Let be distinct prime numbers. Every group of group order is Abelian if and only if does not divide .
For sufficiency, the Sylow theorems make the number of Sylow p-subgroups one of , congruent to one modulo . The divisibility hypothesis excludes both nontrivial choices, so that subgroup is normal. The number of Sylow subgroups for is one of , congruent to one modulo . The choice is impossible because . If divided , primality and would force , hence ; this pair violates the hypothesis. Thus the other Sylow subgroup is normal too. Their intersection is trivial, and their group commutators lie in that intersection, so the group is their direct product of groups. A group of prime-square order is abelian: its nontrivial center of a group is either the whole group or has cyclic quotient, and a cyclic central quotient also forces commutativity. Both factors are therefore abelian.
For necessity, suppose . The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, so contains of order . Let the cyclic group act on the additive group of by mapping its generator to multiplication by . This is a well-defined nontrivial group action, since . The resulting semidirect product has order and is nonabelian, because the generator does not commute with a nonzero field element. Thus a nonabelian group of this order exists exactly when .
Take to be linear in its first argument and conjugate-linear in its second, with . For a Hermitian form over a quadratic finite field, . We first establish the quadratic finite-field norm and trace surjectivity needed for orthonormalization of a finite-field Hermitian form. The field norm maps onto because the multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic of order . The field trace is an -linear map into . It is nonzero: a nonzero polynomial of degree cannot vanish at all elements. It is therefore onto, including in characteristic two.
There must be with . Otherwise, for any , expanding the diagonal value gives
If , varying contradicts the surjectivity of the field trace. Thus all pairings would vanish, contrary to nondegeneracy. Choose with ; then has norm one. Every decomposes uniquely as
The restricted Hermitian form over a quadratic finite field on the orthogonal complement for a sesquilinear form is nondegenerate: a vector there orthogonal to that complement is also orthogonal to , hence to all of , and is zero. Induction produces an orthonormal basis .
The unitary group over a finite field is the group of invertible -linear maps preserving . In the orthonormal basis just constructed, its concise description is
The notation here uses the size of the matrix field; it is also frequently written . There is no determinant-one condition in this definition.
Put and write . The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, so on its nonzero elements the th-power map has kernel of size . For , character orthogonality consequently gives
where the sum is over its multiplicative characters. Thus, for ,
The term from the trivial character is and cancels the initial one.
For a nontrivial character, the prime-field character Gauss sum identity can be proved directly. Since on nonzero elements, substituting gives
The inner sum is for and otherwise. Since , the result is . The triangle inequality now proves the power Gauss sum over a prime field bound
This also includes , when the nonzero-frequency sum vanishes.
For , additive character orthogonality counts its representations as three powers:
The zero-frequency term is . Each other term has , so
If , this is less than , giving for every . Hence is a sufficient threshold for the three power summands over a large prime field conclusion.
Let be a uniformizer. Because is unramified, the same is a uniformizer of , and . The conjugates of all have the same valuation, so
This proves that every field norm has valuation divisible by . Conversely for every integer , so it remains to prove surjectivity of unit norms in unramified extensions.
Write , so . Reduction of the field norm on units is the finite-field norm
The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic. The displayed power map on a group of order has image of order , and is therefore onto . Given a unit , first choose with .
We can correct the norm at each subsequent power of . For and , expanding the product over the cyclic Galois group gives
All products involving at least two correction terms are divisible by , hence by . The residue field trace is onto even if the residue characteristic divides . Indeed its polynomial is nonzero of degree ; it cannot vanish at every element of . Its values lie in , since raising to cyclically permutes the summands. Thus it is a nonzero -linear map to the one-dimensional space , and is surjective.
Suppose . Choose whose trace is the coefficient of in , and put . Then , and . By completeness the units converge to a unit . The field norm is continuous, being a polynomial in coordinates of multiplication, so . Multiplying such a unit by a power of proves
The proof uses no local class field theory, and works in either characteristic.
A strong lifting lemma. Let be a complete discrete valuation ring, with fraction field and normalized discrete valuation . A useful strong form of Hensel lemma says that for and satisfying
there is a root with
If , take . Otherwise the hypothesis ensures that . The root is unique among satisfying . In particular, a simple root of the reduction of lifts uniquely with its specified residue.
Here is a proof by Newton iteration over a valued field. Put and
Write and . Taylor expansion over shows, inductively, that the increment has valuation , that , and that
Indeed, the constant and linear terms of cancel, leaving terms of valuation at least twice that of the increment. The change in has valuation greater than , so its valuation stays . Thus all iterates lie in and form a Cauchy sequence. Completeness and continuity give a root . The later increments have strictly larger valuations than the first, proving the displayed distance formula. For uniqueness, if are in the stated ball, Taylor expansion factors
The second factor is nonzero, so two roots must coincide. This proves Hensel's lemma in the form needed here.
Odd residue characteristic. For odd , a p-adic unit is a square exactly when its reduction is a square in . Necessity follows by reduction. For sufficiency, a nonzero residue root of has derivative invertible modulo , so the Hensel lemma lifts it. The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, and its subgroup of squares has index two. Therefore
Representatives are and any unit whose reduction is a quadratic nonresidue.
Residue characteristic two. An odd integer has square congruent to one modulo eight, so a square 2-adic unit must lie in . Conversely, if , take and . Then , and the strong form of Hensel lemma produces a square root. Hence
The four unit square classes of the p-adic integers have representatives .
If the minimal polynomial of has degree , then
has elements and is an intermediate field of
. The tower law for field extensions gives
so .
The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic. Choose a generator
of , of order . If lay in a proper intermediate field of degree , its order would divide , a contradiction. Thus
and its minimal polynomial has degree .
For arbitrary , let be the splitting field of
over . Its roots form a field: the Frobenius endomorphism shows they are closed under addition, subtraction, multiplication, and inversion. The derivative is , so there are exactly distinct roots. Thus this root field has order . Applying the preceding generator argument supplies an element whose minimal polynomial over has degree , proving that an irreducible polynomial of every positive degree exists.
Apply the Abelian group criterion for a product of two prime squares with the smaller and larger primes in their correct order. For , all such groups are Abelian exactly when . Of the primes , only qualifies. For , the criterion is , equivalently . Therefore the exact answer is
Equivalently, among the stipulated primes , exclude and the residue classes modulo .
For completeness, the necessity in that criterion supplies actual counterexamples at every excluded prime. If and , the multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, so choose of order . Let a generator of act on the additive group of by multiplication by . This defines a nontrivial group action, hence a nonabelian semidirect product of order . Use for , and for with . Thus no excluded prime can be restored to the answer.
For in the finite field , put . The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, and character orthogonality expresses the number of th roots of as . The trivial character contributes , cancelling the term. Each of the remaining Gauss sums of Dirichlet characters has modulus , by the prime-field character Gauss sum identity. Consequently .
Quadratic finite-field norm and trace surjectivity Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
For , the field norm maps the nonzero elements onto : the multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, and the power has image of order . The field trace is also onto. Indeed it is an -linear map into , and is not zero because its polynomial has degree and cannot vanish at all field elements. Consequently is onto whenever .