Past exam of the condensed matter physics course of the University of Oxford 2021 1 d Solution 2026-10-25
An applied magnetic field changes the alignment of the manganese magnetic moments. The component of their magnetic structure factor perpendicular to the scattering vector contributes to magnetic neutron diffraction. A field-induced uniform magnetization has the same translational periodicity as the nuclear crystal structure, so its scattering amplitude can occur at the existing reciprocal lattice vectors. The diffraction wave intensities can therefore change without moving the peaks. Their angular positions still measure the same interplanar spacings. This mechanism does not require a measurable change of the lattice constant.
For competing exchanges on a body-centred cubic antiferromagnet, use the Heisenberg model convention , with each bond counted once, dimensionless spins, and positive antiferromagnetic . There are eight nearest and six next-nearest neighbours. Bond counting in the two classical collinear structures givesFor type II the eight contributions cancel, while all six bonds are antiparallel. Their crossing yields . One can also exclude a lower spiral within the classical bilinear model: writing givesFor a favourable sign of the product, . Hence when its minimum is at , the type-II ordering vectors. When , compare with the type-I value and use to obtain the complementary bound. ThusThis is a classical/mean-field energy comparison; an exact quantum ground state is not generally a collinear product state.
For type I a magnetic cell is the simple cube of side , with opposite moments at and . Its magnetic structure factor is proportional to . Allowed magnetic reflections have integer with odd. The first two families are and , with symmetry-equivalent members understood.
For type II choose magnetic primitive translations , and , enclosing four spins in volume . Equivalently, a side- cube is a convenient nonprimitive magnetic cell. On each original simple-cubic sublattice the moment at is proportional to . Accordingly,The translated body-centre basis gives , so there is no further extinction. The first two families are and . The neutron polarization factor may additionally suppress a reflection for a particular moment direction; the stated rules are the positional selection rules.
Each sublattice has number density and saturation magnetization . Replacing neighbouring spins by their averages makes their exchange energy equivalent to a molecular magnetic field. Its minus sign expresses antiferromagnetic exchange, not an externally applied field. Since ,For , . Linearizing the Brillouin magnetization formula givesThe g-factor cancels because exchange is specified in energy units. A convention with doubles these exchange energies and .
Let , and let denote the cubic coefficient of the Brillouin magnetization formula. The argument is . Thus impliesConsequently in mean-field theory. The positive branch falls from saturation at zero temperature to zero at and remains zero above it. An elastic magnetic neutron-reflection intensity scales as ; a log–log fit against has slope . Background subtraction and a suitable critical interval are needed. Fluctuations can change the measured exponent from its mean-field value; uniform bulk magnetization vanishes for a compensated antiferromagnet and is not itself this order parameter.
Choose the four basis-spin signs as in the order of positions listed in the source; reversing all signs changes no diffraction intensity. Apart from the common magnetic form factor and perpendicular-moment factor, the magnetic structure factor isThe first factor is nonzero exactly when and have opposite parity, and the second exactly when is odd. Thus the magnetic Bragg peaks requireWhen both conditions hold, before geometric and magnetic-form-factor weights. These are magnetic selection rules for the antiferromagnetic component, not conditions forbidding all nuclear diffraction at other indices.
