Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2017 iii Paper 125 5 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Translate the rational 2-torsion point to and clear denominators to obtain the integral Weierstrass equation of an elliptic curve. Nonsingularity requires and . The two-isogeny descent usesand its dual isogenyThese formulas extend across their missing affine points as degree-two isogenies of elliptic curves, with kernels on their respective curves; substitution gives and .
Define homomorphisms to the square-class group of a field byFor ordinary intersections with a line, the product of the three first coordinates is the square of its intercept, proving the homomorphism identity; tangent cases use the same product with multiplicities. For , direct addition gives , so . Also and , which handle inverse points and . These verify the exceptional values as well. Their kernels are and . One can check the first assertion directly: if , solving for the first coordinate of a preimage under giveswith rational corresponding ordinate. Conversely, on one has , a square. The exceptional point has a rational preimage exactly when is a square. The other kernel assertion follows identically, since the double companion curve is isomorphic to by scaling its coordinates by four and eight.
We now justify the rank factor in the square-class index formula for two-isogeny descent, rather than forgetting a torsion correction. Put , , andThe preimage of under is , soThe Mordell-Weil theorem gives , where is the rank of an abelian group of . If is a square, and , so . If it is not a square, and . Hence in both cases, and
To bound these two images, let and take a point with . If , then is a unit, so is even. If , the leading term uniquely has least valuation in the equation, so and again is even. Thus every image class has a signed square-free integer representative supported on the prime divisors of . The exceptional class also has that property. There are at most such classes. Applying the same reasoning to gives . The prime-support bound in two-isogeny descent is thereforeHere counts the distinct prime divisors of the absolute value of a nonzero integer; . The nonsingularity hypotheses exclude the otherwise undefined case .
For the unheaded practical procedure, enumerate signed square-free divisors of , and of on the companion curve. A class is represented by a point of exactly when its quartic covering in a two-isogeny descenthas a rational solution with . For , reconstruct , ; substitution verifies the equivalence. Solutions with or account for the identity class or the class of respectively. Clearing denominators allows integral with .
Test these finitely many coverings over the real numbers and local fields, especially at two and the primes dividing , to exclude impossible classes. Search the survivors for rational points, close the witnessed classes under multiplication, and use the index formula once both images are determined. Equivalently, local solubility gives a descent upper bound and independent rational points, certified for example by their canonical height of an elliptic curve pairing, give a lower bound. When the bounds coincide the rank is determined. This procedure often succeeds, but local solubility alone does not prove global solubility: a nonzero Tate–Shafarevich group can leave surviving coverings without rational points. In that case the computation gives a rigorous bound rather than a falsely certified exact rank.