$ with $AB\subseteq I$. Neither is a counterexample; products of prime ideals contained in $A$ and in $B$ then concatenate to a product contained in $I$, a contradiction.

Write $P_1\cdots P_t\subseteq I\subseteq P_j$. Every prime ideal $P$ over $I$ contains at least one $P_j$, by primeness. The inclusion-minimal members of the finite list $P_j$ are therefore precisely the minimal primes over an ideal $I$: any smaller prime over $I$ would contain a member of that same list. Consequently there are finitely many. Replacing each factor $P_j$ by a minimal prime contained in it giveswith each $Q_j$ minimal over $I$. Repeated factors may be necessary; in $k[\epsilon ]/({\epsilon }^m)$ the sole minimal prime $(\epsilon )$ requires its $m$th power to reach zero.

Apply this to $I=0$. Since $N(R)\subseteq Q_j$ for every $j$,Thus the prime radical is a nilpotent ideal, as in finite minimal primes and nilpotent prime radical.

Now assume $R$ is commutative. A prime ideal $P$ is an associated prime of a module $M$ when $P={\mathrm{Ann}}_R(m)$ for some $0\ne m\in M$. Every nonzero module over $R$ has an associated prime: the ascending chain condition gives a maximal annihilator of a nonzero element, and maximal annihilator of a module element is prime.

Since the given $M$ is a Noetherian module, repeatedly choosing such a cyclic submodule in the next quotient yields a finite prime filtrationThe process terminates by the ascending chain condition. In a short exact sequence $0\to U\to M\to W\to 0$, one has $\mathrm{Ass}(M)\subseteq \mathrm{Ass}(U)\cup \mathrm{Ass}(W)$. Indeed, if $P=\mathrm{Ann}(m)$ and $Rm\cap U=0$, the image of $m$ in $W$ still has annihilator $P$. Otherwise choose $0\ne am\in U$; then $a\notin P$, and primeness gives $\mathrm{Ann}(am)=P$. As $\mathrm{Ass}(R/P_i)=\{P_i\}$, induction along the prime filtration provesIn particular there are only finitely many associated primes of a module.

Finally let $P$ be a minimal prime ideal of $R$. Its localization at a prime ideal $R_P$ has exactly one prime, its maximal ideal $P{R}_P$. The preceding nilpotence result makes this maximal ideal nilpotent. Choose $0\ne y\in R_P$ annihilated by $P{R}_P$, for example a nonzero element in its last nonzero power, or $1$ if $P{R}_P=0$. Since elements outside the maximal ideal are units, ${\mathrm{Ann}}_{R_P}(y)=P{R}_P$.

Write $y=r/s$. The element $r/1$ is nonzero and also has annihilator $P{R}_P$. Generate $P$ by $p_1,\dots ,p_{\ell }$. For each $i$, choose $u_i\notin P$ with $u_i{p}_{i}r=0$, and put $u={\prod }_i{u}_i$. Then $m=ur$ remains nonzero after localization, while $Pm=0$. If $am=0$, localization forces $a/1\in P{R}_P$, and hence $a\in P$. Therefore ${\mathrm{Ann}}_R(m)=P$. This proves that minimal primes are associated primes.

Fix a finite-dimensional nonnegative filtration of a ring giving $R$ its almost commutative algebra structure, and choose a good filtration of a module on $M$. When $\mathrm{gr}R$ is a standard graded algebra, the Hilbert-Serre theorem makes the cumulative Hilbert function $h_M(j)={\dim }_k{F}_{j}M$ eventually a polynomial. For $M\ne 0$, define the dimension of a filtered module and multiplicity of a filtered module byUse $d(0)=-\infty$ and $m(0)=0$. With positive weighted generators instead of a standard grading, the cumulative Hilbert function is eventually a quasipolynomial with a common positive leading coefficient across residue classes. Equivalently, $h_M(j)=c{j}^d+O(j^{d-1})$, and the definitions are $d(M)=d$ and $m(M)=d!c$. The common leading coefficient follows from monotonicity: interlacing consecutive residue classes forces their leading coefficients to agree. For a standard grading, multiplicity is a positive integer, since an integer-valued polynomial has an integral expansion in the binomial polynomials; weighted normalization can instead give a positive rational number.

Two good filtrations of a module for this fixed algebra filtration bound each other after fixed index shifts. The corresponding Hilbert functions therefore satisfy $h_F(j-a)\le h_G(j)\le h_F(j+b)$ for fixed $a,b$. Comparing their leading growth shows that the degree and leading coefficient agree. Thus $d(M)$ and $m(M)$ are independent of the module filtration; the fixed algebra filtration is part of the multiplicity convention.

For a submodule $N$, use its subspace filtration and the quotient filtration on $M/N$. These are good because $\mathrm{gr}R$ is Noetherian. The short exact sequence of filtered pieces givesNonzero leading coefficients are positive, soIf $d(N)=d(M/N)$, those leading coefficients add andThis is dimension and multiplicity in a filtered exact sequence.

For the Weyl algebra $A_n(k)$ in characteristic zero, Bernstein inequality for Weyl algebra modules asserts $d(M)\ge n$ for every nonzero finitely generated module $M$. Write its generators as $x_i,D_i$, with $[D_i,x_j]={\delta }_{ij}$ and all other generator commutators zero. The ordered monomials $x^{\alpha }{D}^{\beta }$ give the Bernstein filtrationTake a finite-dimensional generating subspace $V\ne 0$ of $M$ and put $M_j=A_{j}V$.

To prove faithful finite-step action of a Weyl algebra, consider $0\ne a\in A_j$ and choose a nonzero coefficient $c_{\alpha \beta }$ of a monomial of maximal total degree $d\le j$. Applying ${\prod }_i(\mathrm{ad}{D}_i{)}^{{\alpha }_i}(\mathrm{ad}{x}_i{)}^{{\beta }_i}$ to $a$ givesIndeed, these commutators differentiate the ordered coefficients: lower-degree monomials vanish, and another degree-$d$ monomial can survive only if all its exponents dominate $(\alpha ,\beta )$, which forces equality. This is scalar extraction by iterated Weyl commutators.

Expanding these iterated commutators writes $\lambda ={\sum }_{\ell }{u}_{\ell }a{v}_{\ell }$ with $u_{\ell },v_{\ell }\in A_j$. If $a$ annihilated $M_j$, every summand would annihilate $V$, contrary to $\lambda V\ne 0$. Therefore the action map is injective:Taking dimensions and comparing polynomial degrees giveswhich proves Bernstein inequality for Weyl algebra modules. The polynomial representation $k[x_1,\dots ,x_n]$ has dimension $n$, so the bound is sharp.

The associated graded ring of the Weyl algebra is a polynomial ring, so ascending filtered-graded transfer of Noetherianity makes $A_n(k)$ a left Noetherian ring. Thus every submodule of a finitely generated module is finitely generated. If $d(M)=n$, every nonzero subquotient has dimension at most $n$ by the exact-sequence formula, and at least $n$ by Bernstein inequality for Weyl algebra modules. Every such subquotient therefore has dimension $n$ and positive integral multiplicity.

In a strictly descending chain $M=M_0⊋M_1⊋\cdots$, each nonzero quotient $M_i/M_{i+1}$ consumes at least one unit of multiplicity, by dimension and multiplicity in a filtered exact sequence. Hence there are at most $m(M)$ strict steps. This proves the descending chain condition, so $M$ is Artinian. In fact this holonomic Weyl algebra module has module length at most $m(M)$, as in multiplicity bounds the length of a holonomic Weyl module.