Past exam of the chemistry course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2023 / Paper 1 / 6 / a

The large drop from carbon to silicon is the main trend; the smaller reversals at Ge and Pb reflect changes in shielding and valence-electron binding. Allen electronegativity is based on the mean binding energy of valence electrons in free ground-state atoms, rather than an arbitrary charge-transfer count. Moving to larger principal shells generally makes the valence electrons more diffuse and more shielded, reducing their attraction to the nucleus. carbon's compact second-shell valence orbitals therefore give particularly high electronegativity.

The intervening filled 3d shell shields imperfectly, increasing effective nuclear attraction in germanium relative to a simple smooth extrapolation from silicon. This helps explain Ge being slightly above Si rather than below it. Increased size then lowers Sn relative to Ge. The filled inner d and f shells and relativistic stabilization of lead's 6s electrons modify the next step; contraction and stronger binding of the 6s contribution help Pb lie slightly above Sn. The small reversals should not obscure the much larger C-to-Si change. The spectroscopic definition includes both occupied s and p valence contributions, so the relativistic s effect can influence the Allen average even though not every electron participates equally in every bond.^[ref]