Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2005 iii Paper 42 3 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Put , and . Apart from a data-only constant, the log-likelihood isThe natural parameters in the ambient two-parameter exponential family of normal distributions are and , restricted to the nonaffine curve , . Its parametrization has rank one. Thus this is a one-dimensional curved exponential family inside a two-dimensional full family.
The Fisher-Neyman factorization theorem makes sufficient. For two samples , the parameter-dependent part of their log density ratio is . A polynomial in is constant on only if both nonconstant coefficients vanish. The likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency therefore proves is minimal sufficient.
Write with independent . Since , has a probability distribution independent of : it is an ancillary statistic. The denominator is nonzero almost surely. The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality gives ; on the requested positive branch, and .
The likelihood equation is . Its positive root isThere is exactly one positive root. The sign of the score function changes from positive to negative there, and at both ends of when , so it is the unique maximum-likelihood estimator. The useful identities areSubstitution yields, dropping the constant ,Differentiating twice and using at the fitted value gives the observed informationThe scalar P-star approximation uses . Consequently, with its normalizing factor explicitly retained,Here is chosen to make the density integrate to one, and is independent of . To see this without assuming an approximate normalizer, defineThe integral is finite and positive, and normalized is exactlyIndeed .
There is a direct check of this conditional scale density in a curved Gaussian family. In polar coordinates , the sample density times volume element is proportional to . Conditioning on fixes . The remaining angular factor is independent of , while . Thus the exact conditional radial density has the same normalized form. For the positive ancillary branch fixes the positive sign and the same one-dimensional radial calculation applies. In this scale model the normalized expression equals the exact conditional density, not merely its leading approximation.
For , compute its conditional distribution by one-dimensional quadrature:It is zero for ; with the conditional-density calculation just given, this normalized formula is exact for almost every admissible . Numerically, subtract the maximum log integrand before exponentiating to avoid overflow. The sampling probability still depends on the stipulated true ; replacing it by a fitted value would be a separate plug-in inference step.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 ii Paper 1 28I i Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
The joint likelihood is , so the factorization criterion for sufficiency proves sufficiency. For any two positive sample vectors its likelihood ratio is , independent of exactly when their sums agree. The likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency therefore makes minimal sufficient.
Its gamma distribution has density on . If is integrable for every and has expectation zero for every , thenBy uniqueness of the Laplace transform, almost everywhere. One may first multiply by to obtain an integrable function and use transform parameters ; this handles the transform's integrability hypothesis. Since the gamma densities are positive on , almost surely for every . is complete as well as minimal sufficient.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2010 ii Paper 4 27J Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
A complete statistic for a family if every measurable with and for all satisfies almost surely under every . It is boundedly complete if the same implication is required only for bounded measurable . Completeness therefore implies bounded completeness.
The vector is multivariate normal with mean zero and covarianceIts determinant is and its inverse is . Hence the joint density isThe Fisher-Neyman factorization theorem gives sufficiency. For minimality use the likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency. The density ratio for is independent of precisely whenis constant. Multiplying by shows that its constant would produce a quadratic term on the right whereas the left is linear, so that constant is zero. The remaining coefficients give . Thus is minimal sufficient statistic.
Each is standard normal, so . The integrable, nonzero function has zero expectation for every parameter, proving that is not complete.
By sufficiency, choose a version common to all parameters. The tower property givesOn the event we necessarily have , so there almost surely. This event has positive probability under every parameter because the joint normal density is strictly positive on a ball about the origin. Thus is not identically . The bounded function has zero expectation for every parameter but is not almost surely zero. Consequently
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 ib Paper 1 19H c Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-06
Write , and . The joint probability density factors asBy the Fisher-Neyman factorization theorem, is a sufficient statistic. The same factorization shows that the smaller statistic is also a sufficient statistic. This gives the sufficient statistic for a symmetric uniform sample.
In fact, the likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency identifies as a minimal sufficient statistic: two sample points with the same have identical likelihoods for all ; with different , their likelihoods have different parameter supports, and so are not proportional as functions of . Equivalently, the condition that for every and some positive constant holds exactly when their absolute maxima agree.
To see rigorously that cannot be recovered from almost surely, fix any . The sample has a distribution invariant under simultaneous sign reversal. If almost surely, the same identity would hold for the sign-reversed sample on another probability-one set. Since is unchanged by sign reversal, it would follow thatand hence almost surely. But this event has probability zero for a finite sample from a continuous uniform distribution: it entails for some pair of indices, including the possible case . Therefore is not a function of the sufficient statistic . The pair of extrema is not minimally sufficient, for every , even though it is sufficient.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2017 ib Paper 1 19H a Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-05
A sufficient statistic has a conditional distribution of the full data given its value that is independent of the unknown parameter. A minimal sufficient statistic is sufficient and is a function of every other sufficient statistic, up to null sets. For a dominated family with common positive support, the likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency states that is minimal sufficient if holds exactly when is independent of .
For , the joint probability mass function isThe Fisher-Neyman factorization theorem proves sufficiency of . For two samples, the likelihood ratio is , independent of exactly when their sums agree. Thus is minimal sufficient. Any one-to-one transformation of it is also minimal sufficient, so chooseThis chosen estimator is an unbiased estimator, since each observation has mean . If instead the statistic is reported as , its expectation is , and as an estimator of it has bias (zero only when ). Being a minimal sufficient statistic is unchanged by this rescaling; being an unbiased estimator is not.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2019 ii Paper 4 13J d Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
For , define the class degree sumand define the number of within-college friendships byEach between-college edge contributes once to the degree sum of each endpoint's college, while each within-college edge contributes twice to its college's degree sum. The model-3 likelihood can therefore be writtenThe Fisher-Neyman factorization theorem shows that is sufficient.
For two networks , the likelihood ratio isBecause the parameters range independently over , this ratio is constant in exactly when every displayed difference vanishes. The likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency therefore gives the answerThis is the degree-sum sufficient statistic for an additive logistic network model.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2023 ib Paper 1 18H b Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-25
Expanding the exponent givesThe Fisher-Neyman factorization theorem therefore shows that is sufficient.
It is also minimal sufficient. For two sample points ,where is independent of . This ratio is independent of exactly when . The likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency applies, proving the claim and the general normal sample sum with known variance result in this case.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2024 ib Paper 1 6H b Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
A sufficient statistic is minimal sufficient if it is a function of every other sufficient statistic: whenever is sufficient, there is a function such that almost surely, up to the usual null-set qualification. Thus its level sets give the coarsest sufficient partition of the sample space. In a dominated family with positive densities, the likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency says that is minimal sufficient when
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2024 ib Paper 1 6H c Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-25
Moreover,is independent of exactly when , equivalently . The likelihood-ratio criterion for minimal sufficiency therefore proves that