Argument principle Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
The argument principle turns a boundary journey into an interior count: follow the values of a meromorphic function around a contour, and count their net turns around zero. Every enclosed zero of a function contributes its multiplicity of a zero; every enclosed pole subtracts its order. There is no need to find each zero of a function separately.
Let be a piecewise smooth simple closed curve with positive orientation of a contour. Suppose is a meromorphic function on an open neighborhood of the curve and its interior, with no zeros of a function or poles on . Then
Here is the sum of the zero multiplicities inside , and is the sum of the orders of its enclosed poles. The image contour may cross itself or revisit a point. Its signed winding number, rather than the number of visually bounded regions, is the quantity that counts.[ref]
For the polynomial and the unit circle , , the image is . It goes around zero three times although its drawn outline is just one circle. The interior contains one distinct zero of a function, at zero, with multiplicity of a zero three: the count is three. Reversing the orientation of a contour reverses the winding number and the sign of the contour integral.
An argument must be followed continuously along the journey. Subtracting the principal arguments at the endpoints loses whole turns: a closed image contour has the same endpoint value even when its winding number is nonzero. Nor does winding number zero prove that there are no zeros of a function: one enclosed simple zero of a function and one enclosed simple pole cancel in . Known poles must be added back to recover .
The mechanism is short. Near a zero of a function of order , factor with a nonvanishing holomorphic function. Its logarithmic derivative is , so its residue is . A pole of order gives residue . The residue theorem adds those contributions. Changing variables to identifies the resulting contour integral with the winding number. This is a local algebraic count joined to a global geometric count.[ref]
The usefulness goes beyond explicit polynomials. Rouché's theorem keeps a count unchanged when a boundary perturbation cannot push the image contour through zero. The Nyquist stability criterion applies the same counting idea to poles governing a system under feedback control.[ref]
Nyquist stability criterion Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-11-05
The Nyquist stability criterion applies the argument principle to a specified negative-feedback return ratio . Assume a proper rational loop with a well-posed interconnection, no poles or closed-loop characteristic zeros on the imaginary axis, and no singularity at the closing part of the contour. Let count poles of in the open right half-plane and let count zeros of there, both with multiplicity. For a positively oriented contour enclosing that half-plane, let be the signed counterclockwise winding of its image under around . Then
A clockwise contour convention reverses the sign of , so the orientation must accompany the formula. Closed-loop input-output stability requires and exclusion of imaginary-axis zeros; simply passing through or encircling is not a conclusion without the pole count and convention.
Poles on the imaginary axis require an indented contour and a corresponding boundary analysis. Also, cancellations in a reduced transfer function can conceal unstable internal states, so a Nyquist conclusion about alone does not prove internal stability of an arbitrary nonminimal realization. The bounded-input bounded-output stability example exhibits that distinction.
For and , zero-initial-data Laplace transforms give the displayed transfer function. For its pole is in the open left half-plane, while and its zero lies in the right half-plane. Passing through in this plant's frequency plot is not evidence of an unstable open cavity: a Nyquist stability criterion needs an explicitly specified feedback return ratio.
For a specified negative-feedback loop with return ratio , let be its number of open-right-half-plane poles. Let be the signed clockwise encirclement count of by the standard Nyquist stability criterion contour. Provided the contour does not hit a singularity or the critical point, the number of right-half-plane closed-loop poles is . Thus closed-loop stability requires and no closed-loop pole on the imaginary axis, with the usual well-posedness and absence of hidden unstable cancellations. For an already stable return ratio, there must be no encirclement of and no passage through it.
The open cavity itself, for , has state eigenvalue and transfer-function pole . Its initial transient decays and its impulse response is a direct-feedthrough term plus a decaying exponential. Hence the open-loop cavity is asymptotically stable and its transfer function is BIBO stable. The right-half-plane zero at does not make the open cavity unstable. On the frequency axis,
Its unit-circle plot passes through at . A Nyquist stability criterion is a feedback criterion; this passage is not by itself a test of open-plant stability.
If the intended interpretation is a unit negative-feedback loop with , then
That loop has a pole at zero, so unit negative feedback is marginal rather than asymptotically stable, and the critical-point passage correctly prevents a strict Nyquist stability conclusion. Without a specified feedback interconnection, the unambiguous conclusion is the stable open cavity, not that particular closed loop.
Assume and zero initial cavity amplitude. Taking Laplace transforms gives
Eliminating the mode yields the passive cavity input-output transfer function
Its unique pole is , so the cavity's internal mode decays and its causal input-output response is stable. A nonzero initial amplitude would add to the output, a decaying transient.
For a precise Nyquist stability criterion interpretation of this open cavity, rewrite the mode equation as an integrator with negative state feedback. Its return ratio is , and its characteristic equation is . The frequency locus lies on the imaginary axis. The Nyquist indentation excluding the pole at the origin maps to a large semicircle in the right half-plane; the whole contour has no winding around . There are no right-half-plane open-loop poles within that indented contour, so there are no unstable characteristic zeros. There is also no zero-frequency characteristic root, since the physical characteristic polynomial is . This recovers asymptotic stability.
Do not use the plant as a return ratio without specifying an additional feedback connection. Indeed
and its locus passes through at . That would indicate a marginal mode for a new unity-negative-feedback loop with characteristic factor , but not instability of the original cavity. Part (e) supplies the actual return ratio for the beam-splitter network.
The stated is specifically the transfer from the external input to the internal field . Combining with gives
For and a nondegenerate beam splitter , the closed-loop pole is . The return ratio for the Nyquist stability criterion is . Its frequency locus is a circle of radius , so it cannot reach or encircle . The open cavity has no unstable poles; hence the closed loop has none. This agrees with the directly derived state damping rate.
The externally accessible output is different. From ,
It is again an all-pass cavity response. Confusing and would give the wrong output steady state.
For a constant coherent input mean , the steady mean cavity amplitude follows by setting its derivative to zero:
The input-output values also follow from and . For any initial mean amplitude, its difference from the stationary mean decays as .
The stability statement needs endpoint qualifications. At , normalization forces , and the cavity obeys : it is isolated and undamped, not asymptotically stable. Its external output is nevertheless the decoupled input. At , the algebraic elimination divides by zero; the instantaneous feedback connection is singular and is not a well-posed instance of these reduced equations. Thus strict cavity stability holds for , not for every real pair satisfying only .
Finally, is a quantum stochastic field, so arbitrary inputs do not approach a literal time-independent operator amplitude. The stationary expressions above describe a constant coherent drive's means, or the formal zero-frequency response. The full solution contains the filtered input-noise convolution
The stationary cavity density operator also depends on the input noise statistics. For this ideal passive cavity with a coherent drive and vacuum noise, it is the coherent state with the amplitude just calculated; without such input statistics, the gain function alone does not specify a complete stationary quantum state.
For ,
Its only pole is , so direct inspection gives stability exactly when
apart from the excluded boundary.
For the Nyquist stability criterion, let . The open loop has no right-half-plane poles, so . On the clockwise right-half-plane contour, the winding number of about zero, equivalently of about , satisfies
where is the number of unstable closed-loop poles. The Nyquist locus
is the circle with diameter joining and on the real axis, completed by its conjugate half.
If , this circle does not wind around , so , , and the loop is stable. If , it winds once with , so , and the loop is unstable. Nyquist therefore gives precisely the same condition .
Topic 11: Argument Principle by Jeremy Orloff Created 2026-10-13 Updated 2026-11-05
By Jeremy Orloff, named on the first page of the notes for MIT 18.04, Complex Variables with Applications, Spring 2018. The credit here refers to this authored set of notes.
Cited passages: §11.2, Theorems 11.1 and 11.4, pp. 1–3, gives the argument principle and its residue theorem explanation; §11.2.3 covers Rouché's theorem; §11.3.6 explains the Nyquist stability criterion, including the sign from the clockwise contour used there. Our rational-function and sparse-sampling examples and images are independently calculated.