 Solution

The Holstein–Primakoff transformation converts a spin algebra into bosonic operators while retaining the finite physical spin Hilbert space. With $[a_n,a_m^{†}]={\delta }_{nm}$, writeThe Holstein–Primakoff occupation constraint is $0\le n_n\le 2S$. Acting on $|n⟩$, the raising matrix element is $\sqrt{n(2S-n+1)}$ and the lowering element is $\sqrt{(n+1)(2S-n)}$. Their squared difference is $2(S-n)$, reproducing $[S^{+},S^{-}]=2S^z$. Operator ordering inside the square roots is essential. For low boson occupation relative to $S$, expand them to obtain $S^{+}\simeq \sqrt{2S}a$ and $S^{-}\simeq \sqrt{2S}{a}^{†}$. Keeping quadratic terms gives the linear spin-wave approximation; higher terms describe magnon interactions. Large $S$ helps control the expansion, but a low-dimensional infrared divergence can invalidate it even at large finite $S$.

For the ferromagnet choose $H_F=-J{\sum }_n{\mathbf{S}}_n\cdot {\mathbf{S}}_{n+1}$, $J>0$, with unit lattice spacing and $\hslash =1$. Expand around the all-up state. A longitudinal bond contributes $-J{S}^2+JS(n_n+n_{n+1})$, and the transverse exchange contributes $-JS(a_n^{†}{a}_{n+1}+a_{n+1}^{†}{a}_n)$. After a Fourier transform,These are ferromagnetic magnons. The polarized vacuum is an exact ground state of the full ferromagnetic Hamiltonian: every bond is in its maximum total-spin sector, minimizing that bond energy. It therefore has no quantum zero-point reduction of its magnetization. The one-magnon dispersion is also exact, although interacting many-magnon states need not be free bosons. Rotating the polarization generates the maximum-total-spin ground-state multiplet. Selecting a definite direction in a thermodynamic symmetry-breaking description breaks $SU(2)$ to $U(1)$; the two transverse spin components form a canonical pair, producing a single quadratic type-B Goldstone boson. A small aligning field gaps it by the Zeeman energy.

At nonzero temperature the one-dimensional ferromagnet is different: its thermal magnon number contains $\int dk[e^{\beta JS{k}^2}-1{]}^{-1}$, with infrared behaviour $\int dkT/k^2$. The divergent magnetization reduction signals the absence of finite-temperature long-range order in an infinite short-range isotropic chain, consistent with the Mermin-Wagner theorem. It does not disallow the polarized zero-temperature ground states just constructed.^[ref]

For the antiferromagnet use $H_{AF}=+J{\sum }_n{\mathbf{S}}_n\cdot {\mathbf{S}}_{n+1}$, still $J>0$, on an even bipartite chain. The classical reference state alternates up and down. Rotate one sublattice through $\pi$ so that both local quantization axes point along their reference spins. In unrotated physical components, to leading order $S_A^z=S-a^{†}a$, $S_B^z=-S+b^{†}b$, $S_A^{+}\simeq \sqrt{2S}a$ and $S_B^{+}\simeq \sqrt{2S}{b}^{†}$. Choosing Fourier phases using the actual site positions givesThe reduced Brillouin zone has $M=N/2$ momenta and length $\pi$. The pair creation and annihilation terms express the fact that an antiparallel reference product state is not an eigenstate. A bosonic Bogoliubov transformation with $u_k=\cosh {\theta }_k$, $v_k=\sinh {\theta }_k$, $\tanh 2{\theta }_k=\cos k$ diagonalizes each two-mode block. With the sign convention $a_k=u_k{\alpha }_k-v_k{\beta }_{-k}^{†}$ and $b_{-k}=u_k{\beta }_{-k}-v_k{\alpha }_k^{†}$, the result isThus the harmonic antiferromagnetic modes have linear, rather than quadratic, long-wave dispersion. In an unfolded Brillouin-zone description the same result is represented by zeros at both zero and the antiferromagnetic wavevector; these are not extra independent degrees of freedom beyond the two-sublattice accounting.

The Bogoliubov vacuum has no $\alpha$ or $\beta$ excitations but contains original spin bosons, with $v_k^2=\frac{1}{2}(|\sin k{|}^{-1}-1)$. Its staggered magnetization is $m_s=S-M^{-1}{\sum }_{k\in \mathrm{RBZ}}{v}_k^2$. This quantum depletion of Néel order diverges logarithmically at small $k$ in one dimension. Linear spin-wave theory therefore does not establish a stable ordered antiferromagnetic ground state for this chain. Its nominal gapless dispersion is a result of expanding around an invalid ordered reference, not a general proof of the exact excitation spectrum. For the nearest-neighbour isotropic chain, integer-spin systems have a Haldane gap, whereas half-integer-spin systems are gapless; the spin-one-half chain in particular has fractional spin excitations rather than a simple dilute gas of ordered-state magnons. This distinction requires physics beyond the harmonic expansion, including the topological term in the continuum theory.^[ref]