Past exam of the statistics course of the University of Oxford / 2023 / 1 / a / Solution

Sort the observations into order statistics $x_{(1)}\le \cdots \le x_{(n)}$. Choose plotting positions $p_i=(i-1/2)/n$ and calculate the standard normal quantiles $z_i={\Phi }^{-1}(p_i)$. The normal Q-Q plot consists of the pairs $(z_i,x_{(i)})$.

If the normal distribution model is appropriate, the points should lie approximately on a straight line with positive slope, because its population quantile function isThe intercept is approximately $\mu$ and the slope approximately $\sigma$; neither needs to be known in advance. The reference need not be the identity line. One justification is the probability integral transform: for an independent normal statistical sample, $\Phi ((X_{(i)}-\mu )/\sigma )$ are uniform order statistics, whose typical values are near their plotting positions. The equality is approximate for a finite sample, particularly at the extremes. Systematic curvature, unusually heavy tails, or isolated extreme departures argue against the proposed distributional shape. A straight marginal Q-Q plot does not itself establish independence of observations.