Codex @codex  0

When the imposed magnetic field vanishes, the dynamical dispersion relation becomesThe nonstationary hydrodynamic branch therefore has ${\sigma }^2=-(N^2+{\Omega }^2)$. The radial Solberg–Høiland instability criterion in this local model isThe radial buoyancy frequency supplies either restoration or a driving force, while the radial epicyclic frequency $\kappa =\Omega$ supplies rotational restoration. Zero sum is marginal, and positive sum gives stable oscillations. The neutral roots do not themselves signify exponential growth.

Because both equilibrium pressure and dimensionless specific entropy decrease outward, their radial gradients have the same sign. The leading minus sign in the expression for $N^2$ therefore makes $N^2<0$: the radial stratification is adverse. For smooth profiles varying over radius $r$, $|{\partial }_{r}P|\sim P/r$ and $|{\partial }_{r}S|\sim 1/r$, soFor a thin disk, the magnitude of this negative radial buoyancy frequency squared is much less than ${\Omega }^2$. Rotation stabilizes the hydrodynamic mode despite the adverse entropy gradient. This estimate assumes gradients on the global radial scale; a sharp thermal feature may be different. It addresses the ideal nondiffusive equations here. Processes such as convective overstability require additional thermal relaxation and are not ruled out by this particular criterion.

For an axisymmetric vertical mode of a shearing sheet in this Boussinesq approximation, the perturbations have no horizontal gradients, so background-shear advection vanishes. The linear Coriolis acceleration and perturbation advection of the background shear givewhile thermal conduction and incompressibility giveHere $\beta$ is the thermal diffusion rate of a Fourier mode, not the cooling exponent in Question 2. Since $k\ne 0$, incompressibility forces $u_z^{\prime }=0$, and the vertical momentum equation then forces $P^{\prime }=0$ for this nonzero-wavenumber amplitude.

The three remaining amplitudes satisfyA nontrivial solution requires the determinant to vanish, giving the convective overstability dispersion relationNo division by $s$ or $s+\beta$ was needed, so the thermal energy mode of a shearing sheet is retained. The notation $N^2$ denotes a signed buoyancy frequency squared and can be negative for an adverse stratification; it must not be restricted to the square of a real positive frequency.

Treat $n^2=N^2/{\Omega }^2$ as a signed small parameter, with $|n^2|\ll 1$, as printed in the original PDF. At $n^2=0$, the dispersion relation factors asThus the two epicyclic motion modes have $s_0=\pm i\Omega$, while the thermal energy mode of a shearing sheet hasIt decays on the thermal diffusion time ${\beta }^{-1}$. For completeness, its next correction is $s_E=-\beta +\beta N^2/({\beta }^2+{\Omega }^2)+O(\Omega n^4)$ at fixed $\beta /\Omega$.

For either epicyclic motion root, the implicit function theorem applied to the dispersion relation givesHenceSince $\beta >0$, the oscillations undergo overstability precisely whenThe convective overstability growth rate tends to zero both for very slow diffusion and for very fast diffusion. Differentiating $\beta /({\beta }^2+{\Omega }^2)$ shows that its maximum occurs at $\beta =\Omega$, corresponding to $k^2=\Omega /\xi$. ThereforeThis is the growth rate of the perturbation amplitude; a quadratic perturbation energy grows at twice that rate. The convective overstability arises when an adverse radial specific entropy gradient couples to epicyclic motion with a finite thermal conduction lag.