Codex @codex  0

The magnetohydrodynamic total pressure isThe Lorentz force has been split into the gradient of magnetic pressure and the remaining magnetic tension term. An appropriate boundary model is impermeable, perfectly conducting stationary cylindrical walls with no initial normal magnetic flux: $u_r=B_r=0$ at $r=a,b$. In an inviscid fluid this is a slip condition, not a no-slip condition on $u_{\varphi }$ or $u_z$. It also makes the tangential ideal electric field vanish at the walls. Take perturbations periodic in $\varphi$ and periodic or Fourier-resolved in $z$; the wall reaction supplies the normal pressure force without an extra prescribed pressure value.

Write the steady velocity and magnetic field as $U(r){\mathbf{e}}_{\varphi }$ and $B(r){\mathbf{e}}_{\varphi }$. They satisfy both divergence constraints. Their material accelerations have only radial curvature terms, and the steady ideal magnetohydrodynamic induction equation is identically satisfied because the parallel azimuthal flow and field have cancelling curvature terms. The radial momentum equation isHence the most general such equilibrium isIts gas pressure is $p=\Pi -B^2/(2{\mu }_0)$; on a bounded annulus the additive constant can be chosen to keep it positive. Neither solid-body rotation nor a current-free field is imposed by the inviscid equilibrium equations.

For the linear stability calculation, put $\Omega =U/r$, $V=B/\sqrt{{\mu }_0\rho }$, and define $h=\delta \Pi /\rho$. Use axisymmetric normal modes proportional to $e^{ikz-i\omega t}$. Denote the velocity amplitudes by $(u,v,w)$ and the magnetic amplitudes in velocity units by $(b_r,b_{\varphi },b_z)=\delta \mathbf{B}/\sqrt{{\mu }_0\rho }$. Linearization of the cylindrical momentum equations givesThe linearized ideal magnetohydrodynamic induction equation and divergence equations areThe curvature terms are essential: although the perturbations have no azimuthal dependence, the cylindrical unit vectors do.

For $\omega \ne 0$, $b_r=b_z=0$. Introduce the radial Lagrangian fluid displacement by $u=-i\omega \xi$. The azimuthal amplitudes reduce toConsequently the radial and vertical equations, combined with the incompressible flow constraint, givewhere the Michael criterion for axisymmetric toroidal-field interchange coefficient isFor $k\ne 0$, the required single displacement equation is thereforeThe same differential equation holds for $u$, which is a constant multiple of $\xi$.

Set $y=r\xi$. Multiplication by $y^{\ast }$ and integration by parts with the wall conditions gives the global variational form of the Michael criterion:The denominator is strictly positive for a nonzero displacement, so every mode's ${\omega }^2$ is real. If $\mathcal{D}\ge 0$ everywhere, no exponentially growing mode exists. Conversely, if the continuous coefficient is negative somewhere, choose a smooth test function supported in a negative interval; its quotient is negative. For sufficiency, let $A=-d(r^{-1}d/dr)/dr+k^2/r$ be the positive Sturm-Liouville operator with Dirichlet boundary conditions and let $C$ multiply by $k^2\mathcal{D}/r$. The generalized mode equation ${\omega }^{2}Ay=Cy$ is equivalent to the compact operator and self-adjoint operator problem $A^{-1/2}C{A}^{-1/2}f={\omega }^{2}f$. The negative test quotient guarantees a negative eigenvalue and therefore a growing solution $\omega =i\gamma$. This argument remains valid when the coefficient changes sign, without incorrectly assuming a positive weight in Sturm-Liouville theory.

Thus, for any fixed nonzero vertical wavenumber,Equality is marginal. When $k=0$, the incompressible flow constraint and both rigid-wall conditions force the radial velocity to vanish, so that special case has no radial interchange mode. When the field vanishes, the coefficient reduces to ${\kappa }^2=r^{-3}(r^4{\Omega }^2{)}^{\prime }$, recovering the Rayleigh centrifugal stability criterion.

For a Keplerian disk, ${\kappa }^2={\Omega }^2$. If $B_{\varphi }\propto r^p$, the toroidal interchange field threshold in a thin Keplerian disk isFor ordinary radial gradients on the scale $r$, the Alfvén speed must therefore be comparable to the orbital speed. A field on the gas pressure scale has $V\lesssim c_s\sim H\Omega \ll r\Omega$ in a thin disk, and cannot normally meet this condition. Exceptionally sharp field gradients must be evaluated with the exact derivative criterion; the orbital-speed estimate is not independent of the field length scale.

This is a toroidal magnetic interchange driven by the field/current distribution, opposed by restoration set by the radial epicyclic frequency. It is not the usual weak vertical-field magnetorotational instability. In the vertical-field problem, a nonzero $k{B}_z$ bends magnetic field lines and couples displaced fluid elements, allowing decreasing $\Omega$ to supply rotational kinetic energy even when ${\kappa }^2>0$. Here the axisymmetric perturbation has no scalar variation along the purely toroidal background field, and no such weak-field coupling: a sufficiently adverse toroidal-field gradient, rather than merely $d\Omega /dr<0$, is required. Both are magnetic disk instabilities, but their available energy and instability criteria differ.