Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2003/iii/paper-60/3/ii/solution

Let the uniform nonzero amplitude be , so and . Write . A perturbation with Fourier wavenumber has stability matrix
The constant mode is disallowed because the conserved mean is prescribed. At the only allowed mode has eigenvalue , so homogeneous stability requires . Then every nonzero-mode trace is negative, and its determinant is smallest in sign at the smallest allowed . The exact periodic stability criterion for a conserved-field uniform amplitude is
A zero in either inequality is a marginal case requiring nonlinear analysis. The zero-amplitude branch, separately, has amplitude growth rates and nonzero conserved-field growth rates , and is strictly stable when .
For the long-domain interpretation one may take by reversing the sign of , and first consider the positive upper branch . It is homogeneously stable even though sufficiently long spatial modulations grow whenever
For , this gives
At a fixed finite the actual unstable part is smaller: it must also satisfy . For , the right side is positive for every positive upper-branch , so every such state is unstable to sufficiently long waves. The physical mechanism is feedback from the conserved field: an increase in reduces local , and the term reinforces that increase.
There are two important limits on the wording of the requested stability conclusion. First,
never vanishes at a finite regular point of this branch. At its fold the derivative is infinite. Thus a condition of zero cannot literally occur here. The meaningful contrast is that a positive-slope, homogeneously stable branch can still have a growing spatial mode.
Second, a long-wave conclusion cannot be asserted for every finite periodic domain. For example, , , , , , give and for every nonzero integer . This state is strictly stable even though . Nor does the unrestricted statement include every sign of : , , , give and , hence stability for every period and every . These examples distinguish the exact stated real-variable periodic problem from its intended positive-amplitude, long-layer interpretation.

New to topics? Read the docs here!