Codex @codex  0

The covariant free-photon oscillator construction uses four polarization vectors and $[a^{\lambda },a^{{\lambda }^{\prime }†}]=-{\eta }^{\lambda {\lambda }^{\prime }}$. Starting from a positive Fock vacuum, it induces an indefinite Hermitian form on the multiparticle state space: the temporal oscillator has negative norm while the three spatial oscillators have positive norm. It is therefore not the physical positive Hilbert space. The Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient selects a positive physical space with two transverse photon polarizations. Continuum momentum oscillators and their states are understood after smearing or finite-volume regularization.

Vary the Maxwell Lagrangian with respect to $A_{\nu }$. Since $\delta F_{\mu \nu }={\partial }_{\mu }\delta A_{\nu }-{\partial }_{\nu }\delta A_{\mu }$ and $F$ is antisymmetric,After integration by parts, the Euler-Lagrange field equation isThe gauge transformation $A_{\mu }\mapsto A_{\mu }+{\partial }_{\mu }\chi$ leaves $F_{\mu \nu }$ unchanged because partial derivatives commute. This gauge invariance means that potentials related in this way represent the same electromagnetic field; all four potential components are not independent physical photon degrees of freedom. In particular, the ungauged kinetic operator is singular and its temporal canonical momentum vanishes.

Choose the Lorenz gauge ${\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }=0$. The field equation then becomes $\boxed{\square A_{\mu }=0}$. Residual gauge transformations with $\square \chi =0$ preserve this condition. The correctly named Lorenz gauge condition concerns the divergence of the potential; Lorentz covariance is the separate transformation property of the equations.

For the alternative quadratic Lagrangian density, direct differentiation givesso its Euler-Lagrange field equation is also $\square A^{\nu }=0$. This density is the Feynman-gauge Maxwell kinetic density after a boundary-term subtraction. Indeed, with $D={\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }$,The divergence identity follows by expanding ${\partial }_{\mu }{K}^{\mu }$ and commuting its second derivatives. The quadratic density alone describes four wave equations; the gauge constraint must still be incorporated in the physical states. It is not an unconstrained four-positive-polarization replacement for Maxwell equations.

Using this specified boundary-term convention, the canonical momentum conjugate to $A_{\nu }$ isThe canonical commutation relations are thereforewith field-field and momentum-momentum brackets zero. Equivalently $[A_{\mu },{\dot{A}}_{\nu }]=-i{g}_{\mu \nu }{\delta }^3$. The temporal component has the opposite sign to the spatial components; replacing the metric by a positive Euclidean one would destroy these brackets.

The wave equation gives massless frequencies ${\omega }_{\mathbf{k}}=|\mathbf{k}|$. Hermiticity pairs its positive- and negative-frequency solutions, so the Heisenberg picture field has the expansionThis is a real field expansion for each component, but its oscillator metric is indefinite. The assumed brackets, with the dagger's vector index restored, areThey verify the photon oscillator completeness and canonical brackets. Inserting ${\Pi }^{\nu }=-{\dot{A}}^{\nu }$ gives at equal timesThe other brackets cancel between the two frequency contributions. Thus both the $2\omega$ normalization and the sign $-g_{\mu \nu }$ are needed.

The Gupta-Bleuler formalism imposes the Lorenz gauge condition weakly on states:Here $(+)$ is the annihilation, positive-frequency part. Setting the full divergence to zero as an operator would conflict with the four-component canonical commutation relations. The subsidiary condition instead selects a physical pre-space inside the covariant photon Fock space, followed by a quotient of its null states.

Apply it to $|k,ϵ⟩={ϵ}^{\nu }{a}_{\nu }^{†}(k)|0⟩$. Commuting $k^{\mu }{a}_{\mu }$ through the creator gives a multiple of $-k_{\nu }{ϵ}^{\nu }|0⟩$. Hence the allowed photon polarization vectors obeyTake $k=(\omega ,0,0,\omega )$. The complete solution iswith complex coefficients. The last two vectors are transverse linear photon polarizations, and $(0,1,\pm i,0)/\sqrt{2}$ gives the two circular photon polarizations. The first vector is $k/\omega$, the allowed temporal-longitudinal combination. A purely spatial longitudinal vector $(0,0,0,1)$ by itself does not satisfy the subsidiary condition.

The oscillator brackets give, apart from the positive continuum normalization factor,Momentum eigenstates are distributionally normalized; a box or a wave packet makes the norm statement literal. The allowed longitudinal combination has zero norm because $k^2=0$, and it is orthogonal to every constrained state since $k\cdot ϵ=0$. It also gives a pure-gauge field wave: the field strength of $A_{\mu }\propto k_{\mu }{e}^{-ik\cdot x}$ vanishes. Thus $ϵ$ and $ϵ+ck$ represent the same physical photon polarization. The Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient removes this null direction and leaves two positive-norm transverse photon photon polarizations. The negative-norm temporal oscillator of the unrestricted space is not an extra physical state. This is the transverse one-photon physical quotient.

Finally verify the two-photon fermion Ward identity directly for electron-positron annihilation into two photons. Define $D(r)=/r-m$ and the reduced Dirac propagatorThe equality follows from the Clifford algebra, since $(/r-m)(/r+m)=(r^2-m^2)I$. The incoming Dirac spinors obey $D(p)u(p)=0$ and $\overline{v}(q)(/q+m)=0$. On replacing one inserted photon polarization vector by $k$, the spinor factor in the two diagrams isAt the electron end, $/k=D(p)-D(p-k)$, soFor the other diagram, four-momentum conservation gives $p-k^{\prime }=k-q$. HenceThe two contributions therefore cancel exactly:Individual diagrams need not vanish; their sum implements the Ward identity. Linearity then gives invariance under $ϵ\mapsto ϵ+ck$, as required by gauge invariance. In particular, the null longitudinal photon polarization proportional to $k$ has zero physical production amplitude. Physical scattering produces the transverse photon classes, not an independent longitudinal massless photon.

Use $g_{\mu \nu }=\mathrm{diag}(1,-1,-1,-1)$ throughout. Vary the Maxwell action with respect to the electromagnetic four-potential. Antisymmetry of the electromagnetic field tensor gives $\delta \mathcal{L}=-F^{\mu \nu }{\partial }_{\mu }\delta A_{\nu }$. After integration by parts, the Euler-Lagrange field equation isA gauge transformation $A_{\mu }\mapsto A_{\mu }+{\partial }_{\mu }\chi$ leaves $F_{\mu \nu }$ unchanged because partial derivatives commute. It therefore leaves the Maxwell action and observable electromagnetic fields unchanged: different potentials represent the same physical field. This redundancy matters for canonical quantization: before gauge fixing, the momentum conjugate to $A_0$ vanishes and the four potential components cannot be treated as four independent physical oscillators.

Choose the Lorenz gauge $D={\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }=0$, attainable by solving $\square \chi =-D$ with suitable boundary data. The Euler-Lagrange field equation then reduces toResidual Lorenz gauge symmetry consists of transformations with $\square \chi =0$. The gauge condition and this residual redundancy ultimately leave two transverse polarizations of a free photon.

For the specified kinetic density ${\mathcal{L}}_C=-\frac{1}{2}{\partial }_{\mu }{A}_{\nu }{\partial }^{\mu }{A}^{\nu }$, one has $\partial {\mathcal{L}}_C/\partial ({\partial }_{\mu }{A}_{\nu })=-{\partial }^{\mu }{A}^{\nu }$. Its Euler-Lagrange field equation is therefore $-\square A^{\nu }=0$. This density is the Feynman-gauge Maxwell kinetic density after a boundary-term subtraction, sinceThe divergence follows by expanding both sides and commuting the second derivatives. Thus the wave equation follows from a Feynman gauge action; the additional physical-state condition will implement the Lorenz gauge. One must not impose $D=0$ inside the original action before varying it.

Take the covariant components $A_{\nu }$ as canonical coordinates. The canonical momentum computed from ${\mathcal{L}}_C$ isThe equal-time canonical Poisson brackets are $\{A_{\mu }(t,\mathbf{x}),{\Pi }^{\nu }(t,\mathbf{y})\}={\delta }_{\mu }{}^{\nu }{\delta }^3(\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{y})$, with coordinate-coordinate and momentum-momentum brackets zero. Applying canonical quantization givesIn particular $[A_{\mu },{\dot{A}}_{\nu }]=-i{g}_{\mu \nu }{\delta }^3$. The negative temporal sign is the source of the indefinite state-space norm in covariant photon quantization.

The spatial Fourier transform of the wave equation gives an oscillator of frequency $\omega =|\mathbf{k}|$ for each component. The Hermitian adjoint condition on the electromagnetic four-potential then yields the mode expansion of a free fieldThese are massless on shell modes. Consistently with the preceding equal-time canonical commutation relation,The normalization is the same as for the scalar modes, with $-g_{\mu \nu }$ replacing the species identity matrix.

Gupta-Bleuler quantization starts with the Fock vacuum annihilated by every $a_{\mu }$ and imposes only the annihilation, or positive-frequency part of a quantum field, of the Lorenz gauge condition:Imposing the entire Hermitian field divergence as a strong operator identity would be incompatible with the four-component canonical commutation relation. The weaker condition suffices: between two physical states its positive-frequency part vanishes on the ket, and its negative-frequency part vanishes on the bra. Hence $⟨{\mathrm{phys}}^{\prime }|{\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }|\mathrm{phys}⟩=0$.

For a one-photon state $|\mathbf{k},ϵ⟩={ϵ}^{\nu }{a}_{\nu }^{†}(\mathbf{k})|0⟩$, commuting the constraint through the creator givesThus the allowed photon polarization vectors satisfy $\boxed{k\cdot ϵ=0}$. Their state inner product, with the common momentum-normalization factor suppressed, is $⟨{ϵ}^{\prime }|ϵ⟩=-{ϵ}^{\prime \ast }\cdot ϵ$. Momentum eigenstates are delta-normalized; the same statements hold with finite norms for normalizable wave packets.

Rotate the spatial axes so that $k=\omega (1,0,0,1)$. The constraint is ${ϵ}^0={ϵ}^3$, so the complete allowed family isThe first vector is the allowed longitudinal gauge polarization, proportional to the null four-momentum $k$. Its state has zero norm because $k^2=0$; it is also orthogonal to every constrained state because $k\cdot ϵ=0$. A purely spatial vector $(0,0,0,1)$ alone is not an allowed physical polarization: its time component must accompany it to satisfy the constraint. The other two vectors are transverse polarizations, perpendicular to $\mathbf{k}$, with positive unit norms. For the displayed family,The timelike negative-norm excitation has been excluded by the constraint, and the remaining form is positive semidefinite. The Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient identifies $ϵ$ and $ϵ+\lambda k$, removing the null direction. It leaves exactly two transverse physical photon polarizations with a positive inner product; their bosonic Fock space is the physical photon state space.

Finally use Feynman slash notation, $/a={\gamma }^{\mu }{a}_{\mu }$, and impose four-momentum conservation $p+q=k+k^{\prime }$. The external Dirac spinors obeySet $r=p-k$ and $r^{\prime }=p-k^{\prime }$. Replacing $ϵ$ by $k$ in the first term of the electron-positron annihilation into two photons amplitude, the rightmost contracted vertex obeysSince the Clifford algebra implies $(/r+m)(/r-m)=(r^2-m^2)I_4$, that term becomesFor the second term, four-momentum conservation gives $k=q+r^{\prime }$. The contracted vertex is now adjacent to the outgoing positron spinor on the left, soConsequentlyThe two terms cancel, proving the two-photon fermion Ward identityExchanging the two photon labels proves the same result for ${ϵ}^{\prime }=k^{\prime }$. By linearity the amplitude is invariant under $ϵ\mapsto ϵ+\lambda k$ on either external photon leg. Therefore the null longitudinal gauge polarization has zero production amplitude: physical scattering produces only the two transverse photon polarizations. This cancellation also shows why both photon orderings in the tree-level Feynman diagrams are essential; either term alone fails the Ward identity.

In quantum electrodynamics, gauge invariance connects local phase freedom, electric-charge conservation and the restrictions on photon interactions. For definiteness takeThe gauge transformationhas $D_{\mu }\psi \mapsto e^{-ie\alpha }{D}_{\mu }\psi$: the derivative of the local phase cancels the added gauge potential. Also $F_{\mu \nu }$ is unchanged because mixed partial derivatives commute. Consequently every term in the Lagrangian density is invariant. This derives the minimal electromagnetic coupling of a Dirac field, including the interaction $-e\bar{\psi }{\gamma }^{\mu }\psi A_{\mu }$. A fermion mass is compatible with the symmetry, whereas a local Proca photon mass $m_{\gamma }^2{A}_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }/2$ is not.

The classical Maxwell equations are ${\partial }_{\mu }{F}^{\mu \nu }=j^{\nu }$, with $j^{\nu }=e\bar{\psi }{\gamma }^{\nu }\psi$. Taking a divergence gives ${\partial }_{\nu }{j}^{\nu }=0$ because $F^{\mu \nu }$ is antisymmetric. The same conservation law follows directly from the charged Dirac equation and its adjoint. For vanishing flux at spatial infinity, $Q=\int d^{3}x{j}^0$ is conserved. Gauss law identifies this charge with the electric flux through a surrounding surface. Particle-antiparticle creation is allowed, but its net electric charge is zero.

Local gauge invariance is also a redundancy in the potentials, rather than an extra propagating degree of freedom. The canonical momentum of $A_0$ vanishes, and its field equation enforces the Gauss law constraint in gauge theory, $\nabla \cdot \mathbf{E}=j^0$. After imposing the constraint and quotienting gauge freedom, a massless photon has two transverse physical polarizations. Gauge transformations vanishing at the boundary identify equivalent descriptions; constant phase transformations at infinity can act on charged states and generate their conserved charge. This distinction explains why gauge redundancy and electric charge are compatible.

In perturbative QED, the quadratic photon operator cannot be inverted before gauge fixing. Adding $-({\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }{)}^2/(2\xi )$ gives the covariant gauge propagatorThis propagator contains longitudinal and timelike components, but these are not external physical photon states. A Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient, or the equivalent BRST construction, removes them. In linear Lorenz gauge, $\delta ({\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu })=\square \alpha$, so the Faddeev-Popov determinant is independent of $A_{\mu }$ and the Faddeev-Popov ghost fields decouple. This last statement concerns the linear gauge; Abelian gauge groups alone do not guarantee decoupling in a nonlinear gauge condition.

At the quantum level, the vector symmetry gives a Ward identity. One way to obtain it is to change variables by a localized phase in a time-ordered correlation function containing $\psi (y)$ and $\bar{\psi }(z)$. The action variation becomes a current divergence; the two field insertions contribute opposite contact terms, since their charges are opposite. Fourier transformation turns the divergence into the photon momentum, and amputating the external fermion propagators turns the two contact terms into the difference of their inverse propagators. With the charge removed from the proper vertex and the overall propagator factor $i$ removed from its inverse, the result is the proper-vertex Ward-Takahashi identity in QEDAt tree level this is simply $k_{\mu }{\gamma }^{\mu }=(/p+/k-m)-(/p-m)$. Between on-shell external spinors, the inverse propagators vanish, so the full physical scattering amplitude satisfies $k_{\mu }{\mathcal{M}}^{\mu }=0$. Therefore replacing a photon polarization vector by ${\epsilon }_{\mu }+c{k}_{\mu }$ leaves the amplitude unchanged. The identity applies to the complete required sum of diagrams, not necessarily each diagram separately. It also ensures cancellation of the gauge parameter from physical observables when all terms at the chosen perturbative order are included.

For the photon two-point function, the Ward identity implies transverse photon vacuum polarization:Thus ultraviolet subtraction renormalizes the gauge-invariant kinetic term, rather than requiring a local photon-mass counterterm. Perturbative unbroken QED retains a massless photon. Transversality by itself would not exclude a nonlocal massless pole in a different theory; the assertion here includes the perturbative QED setting.

Taking $k\to 0$ in the proper-vertex identity gives ${\Gamma }^{\mu }(p,p)=\partial S^{-1}(p)/\partial p_{\mu }$. Matching the divergent coefficients of the derivative and vertex terms yields the Ward identity for QED renormalization constants, $Z_1=Z_2$, in a gauge-preserving prescription. If ${\psi }_0=\sqrt{Z_2}\psi$ and $A_0=\sqrt{Z_3}A$, comparison of the interaction coefficients givesHence charge renormalization is fixed by photon wave-function renormalization. Gauge invariance constrains counterterms and relates renormalizations; it does not make the electric charge independent of scale.

The Soft photon theorem gives another physical manifestation. Attaching a photon of small momentum $k$ to the external charged legs gives the leading factorwhere $Q_i$ is charge in units of $e$ and ${\eta }_i=+1$ for outgoing and $-1$ for incoming legs. Replacing $\epsilon$ by $k$ makes this factor proportional to ${\sum }_i{\eta }_i{Q}_i$, which vanishes by electric charge conservation. Massless photons also cause infrared divergences; physical inclusive measurements combine unresolved real emission with virtual corrections, rather than treating either contribution alone as an observable.

Finally, the vector gauge symmetry of a Dirac fermion in QED is anomaly-free, so it can be maintained by regularization and renormalization. This must be distinguished from the axial current: its divergence has explicit mass terms, as in Question 3, and can additionally have a quantum chiral anomaly. Conservation of the gauge current does not imply axial-current conservation. The resulting picture is that gauge invariance simultaneously organizes the physical photon states, enforces electric-charge conservation and ties together amplitudes and ultraviolet subtractions.

The oscillator commutator givesThe temporal mode $\lambda =0$ has negative norm. More precisely, the nonzero wave packet $|f,0⟩=\int d^{3}pf(\mathbf{p})a_{\mathbf{p}}^{0†}|0⟩/(2\pi {)}^3$ has norm $-\int d^{3}p|f(\mathbf{p}){|}^2/(2\pi {)}^3<0$. The difficulty is an indefinite Hermitian form, not the divergent normalization of an unsmeared momentum eigenstate. The covariant photon Fock space is therefore not a positive physical Hilbert space.

Gupta-Bleuler quantization imposes only the annihilation, or positive-frequency part of a quantum field, of the divergence:A strong operator identity $\partial \cdot A=0$ is incompatible with the four unconstrained canonical commutation relations; in the literal momentum convention it would set ${\pi }^0=0$. The weaker condition instead implies $⟨\Phi |\partial \cdot A|\Psi ⟩=0$ between physical states: the positive-frequency part annihilates the ket, and its adjoint annihilates the bra.

For a nonzero momentum choose upper-index polarization vectorswhere ${\mathbf{e}}_1,{\mathbf{e}}_2$ are an orthonormal pair perpendicular to $\mathbf{p}$. Labels 1 and 2 have transverse polarization, label 3 has spatial longitudinal polarization, and label 0 has timelike photon polarization. With $p^0=|\mathbf{p}|=\omega$, the divergence of the annihilation part is proportional to $-i\omega (a_{\mathbf{p}}^0-a_{\mathbf{p}}^3)$. The physical condition is thereforeFor a one-mode state $|\chi ⟩={\sum }_{\lambda }{c}_{\lambda }{a}^{\lambda †}|0⟩$, the condition reads $-c_0-c_3=0$. ThusThe last direction has zero norm and is orthogonal to every constrained state. Its field wavefunction is proportional to ${ϵ}^{\mu 0}+{ϵ}^{\mu 3}=p^{\mu }/\omega$, hence it is a pure gauge symmetry direction. A purely longitudinal creator $a^{3†}$ alone is not physical, despite having positive norm.

For the multiparticle sketch, put $C=a^0-a^3$ and $C^{†}=a^{0†}-a^{3†}$. The commutator $[C,C^{†}]=0$ allows polynomials in $C^{†}$ times transverse creator states to obey the constraint. Conversely, on creator polynomials the constraint is $-{\partial }_{a^{0†}}-{\partial }_{a^{3†}}$, so these are all the constrained polynomials. Every term containing $C^{†}$ is orthogonal to every constrained bra, since $⟨\Phi |C^{†}=⟨C\Phi |=0$. Quotienting those null vectors and completing the remaining positive space is the Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient. It givesThe one-particle instance is the transverse one-photon physical quotient.

A symmetry of a classical field theory maps solutions to solutions; for the Noether theorem we require a continuous variational symmetry of the action, allowing its density to change by a total divergence. This is stronger than simply observing an accidental symmetry of one solution. Consider first-derivative fields ${\varphi }_a$ and defineThe Euler-Lagrange field equations are $E_a=0$. For a fixed-coordinate variation ${\delta }_0{\varphi }_a=\epsilon Q_a$, the product rule gives the off-shell identityThis identity is the proof's essential integration-by-parts step.

For a general spacetime symmetry write $x^{\prime \mu }=x^{\mu }+\epsilon {\xi }^{\mu }$ and ${\varphi }_a^{\prime }(x^{\prime })={\varphi }_a(x)+\epsilon {\Delta }_a$. At a fixed point $Q_a={\Delta }_a-{\xi }^{\nu }{\partial }_{\nu }{\varphi }_a$, while the volume-element variation contributes ${\partial }_{\mu }(\mathcal{L}{\xi }^{\mu })$. Suppose action invariance takes the formCombining with the preceding identity provesThis is the Noether current for a spacetime symmetry. It also covers internal symmetries, for which $\xi =0$. A constant parameter corresponds to one Noether current; several independent parameters give several currents. Integrating the continuity equation givesThus the Noether charge is conserved when the fields have suitable falloff or no flux through the spatial boundary. These are classical identities; quantum symmetries may additionally require absence of an quantum anomaly.

Translations conserve energy and momentum. If the density has no explicit coordinate dependence, take the active fixed-coordinate variation $Q_a={\partial }_{\nu }{\varphi }_a$ for translation in direction $\nu$. Then ${\delta }_0\mathcal{L}/\epsilon ={\partial }_{\nu }\mathcal{L}$, and the internal-form proof with $K^{\mu }={\delta }^{\mu }{}_{\nu }\mathcal{L}$ gives the canonical energy-momentum tensorIts four spatial integrals are the conserved energy and momentum. For a real scalar field with density $\frac{1}{2}(\partial \varphi {)}^2-V(\varphi )$ this becomes $T^{\mu \nu }={\partial }^{\mu }\varphi {\partial }^{\nu }\varphi -{\eta }^{\mu \nu }\mathcal{L}$. Direct differentiation gives ${\partial }_{\mu }{T}^{\mu \nu }=(\square \varphi +V^{\prime }(\varphi )){\partial }^{\nu }\varphi$, which vanishes by the field equation.

Lorentz symmetry conserves angular momentum and boost charges. For that scalar example, $T^{\mu \nu }$ is symmetric, so the Lorentz transformation currents can be writtenTheir divergence is $T^{\rho \sigma }-T^{\sigma \rho }=0$. Spatial pairs give angular momentum, and time-space pairs give the conserved boost charges. For a spinor field or a vector field, the intrinsic field variation supplies an additional spin current; equivalently the Belinfante-Rosenfeld stress-energy tensor combines spin and orbital pieces into a symmetric stress tensor. The nonunitarity of the finite component Spinor representation of the Lorentz group does not obstruct conservation of these physical spacetime charges.

Global phase symmetry conserves particle charge. For a complex scalar field with density ${\partial }_{\mu }{\Phi }^{\ast }{\partial }^{\mu }\Phi -V({\Phi }^{\ast }\Phi )$, the constant transformation $\Phi \mapsto e^{-i\alpha }\Phi$ leaves the density invariant. Using $Q_{\Phi }=-i\Phi$ and $Q_{{\Phi }^{\ast }}=i{\Phi }^{\ast }$ gives the Noether currentFor a Dirac field, the corresponding variations $Q_{\psi }=-i\psi$, $Q_{\bar{\psi }}=i\bar{\psi }$ yield instead $j^{\mu }=\bar{\psi }{\gamma }^{\mu }\psi$, the Dirac current. Its divergence vanishes by the Dirac equation and adjoint Dirac equation. The Yukawa interaction of part 2 also preserves this phase symmetry, because each bilinear has one $\psi$ and one $\bar{\psi }$. Thus it preserves fermion number and forbids annihilation of two fermions into a single scalar. These currents express charge or particle-minus-antiparticle-number conservation, rather than conservation of total particle count in arbitrary interacting processes.

A global symmetry in field theory uses a spacetime-independent parameter and ordinarily relates physically distinct configurations. A gauge symmetry instead has arbitrary local parameters and represents redundancy in the description. For example, the Maxwell field is unchanged physically by $A_{\mu }\mapsto A_{\mu }+{\partial }_{\mu }\alpha (x)$: its electromagnetic field tensor is unchanged. For charged matter use $D_{\mu }={\partial }_{\mu }+iq{A}_{\mu }$ together with $\psi \mapsto e^{-iq\alpha (x)}\psi$. Differentiating shows $D_{\mu }^{\prime }{\psi }^{\prime }=e^{-iq\alpha }{D}_{\mu }\psi$, so the coupled Dirac action is locally gauge invariant. A local phase applied to free matter alone produces extra derivatives of $\alpha$ and is not an invariance; the compensating gauge field is necessary.

Local arbitrariness gives identities among field equations, rather than an independent physical charge for every function $\alpha$. In the pure Maxwell field, action invariance under a compactly supported $\alpha$ impliesThus ${\partial }_{\nu }{E}^{\nu }=0$ holds off shell, directly because $F^{\mu \nu }$ is antisymmetric. This exemplifies the Noether second theorem. Gauge fixing and the Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient remove redundant photon components; they do not remove a physical global charge. Gauge transformations that are nontrivial at a boundary can carry boundary charges, so the redundancy statement concerns transformations satisfying the chosen boundary conditions. Finally, discrete symmetries such as the sign reversal of a real scalar or parity symmetry in quantum field theory can be important without furnishing a continuous-parameter Noether current.

Use the free Maxwell Lagrangian $\mathcal{L}=-F_{\mu \nu }{F}^{\mu \nu }/4$ in mostly-minus signature. In terms of the spatial electromagnetic four-potential, define $\mathbf{E}=-\dot{\mathbf{A}}-\nabla A_0$ and $\mathbf{B}=\nabla \times \mathbf{A}$. Thus $\mathcal{L}=({\mathbf{E}}^2-{\mathbf{B}}^2)/2$. Taking the Cartesian components of $\mathbf{A}$ as coordinates gives the canonical momentaThis sign convention treats $A_i$ here as Cartesian spatial-vector labels; it is not a claim that covariant and contravariant four-vector components coincide.

The temporal momentum vanishes because no ${\dot{A}}_0$ occurs. This is the primary momentum constraint of the electromagnetic potential, so one cannot treat all four components as independent unconstrained oscillators. The Legendre transformation for the spatial components gives ${\Pi }_i{\dot{A}}_i-\mathcal{L}=({\mathbf{\Pi }}^2+{\mathbf{B}}^2)/2-\mathbf{\Pi }\cdot \nabla A_0$. After integration by parts, the Hamiltonian isSurface terms vanish for decaying fields or the corresponding regulated boundary conditions. The total constrained Hamiltonian also contains an arbitrary multiplier of ${\Pi }^0$. Preserving ${\Pi }^0=0$ under time evolution requireswhich is the Gauss law constraint in gauge theory. Both constraints are first-class constraints; they express the gauge invariance $\mathbf{A}\mapsto \mathbf{A}+\nabla \alpha$, $A_0\mapsto A_0-\dot{\alpha }$. The electric and magnetic fields are unchanged, so different gauge potentials need not describe different physical states.

One consistent canonical quantization of the electromagnetic field first reduces this redundancy. Choose Coulomb gauge $\nabla \cdot \mathbf{A}=0$. In the absence of charges, the Gauss law constraint in gauge theory gives ${\nabla }^2{A}_0=0$; decay at infinity sets $A_0=0$. Residual spatially constant gauge parameters do not change $\mathbf{A}$. The remaining variables are the transverse pairs ${\mathbf{A}}^T,{\mathbf{\Pi }}^T={\dot{\mathbf{A}}}^T$. Their gauge reduction of the Maxwell Hamiltonian isThe two transverse coordinates for each nonzero momentum are the physical degrees of freedom. Treating the constraints as operator identities while retaining unconstrained componentwise commutators would be inconsistent: differentiating $[A_i^T,{\Pi }_j^T]=i{\delta }_{ij}{\delta }^3$ would give a nonzero right side even though ${\partial }_i{A}_i^T=0$.

The reduced Dirac bracket, promoted to a canonical commutation relation, instead gives the transverse equal-time commutator:whereIndeed the spatial transverse projector of a vector field $P_{ij}^T={\delta }_{ij}-k_i{k}_j/|\mathbf{k}{|}^2$ is symmetric, has $P^T\mathbf{k}=0$ and $(P^T{)}^2=P^T$. Projecting both entries of the unconstrained canonical bracket onto the transverse subspace therefore produces $P^T{\delta }^3$, equivalently the constrained Dirac bracket. The spatial zero mode is excluded by the decay condition; in a finite-volume regulator it must be treated separately.

Choose two orthonormal transverse photon polarization vectors ${\mathbf{ϵ}}_r(\mathbf{k})$, so thatThe canonical transverse photon field has mode expansionDifferentiate in time to obtain ${\Pi }_i^T$: the annihilation coefficient acquires $-i{\omega }_{\mathbf{k}}$ and the creation coefficient $+i{\omega }_{\mathbf{k}}$. The oscillator canonical commutation relations areSubstitution into $[A_i^T,{\Pi }_j^T]$ gives $i/2$ times the sum of the two Fourier kernels with phases $\pm i\mathbf{k}\cdot (\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{y})$. The polarization completeness relation and the evenness of $P^T(\mathbf{k})$ make that sum exactly $i{\delta }_{ij}^T$. This derives, rather than presumes, the correspondence between the oscillator and field commutators.

Substitute the mode expansions into $H_T$. Spatial integration sets paired momenta equal or opposite. The $aa$ and $a^{†}{a}^{†}$ terms from the electric and magnetic energies cancel because ${\omega }_{\mathbf{k}}^2=|\mathbf{k}{|}^2$ and $\mathbf{k}\cdot {\mathbf{ϵ}}_r=0$. The remaining terms are harmonic-oscillator energies. Removing the state-independent zero-point energy by normal ordering givesThe corresponding momentum operator is $\mathbf{P}={\sum }_r\int d^{3}k\mathbf{k}{a}_r^{†}{a}_r/(2\pi {)}^3$. These expressions imply $[H_T,a_r^{†}(\mathbf{k})]={\omega }_{\mathbf{k}}{a}_r^{†}(\mathbf{k})$ and $[\mathbf{P},a_r^{†}(\mathbf{k})]=\mathbf{k}{a}_r^{†}(\mathbf{k})$.

Define the Fock vacuum by $a_r(\mathbf{k})|0⟩=0$. Applying $a_r^{†}(\mathbf{k})$ creates a photon of energy $|\mathbf{k}|$, momentum $\mathbf{k}$, and one of two transverse polarizations. Its mass is zero because $k^2=0$. The relativistically normalized state is $|\mathbf{k},r⟩=\sqrt{2{\omega }_{\mathbf{k}}}{a}_r^{†}(\mathbf{k})|0⟩$, with inner product $2{\omega }_{\mathbf{k}}(2\pi {)}^3{\delta }_{rs}{\delta }^3(\mathbf{k}-\mathbf{q})$. Smearing these momentum eigenstates gives normalizable wave packets. Repeated commuting bosonic creation operators construct the symmetric multiphoton bosonic Fock space. Circular combinations of the two transverse photon polarization vectors transform with opposite phases under rotations about $\mathbf{k}$, giving the two physical helicities $\boxed{h=\pm 1}$.

The same physical states can be obtained while retaining manifest Lorentz covariance through Gupta-Bleuler quantization. Add the Feynman gauge term $-({\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }{)}^2/2$ and quantize four auxiliary oscillator polarizations. Their algebra has an indefinite metric, including a negative-norm temporal excitation. Impose $({\partial }_{\mu }{A}^{\mu }{)}^{(+)}|\mathrm{phys}⟩=0$ and take the Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient. Temporal and longitudinal excitations then do not survive as independent physical states. The result agrees with the positive, two-polarization space obtained by Coulomb gauge reduction; covariant gauge fixing is a different implementation of the same physical constraint, not four physical photon states.

Use signature $(+---)$ and take the covariant spatial components $A_i$ as canonical coordinates. The canonical quantization of the electromagnetic field begins with the canonical momentaThus the primary momentum constraint of the electromagnetic potential is ${\Pi }^0=0$: $A_0$ has no independent velocity. The Hamiltonian obtained by the Legendre transform in mechanics, up to a boundary term, isPreserving the primary constraint requires the Gauss law constraint in gauge theory, ${\partial }_i{\Pi }^i=0$. It also follows by varying $A_0$. These are two first-class constraints; they generate the gauge freedom and remove two canonical pairs from the four potential components. The reduced phase space has four dimensions per spatial mode, hence two propagating photon degrees of freedom.