Scalar contraction test for a Cartesian tensor ($A\prime :(RB{R}^T)=A:B\forall B⟹A\prime =RA{R}^T$)

If an array specified in each orthonormal basis has invariant Frobenius inner product with every Cartesian second-rank tensor, it transforms as such a tensor. For a component change $R$, invariance says $(R^{T}A\prime R-A):B=0$ for every matrix $B$. Nondegeneracy of the Frobenius inner product forces the difference to vanish. Testing every tensor, rather than a single selected tensor, is essential.

If an array is antisymmetric in every orthonormal basis and its contractions with every antisymmetric second-rank tensor are invariant scalars, it obeys the Cartesian second-rank tensor transformation law. The difference $D=R^{T}A\prime R-A$ is antisymmetric and orthogonal to every antisymmetric test matrix. Choosing the test matrix equal to $D$ gives $D:D=0$, hence $D=0$. The Frobenius inner product is nondegenerate on the antisymmetric subspace.

The Frobenius inner product of a symmetric matrix and an antisymmetric matrix is zero. Thus invariant contractions of an array with all symmetric second-rank tensors test only its symmetric part; an arbitrary basis-dependent antisymmetric part is invisible. A nonzero antisymmetric matrix in one basis and the zero matrix in another passes all such tests with scalar zero but is not a Cartesian second-rank tensor.