A nonzero vector field has hypersurface orthogonality when it is locally normal to a family of hypersurfaces. In terms of its associated differential one-form , the Frobenius theorem gives the equivalent conditions
locally with nonzero and ; square brackets denote tensor index antisymmetrization.
All coefficients of the Reissner-Nordstrom metric are independent of , and has constant coordinate components. Thus the Lie derivative obeys : is a Killing vector field. Moreover,
Thus has hypersurface orthogonality, with the hypersurfaces providing the orthogonal family wherever this chart is regular. It is timelike where , since . Its hypersurface orthogonality also holds in a regular extension across a horizon; singular static coordinates do not invalidate the Frobenius theorem test.
For the branching from B3 to A3, apply the supplied weight projection matrix to column vectors of Dynkin labels. It sends
It is consistent with choosing the simple roots in the order , , . Their Dynkin diagram is the chain . Their coroot pairings are respectively , explaining the projection without confusing labels and Euclidean coordinates.
The seven weights in b project as
The six nonzero weights form the weight system of the SU(4) two-index antisymmetric representation of highest weight . The zero weight is the remaining singlet representation. Consequently
The eight spinor weights project as
The four weights constitute the defining fundamental representation . The other four are their negatives, forming the dual representation of highest weight . Hence
For the Young tableaux and tensors, let be the defining SU(4) representation. The singlet representation is , with the empty Young diagram and a scalar. The other three Young diagrams are columns of one, two and three boxes, representing , and :
The square brackets indicate tensor index antisymmetrization, with indices from 1 to 4. The invariant Levi-Civita symbol identifies the three-index antisymmetric tensor with a covector, , explaining .
Figure 1.
Young tableaux for the SU4 representations in the two branchings
. The empty Young diagram gives the singlet representation; columns of one, two and three boxes give , and . Increasing entries down each column display a standard Young tableau. The column determines complete tensor index antisymmetrization. Details.
The first derivative of a scalar is a covector, so
Commuting partial derivatives and the torsion-free connection give , the symmetric Hessian of a scalar field. Its next covariant derivative is
In particular, tensor index symmetrization over adds nothing: . This does not make the third index interchangeable with the first two. Applying the lower-index Ricci identity to the covector yields the requested tensor index antisymmetrization:
Parentheses and brackets include the usual averaging factors. To make the remaining symmetry explicit, let . Since the first two derivative indices are already symmetric,
The two commutator identities give and . Thus the third covariant derivatives of a scalar can also be written
The right-hand side displays exactly the obstruction to total symmetry. At a point where the scalar gradient vanishes, or where these curvature contractions vanish, the third derivative is totally symmetric.
For the final contraction use . The arbitrary-valence formula gives
The Ricci tensor of the Levi-Civita connection is symmetric, whereas the last factor is antisymmetric. Their contraction is zero, proving
No symmetry of was assumed. This double divergence of a contravariant tensor identity uses the metric-compatible connection of general relativity: zero torsion alone for an arbitrary affine connection does not guarantee a symmetric Ricci tensor and would not suffice for this final step.