Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2001 / iii / Paper 72 / 3

Landau-Ginzburg theory describes a slowly varying order parameter by a local free-energy functional consistent with the microscopic symmetries. For a representative scalar system with spin-inversion symmetry, take the dimensionless functionalThe gradient term penalizes spatial variation, while the even local potential implements the zero-field symmetry $\varphi \mapsto -\varphi$. The positive quartic coefficient stabilizes a continuous transition. A negative quartic coefficient requires higher powers and can instead produce a first-order phase transition. A vector order parameter gives the corresponding rotationally invariant model with powers of $|\mathbf{\varphi }{|}^2$.

In the mean-field approximation, replace the field by a constant $M$ and minimize the local potential. Its equation of state and stable zero-field solutions areBelow the transition these two minima exhibit spontaneous symmetry breaking. Differentiating the equation of state gives $\chi =(r+3u{M}^2{)}^{-1}$: it is $1/r$ above the transition and $1/(2|r|)$ within either ordered phase. At $r=0$, $M=(h/u{)}^{1/3}$. The minimized zero-field free-energy density is zero above and $-r^2/(4u)$ below, apart from an analytic background; its second temperature derivative has a finite jump. Consequently

To include fluctuations, write $\varphi =M+\psi$. The quadratic part isA Gaussian functional integral therefore gives $⟨\psi (q)\psi (-q)⟩=(c{q}^2+r+3u{M}^2{)}^{-1}$, with the momentum-volume delta function understood. The Ornstein--Zernike correlation function has correlation length $\xi =\sqrt{c/(r+3u{M}^2)}$. Thus ${\nu }_{\mathrm{MF}}=1/2$, and at criticality the Gaussian covariance is proportional to $q^{-2}$, giving ${\eta }_{\mathrm{MF}}=0$. Continuous-symmetry ordered phases additionally have transverse Goldstone modes, for which the restoring mass vanishes.

The Gaussian integration contributes $\frac{1}{2}\int d^{d}q(2\pi {)}^{-d}\log (c{q}^2+r)$ to the disordered-phase free-energy density. Differentiating twice with respect to $r$ gives a critical contribution proportional to $\int d^{d}q(c{q}^2+r{)}^{-2}$; for $d<4$ its singular part grows as $r^{(d-4)/2}$ and at four dimensions it is logarithmic. Interacting fluctuations thus become important close to the critical point below four dimensions. The Ginzburg criterion tests this failure of the mean-field approximation; the renormalization group then explains modified exponents and universality. Mean-field theory finds the competing minima, while fluctuations determine whether its predicted critical behavior survives at long distance.

The Ginzburg criterion tests whether fluctuations on the scale of one correlation volume are small compared with the squared equilibrium order parameter. In the scalar quartic Landau-Ginzburg theory of part (a), the ordered mean-field value is $M^2=|r|/u$, and its longitudinal correlation length is proportional to $(c/|r|{)}^{1/2}$.

Average the fluctuation field over a region of size $\xi$. Its smoothing factor selects momenta of order ${\xi }^{-1}$ or smaller. The Gaussian correlation function then gives, up to a positive dimension-dependent constant,The last step follows directly by setting $q=\sqrt{|r|/c}k$. Dividing by $M^2$ proves the correlation-volume derivation of the scalar Ginzburg ratio:For $d<4$, the ratio diverges as the transition is approached, so there is a fluctuation-dominated critical region of a phase transition in which mean-field critical exponents cannot be trusted. With $r=r_{0}t$, an estimate of its width isin fixed microscopic units. Its numerical coefficient depends on the averaging convention and microscopic normalization.

For $d>4$, the ratio tends to zero and the long-distance mean-field approximation becomes self-consistent. Four is therefore the ordinary quartic upper critical dimension. At $d=4$ this test is marginal: its thermal power is zero, and the running quartic interaction produces logarithmic corrections. The marginal Ginzburg criterion alone cannot decide those logarithms. Short-distance contributions to an unaveraged variance renormalize the coefficients; they should not be mistaken for the long-wavelength fluctuations used in this criterion. Nor does the criterion by itself prove that a proposed ordered phase exists below its lower critical dimension.

The renormalization group organizes how a statistical system changes when observed at progressively larger length scales. Start with its partition function and a microscopic cutoff $\Lambda$. Split the Fourier transform field into modes below $\Lambda /b$ and modes in the shell $\Lambda /b<|q|<\Lambda$. Integrate the shell modes, rescale coordinates $x^{\prime }=x/b$ to restore the cutoff, and rescale the field to keep a chosen gradient normalization. This is a renormalization-group transformation. It preserves the partition function when the generated interactions and additive free energy terms are retained; truncating the resulting operator expansion is an approximation.

A renormalization-group fixed point has an invariant dimensionless interaction structure. The continuous flow of a nearby scaling field $v_i$ takes the linearized formA positive $y_i$ defines a relevant operator, a negative $y_i$ an irrelevant operator, and a zero $y_i$ a marginal operator requiring nonlinear analysis. The continuous-flow eigenvalues $y_i$ should not be confused with the discrete multipliers $b^{y_i}$. To reach a critical point, tune the relevant thermal variable and set the relevant symmetry-breaking source to zero. The resulting flow stays on the critical surface.

Microscopically different systems whose remaining couplings approach the same fixed point share a universality class. Irrelevant perturbations lose their influence on long-distance exponents. Relevant directions explain why varying the temperature or field moves the system away from criticality. The thermal scaling field obeys $t^{\prime }=b^{y_t}t$, while the rescaled correlation length is ${\xi }^{\prime }=\xi /b$. Taking $b=|t{|}^{-1/y_t}$ therefore gives $\nu =1/y_t$.

If the field has scaling dimension $x_{\varphi }=(d-2+\eta )/2$, the source term $\int h\varphi$ has eigenvalue $y_h=d-x_{\varphi }=(d+2-\eta )/2$. The singular free-energy density then obeyswhen the hyperscaling relation is valid. This derives the scaling hypothesis for critical phenomena and the exponent relations of Question 2 from the fixed-point picture.

At the Gaussian fixed point, keeping $\int (\nabla \varphi {)}^2$ invariant gives $x_{\varphi }=(d-2)/2$. The quadratic coupling has $y_r=2$ and the quartic coupling has $y_u=4-d$. Thus quartic interactions are relevant below four dimensions, marginal at four, and irrelevant above four. Below four, in dimensions where an ordinary continuous short-range scalar transition exists, an interacting Wilson-Fisher fixed point governs that transition. Above four, the Gaussian fixed point gives mean-field powers, but the quartic term remains necessary to stabilize the ordered state: it is a dangerously irrelevant coupling, explaining the failure of naive hyperscaling. The renormalization group connects scale invariance, universality, relevant tuning parameters and fluctuation corrections in one framework.