Past exam of the year 2 of the earth sciences (geology) course of the University of Oxford / 2025 / Paper 3 / 3 / b / ii

Draw a failure envelope in the $({\sigma }_n^{\prime },\tau )$ plane. A useful brittle shear-failure approximation is the Mohr-Coulomb failure criterionwhere $c$ is cohesion, $\phi$ the internal friction angle, and ${\sigma }_n^{\prime }$ the effective compressive normal stress. A circle wholly inside the envelope is below this ideal failure threshold. Increasing the differential stress expands it until it first touches the envelope: the tangent points identify the failing plane orientations. For a linear envelope, tangency impliesWith the angle convention above, the upper tangent point is at $2\theta =90^{\circ }+\phi$. Its plane therefore makes $45^{\circ }-\phi /2$ with the maximum-compression direction; there is a conjugate plane on the other side. For $\phi =30^{\circ }$, this is $30^{\circ }$, rather than the $45^{\circ }$ plane of maximum shear stress. An existing weak fault can reactivate first, with its own lower cohesion and friction, and need not have this optimum new-fracture orientation.

For tensile brittle fracture, add a tensile strength cutoff: failure occurs when ${\sigma }_3^{\prime }\le -T_0$, where $T_0>0$. The opening fracture is approximately perpendicular to the minimum-compression direction. Real rock envelopes curve, especially at small confinement; a straight shear envelope must not be extrapolated as an exact tensile law. High confinement can instead favor distributed or ductile deformation, so merely drawing a larger circle does not establish that brittle failure is the active mechanism.^[ref]