Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 315 3 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Four mechanisms that can produce disequilibrium chemistry in an exoplanet atmosphere are:
- Atmospheric photochemistry. Stellar ultraviolet photons initiate reactions whose products need not follow local thermochemical equilibrium. The ozone layer on Earth is a solar-system example. Calculations for HD 189733 b predict enhanced hydrogen cyanide and acetylene from the processing of methane and ammonia; these are model examples rather than assertions of an unambiguous detection.
- Vertical transport and chemical quenching. When the eddy mixing time is shorter than the chemical relaxation time, gas retains a deeper abundance above its chemical quench level. The excess carbon monoxide in Jupiter's cool atmosphere exemplifies carbon monoxide–methane quenching. Models of HD 189733 b predict quenched methane and ammonia abundances differing from their local chemical equilibrium values. The enhancement or depletion depends on the underlying atmospheric pressure-temperature profile.
- Horizontal chemical quenching. If the atmospheric advection time is short, winds move chemically processed gas into regions with different irradiation or temperature faster than it can re-equilibrate. Transport of gas within Earth's ozone layer moves material away from its local photochemical production regions. Models of HD 209458 b show that dayside carbon monoxide-rich composition can persist into the cooler nightside instead of forming the local chemical equilibrium amount of methane.
- Condensation with sedimentation or rainout. Finite-rate cloud formation can depart from phase equilibrium, while atmospheric condensate rainout removes elements from a layer and changes its gas composition. Earth's water atmospheric cold trap limits the supply of water to the stratosphere. In HD 209458 b models, titanium-bearing condensates can settle and suppress upper-atmospheric titanium monoxide. The remaining gas can still be in local chemical equilibrium with its depleted inventory: rainout is an open-column effect, not necessarily a failure of equilibrium among all gas reactions.
The exoplanet transport and photochemical examples follow kinetic atmosphere calculations and models including horizontal transport; the condensate example is examined in cold-trap calculations.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 315 3 b iii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Four possible molecular signatures of disequilibrium chemistry in an exoplanet atmosphere, measured through an exoplanet transmission spectrum or exoplanet emission spectrum, are:
- Excess carbon monoxide in the cool upper layers, where local chemical equilibrium would place most carbon in methane. This can indicate carbon monoxide–methane quenching from deeper hot gas.
- Suppressed methane bands relative to the same cool equilibrium model, consistent with transport preventing complete carbon monoxide conversion or with photochemical loss.
- An ammonia abundance inconsistent with the local equilibrium nitrogen partition, potentially recording nitrogen–ammonia quenching. Its direction must be evaluated for the actual atmospheric pressure-temperature profile; a depleted value is possible when hotter, molecular nitrogen-rich gas is transported upward.
- Enhanced hydrogen cyanide or acetylene bands, consistent with atmospheric photochemistry acting on the transported carbon and nitrogen reservoirs.
The first two signatures can be consequences of the same process and are not independent evidence for two mechanisms. Changes in atmospheric carbon-to-oxygen ratio, atmospheric metallicity of a giant planet, exoplanet cloud coverage, and the atmospheric pressure-temperature profile can mimic abundance changes. A convincing inference compares several molecular bands with a chemically consistent equilibrium model rather than identifying one unusual band alone.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 315 3 b ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
For solar elemental abundances, take a molecular hydrogen- and helium-dominated atmosphere with atmospheric carbon-to-oxygen ratio near . The principal oxygen-bearing molecule is generally water; the carbon and nitrogen carriers depend on both temperature and pressure.
At the cool observable upper layers, methane is the expected main carbon reservoir under chemical equilibrium, with abundant water and much less carbon monoxide. At the hotter layers approaching , carbon monoxide becomes the main carbon carrier and water contains much of the oxygen not bound in it. The relevant law of mass action follows fromLower temperature favors the exothermic methane-forming direction, while increasing pressure favors the side with fewer molecules. This explains why the change of dominant carrier cannot be specified by temperature alone.
Nitrogen is distributed between molecular nitrogen and ammonia. Cooling favors ammonia, but low pressure favors molecular nitrogen; it is therefore unsafe to call ammonia dominant throughout the low-pressure region. The exact partition requires the equilibrium constant for .
Carbon dioxide is usually a minor constituent at solar composition; hydrogen cyanide and acetylene are much less abundant than the principal carbon carriers in this oxygen-rich equilibrium case. Condensation can remove refractory species where a condensation curve is crossed. The robust cool-atmosphere expectation is a molecular hydrogen–helium background with methane and water, changing toward carbon monoxide in hotter layers. Precise mixing ratios require thermodynamic data and an explicitly specified elemental inventory after rainout.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 315 3 b i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Take the logarithm to base ten and write pressure in units of , so its argument is dimensionless. Continuity of the atmospheric pressure-temperature profile givesThusIf the logarithm means , the equivalent constant is . A plot of temperature against logarithmic pressure is vertical in each isothermal region and straight between the two endpoints.
The processes can be organized by the supplied pressure ranges, although the exact boundaries require reaction rates, irradiation and mixing information:
- At , the dense gas can approach thermochemical equilibrium because collisions and reactions are relatively rapid. Deep carbon monoxide and molecular nitrogen can provide reservoirs for transported material.
- At , the falling temperature slows chemical conversion. Vertical transport can produce a chemical quench level when the chemical relaxation time crosses the eddy mixing time. Horizontal chemical quenching is also possible if dayside and nightside conditions differ. Suitable species can condense and undergo atmospheric condensate rainout where a saturation curve is crossed.
- At , slow thermal chemistry permits a quenched atmospheric mixing ratio to survive. Atmospheric photochemistry can dominate where stellar ultraviolet photons penetrate, often at still lower pressures; atmospheric haze may form from its products. Extremely high layers can also experience atmospheric escape.
The profile identifies plausible chemical regimes, but does not fix their transition pressures by itself. In particular, cloud formation depends on the species-specific condensation curve, and ultraviolet processing depends on shielding.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 315 3 b iv Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
At fixed temperature and pressure, the atmospheric carbon-to-oxygen ratio controls the division of the elemental inventory among carbon monoxide, methane, water and other molecules. For an oxygen-rich mixture, water can remain after carbon monoxide consumes its share of oxygen. Increasing the atmospheric carbon-to-oxygen ratio reduces the oxygen available for water, particularly in the hotter layers where carbon monoxide is stable. Near or above unity there, water can become strongly depleted while excess carbon feeds methane, hydrogen cyanide and acetylene. This familiar hot carbon-rich behavior should not be applied unchanged to every cool layer: at , methane formation can leave substantial water even at high atmospheric carbon-to-oxygen ratio.
Increasing the atmospheric metallicity of a giant planet at fixed elemental ratios increases the heavy-element inventory relative to molecular hydrogen and helium. Abundances of water and the major carbon-bearing molecules generally rise while molecular hydrogen remains dominant. In that regime, the law of mass action for givesWhere carbon monoxide and water each scale roughly linearly with enrichment , carbon dioxide consequently scales approximately as . This scaling changes when molecular hydrogen ceases to dominate or chemical partitioning changes. Higher enrichment can also favor carbon monoxide over methane at fixed conditions, increase mean molecular weight, and reduce the atmospheric scale height and transmission-feature amplitudes. Cloud formation and atmospheric condensate rainout alter the observable elemental ratios relative to the bulk ones.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 315 3 c Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Use the standard local chemical quench level approximation: carbon monoxide-rich gas from the hot deep region is transported upward, and conversion becomes slower as the gas enters the cooler layers. Assume that neither a faster loss process nor strong compositional fractionation removes carbon monoxide above the quench level. For an effective mixing length , the eddy mixing time is , so outrunning conversion near requiresThe usual order-of-magnitude choice is , the local atmospheric scale height at . Equal planetary mass and radius give the same gravity as Jupiter; with the same mean molecular weight, the atmospheric scale height scales linearly with temperature. To use the supplied reference, additionally adopt a representative Jovian reference temperature . ThenUsing directly with and Jovian gives and , the same order of magnitude. The supplied Jovian height is approximate and does not specify its reference temperature. Inserting unchanged for the hot gas would instead give and neglect this temperature scaling.
The pressure separation is relevant to a stronger, whole-column transport estimate. With constant gravity and mean molecular weight, the profile givesIf one additionally requires diffusion through the entire column within , a sufficient conservative condition is . It is not a necessary local quench condition: the chemical relaxation time is expected to become much longer in the cooler gas, so a longer total transit time can still preserve carbon monoxide.
The usual quench estimate is of order under the stated scale-height assumptions. A unique bound for survival to cannot be inferred from one reaction time without assumptions about its variation, the mixing length and upper-atmospheric losses.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 iii Paper 315 4 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
Three observational signatures constrain exoplanet atmospheric dynamics:
- A displaced maximum of the exoplanet thermal phase curve. If the thermal maximum precedes exoplanet secondary eclipse, the hottest region is displaced east of the substellar longitude in the usual synchronously rotating geometry. The observed offset for HD 189733 b is consistent with eastward heat advection and atmospheric superrotation; the early infrared phase-curve measurement established this effect.
- Warm nightside emission and a reduced day-night contrast. The amplitude of an exoplanet thermal phase curve constrains day-night heat redistribution. For HD 189733 b, the same observations found hemisphere brightness temperatures roughly and , supporting substantial transport to the nightside instead of purely local reradiation.
- Atmospheric line shifts after orbital motion is removed. A residual Doppler shift measures winds projected along the line of sight. A carbon monoxide signal blueshifted by roughly in HD 209458 b was interpreted as day-to-night winds in high-resolution transit spectroscopy. Rotational broadening and different limb velocities can supply additional dynamical information.
Opacity, exoplanet cloud distributions, and pressure-dependent brightness temperature affect the phase-curve interpretation. These measurements constrain circulation through atmospheric models; a single offset or line shift does not uniquely determine a three-dimensional wind field.
