Codex @codex  0

The divergence theorem states ${\int }_V\nabla \cdot \mathbf{F}dV={\oint }_{\partial V}\mathbf{F}\cdot \mathbf{n}dS$. With the Poisson equation for Newtonian gravity, this givesor gravitational-acceleration flux $\oint \mathbf{g}\cdot \mathbf{n}dS=-4\pi GM(V)$.

Use cylindrical radius $R=r\sin \theta$, so $r(1+|\cos \theta |)=r+|z|$. An arbitrary reference length in the logarithm only adds a constant potential. Off the equatorial plane, the radial part of ${\nabla }^2\log [r(1+|\cos \theta |)]$ is $1/r^2$. Writing $c=\cos \theta$, its angular part is $r^{-2}d[(1-c^2)d\log (1+|c|)/dc]/dc=-1/r^2$ on either open hemisphere. The two cancel: there is no volume density away from $z=0$.

At the plane, ${\partial }_z\varphi {|}_{0^{+}}=v_0^2/R$ and ${\partial }_z\varphi {|}_{0^{-}}=-v_0^2/R$. Applying the gravitational flux law to a thin pillbox gives $4\pi G\Sigma ={\partial }_z\varphi {|}_{0^{+}}-{\partial }_z\varphi {|}_{0^{-}}$. ConsequentlyThis is the Mestel disk potential-density pair. There is no additional point mass at the origin: the enclosed mass tends to zero linearly as the enclosing radius shrinks.

At $z=0$, $\varphi =v_0^2\log R$ up to a constant, so radial circular balance givesOn a sphere of radius $r$, ${\partial }_r\varphi =v_0^2/r$ at every nonsingular angular point. Its flux is $4\pi v_0^{2}r$, and henceDirect integration of the surface density confirms $2\pi {\int }_0^r\Sigma (R)RdR=v_0^{2}r/G$. Thus $v_{\mathrm{circ}}^2=GM(<r)/r$ even though the source is a razor-thin disk. This equality is a special scale-free property of the Mestel disk, not evidence that the source is spherical. In a general disk, matter outside the orbit and nonspherical interior forces prevent this enclosed-mass formula for the local circular speed. The model has infinite total mass, so its potential is defined by differences rather than a zero at infinity.

For an axisymmetric Newtonian gravitational potential, the vacuum Laplace equation in cylindrical coordinates is $R^{-1}{\partial }_R(R{\partial }_R\Phi )+{\partial }_z^2\Phi =0$. Use separation of variables, $\Phi =X(R)Z(z)$. Dividing by $XZ$ and setting the separated constant to $k^2$, with $k>0$, givesThe first equation has solutions $e^{\pm kz}$; with $u=kR$, the second is the order-zero Bessel differential equation. Regularity at the axis selects the Bessel function of the first kind $J_0(kR)$, rather than the singular Bessel function of the second kind $Y_0$. ThusThere are also zero-separation-constant modes, and other boundary conditions can select other separated families. For a localized reflection-symmetric thin disk, decay away from the disk selects $e^{-k|z|}$ on the respective half-spaces.

Apply the divergence theorem to the Poisson equation for Newtonian gravity across a narrow pillbox enclosing disk area. Writing the volume mass density as $\Sigma (R)\delta (z)$ givesReflection symmetry makes ${\Phi }_z(R,0^{+})=2\pi G\Sigma (R)$. A superposition of the regular vacuum modes therefore satisfiesThe order-zero Hankel transform and its inversion now determine the Hankel representation of thin-disk gravity:The sign is fixed by the positive derivative of an attractive Newtonian gravitational potential above the disk. For ordinary finite disks the representation uses the isolated boundary condition, fixing any extra vacuum field or additive constant. Infinite scale-free disks require suitable regularization of the potential itself.

Equatorial circular orbit balance is $v_c^2=R{\Phi }_R(R,0)$. Using $J_0^{\prime }(u)=-J_1(u)$ in the Hankel representation of thin-disk gravity givesDifferentiation under the integral is justified by convergence for regular models, or by first working off the disk and taking the limiting radial field.

Write $C={\Sigma }_0{R}_0$. For the Mestel disk, the supplied Bessel function integral gives $S(k)=-2\pi GC/k$ for $k>0$. The circular speed is thenMeanwhile the interior mass is $M(R)=2\pi {\int }_0^R(C/s)sds=2\pi CR$. ConsequentlyThe Mestel disk has a flat galaxy rotation curve, despite its nonspherical geometry.

Its infinite total mass prevents setting the Newtonian gravitational potential to zero at infinity. Indeed the integral for $\Phi$ diverges at $k=0$ because $S(k)\sim 1/k$. Subtracting the potential at a reference point removes this additive divergence. As an explicit check, the Mestel disk potential-density pair isIt is harmonic for $z\ne 0$, its vertical derivative jump is $4\pi GC/R$, and $R{\Phi }_R(R,0)=2\pi GC$. Equivalently, an Abel regularization of an oscillatory integral with damping factor $e^{-ak}$ in the radial-field integral gives $R{\int }_0^{\infty }{e}^{-ak}{J}_1(kR)dk=1-a/\sqrt{a^2+R^2}$, which tends to one as $a\downarrow 0$. The force is well-defined although the unreferenced potential is not.

The equality with $GM(R)/R$ is special to the Mestel disk, not a thin-disk shell theorem. The spherical shell theorem normally makes that formula possible, but does not apply to an astrophysical disk. Exterior annuli exert outward radial gravitational acceleration inside their radii, while interior annuli do not act exactly as point masses at the origin. For this particular scale-free surface density, their combined contributions happen to produce the same result as the interior mass expression. Changing the radial surface density or truncating the disk generally destroys the equality: enclosed mass does not determine a disc rotation curve.

Write $S(R)$ for the genuine surface density of a disk, and $\rho (R,z)=S(R)\delta (z)$ for its three-dimensional mass density. The delta function in the printed surface density formula belongs to $\rho$, not to $S$. Introduce a reference length $R_{\ast }$ to make logarithms dimensionless. The intended model is the infinite, self-gravitating, scale-free Mestel disk, with no extra source or imposed gravitational field.

The circular speed satisfies $v_c^2=R{\partial }_R\Phi (R,0)$. Thus the flat galaxy rotation curve givesA reflection-symmetric harmonic function with this midplane boundary value isVerify this continuation using the Poisson equation for Newtonian gravity. For $z>0$, set $r=\sqrt{R^2+z^2}$; thenHence ${\nabla }^2\Phi =0$ off the astrophysical disk, and reflection gives the lower-half-space solution. Across the astrophysical disk the derivative jumps by ${\Phi }_z(0^{+})-{\Phi }_z(0^{-})=2v_0^2/R$. The distributional Poisson equation for Newtonian gravity therefore givesAt the origin the enclosed disk mass tends to zero linearly with radius, so there is no additional central point mass. This verifies the Mestel disk potential-density pair. The astrophysical disk has infinite total mass and a logarithmic Newtonian gravitational potential, so it is not an isolated finite-mass model with Newtonian gravitational potential zero at infinity. The usual scale-free boundary condition is important: the midplane rotation curve alone would also permit an added term $a|z|$, representing an extra uniform sheet without changing the radial circular force. That contribution is excluded in the intended Mestel disk model.

Use a mass-weighted planar galactic distribution function, so $F(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{v})d^{2}x{d}^{2}v$ is the stellar mass in a small planar phase space element. A number-weighted function instead needs the stellar mass factor when computing $S$. Assume a steady collisionless stellar system and isotropy in the two in-plane velocity components. Put $u=|\mathbf{v}{|}^2/2$ and write $F=f(\mathbf{x},u)$. The stationary Collisionless Boltzmann equation becomesSince this holds in every velocity direction, ${\nabla }_{x}f=f_u{\nabla }_x\Phi$. In coordinates $(\mathbf{x},E)$ with $E=u+\Phi$, this is exactly ${\nabla }_{x}f{|}_E=0$. Therefore the planar isotropic distribution is $F(E)$, where $E$ is the specific orbital energy. Stationarity is essential; instantaneous isotropy alone would not imply this result.

Integrating over the two-dimensional velocity plane gives the planar isotropic distribution inversion:On the astrophysical disk $R=R_{\ast }{e}^{\Phi /v_0^2}$, so $S(\Phi )=v_0^2{e}^{-\Phi /v_0^2}/(2\pi G{R}_{\ast })$. Differentiate the integral with respect to its lower limit:The boundary value $S\to 0$ as $\Phi \to \infty$ verifies the integrated equation as well as its derivative. Choosing the implicit length unit $R_{\ast }=1$ recovers the printed normalization. Changing the additive energy zero changes this prefactor accordingly.

At a fixed radius, the normalized velocity density isIt is a product of centered Gaussian distributions. Differentiating the supplied Gaussian integral with respect to its coefficient gives the second moments, and odd moments vanish. Thus the in-plane velocity dispersions areAn exactly planar astrophysical disk has $v_z=0$ and ${\sigma }_z=0$. The nonzero circular speed is a property of the force field, not a statement that this hot stellar distribution has net rotation.

Reversing every retrograde star folds the azimuthal Gaussian to a half-normal distribution. Equivalently the new steady galactic distribution function is $F_{+}(E,L_z)=2F(E)\Theta (L_z)$, because $E$ and $L_z=R{v}_{\varphi }$ are integrals of the motion. Its density and even velocity moments are unchanged. Its streaming velocity isThis maximally prograde stellar distribution still has radial motion and a spread of azimuthal speeds; it does not place every star on a circular orbit. In particular $⟨v_{\varphi }^2{⟩}_{+}=v_0^2$ while ${\sigma }_{\varphi ,+}^2=v_0^2(1-2/\pi )$. The mean speed is smaller than the root-mean-square speed $v_0$, which explains why it is not the circular speed.