Past exam of the linear algebra course of the University of Oxford / 2021 / 3 / c / Solution

Writeon $V=W\times W^{\prime }$, where $W^{\prime }$ is the dual space. The dual pairing is linear separately in the vector and the linear functional. For example, for real numbers $a,b$,Thus $\omega$ is a bilinear form. It is also an alternating bilinear form, since

To prove that this is a nondegenerate bilinear form, suppose $(v,f)$ pairs to zero with every $(w,g)$. Setting $g=0$ gives $f(w)=0$ for every $w\in W$, hence $f=0$. Setting $w=0$ gives $g(v)=0$ for every $g\in W^{\prime }$. If $v\ne 0$, basis extension supplies a coordinate functional with $g(v)=1$, a contradiction. Thus $v=0$. The left radical is zero, and the displayed change of sign implies the right radical is zero as well. Hence $\omega$ is a nondegenerate bilinear form, making $V$ a symplectic vector space.

For the required example take the coordinate subspaceUsing the definition of the bilinear orthogonal complement in part (b),ThereforeThis is a Lagrangian subspace. Its dimension is $\dim W$, exactly half of $\dim V=2\dim W$, so part (b)(i) is satisfied.

There is no contradiction with part (b)(ii): that part asks whether a direct sum is guaranteed, and the answer is already no. Moreover, when $W\ne 0$, the present alternating bilinear form is not a symmetric bilinear form. Choose $v\ne 0$ and $f\in W^{\prime }$ with $f(v)=1$; thenIt therefore does not satisfy the symmetry hypothesis of part (b)(ii). If $W=0$, then $V=U=0$, and both $U=U^{\perp }$ and $V=U\oplus U^{\perp }$ hold trivially.