Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 71 5 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For small baryon fraction the CDM growing mode is , and its gravity forcesFor an adiabatic cosmological perturbation to follow the unsuppressed growing mode, pressure must be below the gravitational forcing frequency: . With physical wavelength , this becomesThis is Jeans support versus forced baryon response. The wording “only grow” must refer to unsuppressed gravitational structure growth; it is not a theorem that all shorter-wavelength baryon perturbations are absent or constant. In the pressure-dominated regime a forced response remains. In particular, a falling sound speed can make this small response grow even before it catches up to CDM.
Before photon decoupling, the photon-baryon fluid has sound speed of order . Its Jeans scale is roughly a horizon scale, so smaller perturbations oscillate acoustically instead of freely following the growing CDM structures. After decoupling the baryon sound speed drops sharply. Above the new Jeans scale, pressure is negligible and subtraction of the CDM equation gives . For , the difference is a constant plus a decaying term; its ratio to the growing CDM contrast tends to zero. Baryons therefore catch up. Under the stipulated post-decoupling , the physical Jeans length scales as , the comoving scale as and the corresponding Jeans mass as .
For the requested instantaneous mass estimates, define the baryonic Jeans mass as the baryon content of a sphere of radius :Using the supplied matter-era age gives s and . ThenThe drop is by . A definition using the total gravitating mass instead of baryon content gives values about ten times larger. The pre-decoupling number is an acoustic Jeans order estimate, not an accurate application of the nonrelativistic equations from part a when .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2004 iii Paper 59 3 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Continue to choose the CDM-comoving synchronous frame. For nonrelativistic baryons, neglect corrections to gravitational density weights and Hubble friction, but retain , since gradients may compensate its small coefficient. ThenTogether with the metric tensor equation these giveThe friction terms contain first derivatives, as the original PDF confirms; they are missing in the TeX's transcription of these equations.
When , Cold dark matter sets the gravitational forcing. Its matter-era growing mode is . Compare pressure with the gravitational timescale:Converting the comoving wavenumber to a physical wavelength givesFor , pressure is negligible and baryons can follow the growing Cold dark matter mode. In that limit subtracting the two equations gives for , so . Relative to , this offset vanishes: baryons catch up.
The phrase “only grow” needs this gravitational-growth interpretation. For a small baryon fraction the baryon equation is forced, not an autonomous Jeans-instability equation. At , its slowly varying response isplus acoustic transients. It is suppressed rather than identically absent. For example, with constant sound speed, and , the equation is . Its particular solution is constant, and its oscillatory homogeneous part decays as . This demonstrates Jeans support versus forced baryon response; the scale above is not a theorem forbidding every forced or transient sub-Jeans change.
Before decoupling, tight photon coupling makes the effective sound speed large, about . The small- approximation just derived is not quantitative in that regime; the coupled photon-baryon fluid must be used. Its large pressure supports acoustic oscillations, and baryon clustering below the corresponding large Jeans/sound scale is inhibited while Cold dark matter wells grow. After decoupling the supplied sound speed is tiny and decreases further as the gas cools. The Jeans length drops sharply, so many previously supported modes fall into Cold dark matter wells and approach its growing density contrast. Modes still below the instantaneous pressure-support scale remain suppressed. The subsequent detailed thermal scaling depends on the gas's temperature evolution; the given sound-speed history suffices for this qualitative conclusion.