Joshua Lederberg and Esther Lederberg reported replica plating in 1952. They autoclave-sterilized velveteen and secured it pile-up on a wood or cork cylinder with a metal hoop. Inverted agar plates touched the fabric lightly. Pencil marks or pin indentations fixed orientation. Complete-medium and minimal-medium replicas compared growth of biological colonies.[ref]
Escherichia coli W-1 grew on plain agar; serial T-1 bacteriophage replicas showed resistant biological colonies at matching sites. Corresponding unexposed master regions seeded repeated broth-and-plain-agar enrichment, yielding resistant isolates. Stray-bacteriophage checks were negative; resistance persisted without challenge. This supported preexisting heritable resistance. The authors noted variable transfer and moisture-dependent resolution.[ref]
The Luria-Delbrück experiment uses variation between independently grown cell cultures to investigate the timing of resistant mutations. The Lederberg replica plating experiment adds a spatial route to a recoverable source: the tested samples identify an unexposed lineage. These are complementary arguments about mutation and natural selection. Growth readouts establish a tested phenotype; identifying the responsible nucleotide sequence requires other evidence, such as DNA sequencing.
By Joshua Lederberg and Esther Lederberg; the primary byline credits Joshua Lederberg and Esther M. Lederberg. Journal of Bacteriology, volume 63, issue 3, pp. 399–406. Published in the March 1952 issue; received 31 August 1951 is a separate date.
University of Wisconsin is the byline affiliation. The Williams & Wilkins Company is the printed copyright holder; neither role establishes authorship. The journal publisher hosts the scan.
Cited passages: Full eight-page original publisher PDF text inspected; pp. 399–400, Methods: Replica plating and Figure 1 caption, complete versus minimal replica comparison; p. 401, transfer variability and Clonal occurrence of phage resistant mutants; p. 402, W-1 preparation, serial T-1 replicas, pencil or pin marks, recovery and persistence; p. 403, unexposed enrichment route and negative stray-phage checks; p. 404, Discussion distinguishes inheritance from reversible adaptation.