The expected utility hypothesis ranks uncertain outcomes by the expected value of a utility function. When these preference assumptions hold, expected utility maximization selects an admissible outcome with greatest expected utility.
With zero interest and zero risk premium, a manager whose current wealth lies between common-tangent contacts can improve expected utility maximization through a fair lottery paying those two values. The probability of is . In a Brownian filtration, replicating a bounded terminal lottery gives a nonnegative wealth martingale throughout.
An investment-consumption problem chooses portfolio holdings and consumption to maximize discounted expected utility maximization subject to a self-financing portfolio wealth equation and admissibility constraints. A Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation or utility duality with martingale deflators characterizes the optimum when the value is finite.
Let the one-period riskless gross return be , with , and let the physical up probability be . The binomial market has risk-neutral probability
Under its equivalent martingale measure , successive multipliers are independent, taking with probabilities . The risk-neutral pricing function has the extension
For every fixed positive multiplier , the function is convex when is convex. Taking a positive weighted sum preserves convexity. More explicitly, for ,
Thus the pricing extension is convex, and so are its values on the attainable stock-price grid.
The replicating portfolio in a binomial market holds
shares over the next interval. If , put and . These are the secant slopes of on and , respectively. For a convex function, the slope of a secant on a later adjacent interval is no smaller than that on the earlier interval: apply the defining convexity inequality to the middle point , then rearrange. Hence . Using backward option pricing twice gives
The two coefficients are positive and sum to one. Therefore convex-payoff delta monotonicity in a binomial market yields
In particular an up move cannot reduce the stock holding. “Increases” here means nondecreases: an affine payoff gives equality, so strict increase cannot be claimed for every convex payoff.
For the expected utility maximization problem, let be the physical measure and on terminal paths. If a path has up moves, its binomial-market probability density is
Every terminal payoff is replicable in this complete market. Buying a positive payoff with initial wealth therefore imposes the state-price budget constraint . Since the utility function is increasing, the full budget is used. Its derivative and second derivative are
Put . The first-order condition for a positive multiplier gives . The budget determines uniquely. Independence of the successive moves gives
Thus the optimal claim, as a function of the number of up moves, is
Because uniquely determines , this is also a terminal-stock-price payoff, attainable by backward option pricing and claim replication. It rewards states relatively more probable under the investor's physical measure than under the pricing measure. If , the optimum is the riskless payoff .
To prove global optimality rather than merely assert a stationary point, use the tangent inequality for the strictly concave function :
Taking physical expectations makes the last term zero for any fully financed competing claim, and nonpositive for any claim costing less. Therefore , with equality only when almost surely. Finiteness causes no difficulty on the finite binomial tree, and in every terminal state.
Use column vectors for dollar holdings and put , and . The normalized state-price density is
The vector is the market price of risk. The density defines an equivalent risk-neutral measure, under which is Brownian motion and every stock has drift . A terminal claim with finite state-price cost is priced at . Nonsingularity of and the natural Brownian market information make this a complete market; in particular the optimal nonnegative payoff below can be replicated.
Let and . Apply the Itô formula to each log price, whose return variance is :
Summing and dividing by proves the geometric stock index formula
Thus , where . The factor applies to the whole bracket. The geometric average need not itself be a self-financing portfolio; its instantaneous drift is .
If is the dollar amount invested in stock , the bank account holds . The self-financing portfolio equation is
Equivalently, gives . For share-holding notation replace by times the number of shares.
Static expected utility maximization uses the terminal budget . Since is an exogenous positive benchmark, differentiating in gives . An interior Lagrange multiplier for the budget therefore gives
For CRRA utility, write . Since , solving this marginal equation gives
Every positive lognormal moment is finite here, so the budget determines the constant uniquely. Put
Then
This is also a sufficiency condition: concavity gives , and taking expectations and using the budget inequality proves global optimality.
To find the whole optimal process, set and
Since , the moment-generating function of a normal distribution gives
Pricing the terminal payoff yields the explicit benchmark-relative power-utility portfolio wealth
Its proportional diffusion coefficient is . Since the wealth diffusion coefficient for dollar fractions is , replication requires
Using gives the requested fixed proportions:
The drift matches the self-financing portfolio equation as well. Indeed, , so the drift of from the explicit formula is
Consequently an equivalent form of the solution is
The bank account fraction is , with negative values representing borrowing. The first stock term is ordinary power-utility risk exposure, while the second hedges the random benchmark. At the logarithmic limit the benchmark term disappears, consistently with .
Write and, for a constant bank rate , define
Assume , positive portfolio wealth, unrestricted stock fractions and the usual nonnegative-wealth admissibility. Once the rate has changed, the model is the Merton consumption-investment problem with . Put . In its finite-value regime , the answer is
Here is the fraction of portfolio wealth in the stock, so the dollar holding is .
The positive-coefficient condition matters: the stated signs of and alone do not guarantee finite infinite-horizon expected utility maximization. If , the unconstrained Merton consumption-investment problem has value for and for . The remaining calculation therefore uses .