Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 15 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
An -dimensional smooth manifold is a Hausdorff space with a countable topological base, equipped with a smooth atlas of homeomorphisms from open subsets onto open subsets of , whose overlap maps are smooth diffeomorphisms. The smooth structure is the maximal smooth atlas compatible with these manifold charts. Here manifolds have no boundary unless specified otherwise.
For a space with all the requested topological properties but no such atlas, take the topological tripod: three closed intervals joined at one endpoint. It is a compact connected subspace of the plane with its induced metric. A countable base of planar rational balls restricts to a countable base, the metric makes it Hausdorff, and compactness gives a finite subcover of every open cover, hence a locally finite refinement and paracompactness.
At an interior point of any arm, arbitrarily small neighborhoods are intervals. A coordinate ball in dimension at least two would remain connected after deleting its center; an interval does not. Dimension zero would make the space discrete. Thus any possible connected manifold structure would have dimension one. But a sufficiently small neighborhood of the junction, minus the junction, has three components, whereas an interval chart has two. This contradiction rules out even a topological manifold structure, and hence any smooth one.
The product smooth structure uses manifold charts . Transition maps act separately in the two coordinate blocks and are smooth with smooth inverses. Products of countable bases give a countable base, and the product remains Hausdorff. Therefore with this natural smooth structure.
Define the tangent space by point derivations: a tangent vector at is an -linear map on germs of smooth functions at , satisfying . Addition and scalar multiplication preserve this rule, so these derivations form a vector space. In coordinates , the local identityfollows by integrating the derivative of along the coordinate line segment. Derivations annihilate constants, so it gives . The coordinate derivations are independent since they evaluate the coordinate functions as . ThusFor a smooth map, define the differential of a smooth map intrinsically by . It is again linear and satisfies the derivation rule at , so it maps into . Its coordinate matrix is the Jacobian of the coordinate expression of , independently of the charts by the intrinsic definition and chain rule.
Finally, a zero differential forces each target coordinate function to have all derivatives zero on a small connected source coordinate ball mapping into one target chart. Integration on straight segments makes those functions constant there. Hence is locally constant. Each nonempty fiber is both open and closed, so connectedness gives the zero-differential constancy theorem, .