A point-null mixture prior assigns positive mass to one parameter value and distributes the remaining mass continuously over alternatives. Posterior point mass is obtained by dividing the null component of the marginal density by the full marginal density.
Suppose independently, and compare with for fixed , using equal prior model probabilities. Put . The posterior probability of a Gaussian point null isHolding fixed while leaves the two-sided p-value unchanged but makes the null posterior probability tend to one. For , and , the p-value is about , while the null posterior is about .
The two procedures answer different model-based questions: a tail probability under the point null and a comparison of that null with a specified alternative prior distribution. The alternative's fixed prior scale spreads mass over parameter values much wider than the increasingly precise likelihood. This is the Jeffreys-Lindley phenomenon, not a conversion formula from p-values to posterior probabilities.[ref]
Bayes Factors by Robert E. Kass and Adrian E. Raftery. Section 5.2, discussion of sample size and point-null testing
Articles by others on the same topic
There are currently no matching articles.