Past exam of the field theories and collective phenomena in condensed matter course of the University of Oxford / 2025 / 2 / a

For $J>0$ each bond minimizes its energy when its two Ising spins are opposite, giving bond energy $-J$. An even ring allows every bond to do this simultaneously, including the closing bond required by the periodic boundary conditions. Its two ground states areThe two configurations are related by spin inversion symmetry. There is no geometrical frustration.

Let $k$ count parallel bonds. Then $N-k$ bonds are antiparallel and the energy isThe periodic boundary conditions imposeHence $N-k$ must be even. For odd $N$, $k$ is odd, so its minimum is one: one bond must be parallel. All other bonds alternate. Choosing that bond in $N$ ways and then choosing either value of $S_1$ determines every Ising spin, givingThis is an odd antiferromagnetic Ising ring: geometrical frustration forces one defect, whose location is unrestricted. The ground-state degeneracy includes both its possible locations and global spin inversion symmetry. The formula also includes the self-bond case $N=1$ under the stated Hamiltonian convention.