Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2011 ia Paper 1 12D Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
The fundamental theorem of calculus connects the Riemann integral with differentiation. Its first part says that for continuous , the accumulation function is continuous on and differentiable inside it, withTo prove this, boundedness of gives , proving continuity. For an interior point and a sufficiently small nonzero increment ,Its absolute value is at most , which tends to zero by continuity of at . This proves the derivative formula. The same estimate gives the appropriate one-sided endpoint derivatives.
The second part says that if is continuous on , differentiable on , and with continuous, thenIndeed , so the mean value theorem makes constant, and evaluating at the endpoints proves the formula. A useful stronger version only requires to be Riemann integrable. For a partition , the mean value theorem on each subinterval provides such thatAs the mesh tends to zero, these tagged Riemann sums converge to , proving that version too. Its integrability hypothesis must not be omitted.
An integrable integrand need not give an everywhere differentiable accumulation function. For a counterexample, let for and for . This bounded step function is Riemann integrable, butIts left and right derivatives at are zero and one. Thus need not be differentiable at every interior point. The first part of the fundamental theorem of calculus does apply at every point where the integrand is continuous.
A derivative need not have a Riemann integral. Define on all of At zero , so ; elsewhere the product rule and chain rule giveAt , this equals . Hence is unbounded on , whereas a properly Riemann integrable function on a compact interval must be bounded. The requested Riemann integral therefore need not exist, even though is differentiable everywhere. This example is an unbounded derivative obstruction to Riemann integrability; it does not contradict the theorem's version that explicitly assumes integrability of the derivative.