Past exam of the astrophysics course of the University of Oxford / 2022 / 4 / b / Solution

Diffusive shock acceleration is viable in principle at $511\mathrm{GeV}$: repeated scattering off magnetic irregularities on opposite sides of a strong nonrelativistic shock wave can reach such energies. Actual viability requires a sufficiently large and long-lived accelerator with an acceleration time shorter than its escape and loss times; $\gamma$ alone does not establish those conditions.

Take positive velocity toward the upstream material, and let the front move at $+v_s$ in the upstream rest frame. For a strong adiabatic shock wave in a gas with adiabatic index $5/3$, the Rankine-Hugoniot conditions give ${\rho }_d/{\rho }_u=4$ and the shock-frame inflow speeds satisfy $u_1=v_s$, $u_2=v_s/4$. The signed velocities in the three frames areThus the two scattering media converge at $V=u_1-u_2=3v_s/4$. For a crossing particle with incident energy $E$ in its local plasma rest frame, a Lorentz transformation to the approaching other plasma giveswhere $\mu >0$ is the incident direction cosine measured toward the approaching medium and $pc\simeq E$. For an almost isotropic crossing population, flux weighting gives $⟨\mu ⟩={\int }_0^1{\mu }^{2}d\mu /{\int }_0^1\mu d\mu =2/3$. Scattering randomizes directions without changing energy in that plasma frame, and the reverse crossing has the same mean gain. ThereforeThese are first-order mean gains. They are not an increase of energy in one fixed frame caused by an instantaneous boundary crossing. Literally choosing the electron's instantaneous rest frame gives incident $E=m_e{c}^2$, and the other gas approaches at nearly $c$, so the expansion in small $V/c$ is invalid. This concrete frame check explains why the printed description of $V$ must instead refer to the upstream/downstream scattering frames.