Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2004 / iii / Paper 1 / 4

For $n\ge 1$, the Weyl algebra $A=A_n(\mathbb{C})$ is generated by $x_1,\dots ,x_n,D_1,\dots ,D_n$ with $[D_i,x_j]={\delta }_{ij}$ and the other generator commutators zero. Iterating the differential Ore extension construction gives the ordered basis $x^{\alpha }{D}^{\beta }$. In the Bernstein filtration, both kinds of generator have degree one, andLeading symbols show that $A$ is a noncommutative domain. The Hilbert basis theorem and homogeneous-generator lifting by decreasing degree make it both left and right Noetherian.

It is also a simple ring. In a nonzero two-sided ideal, choose a nonzero element and a monomial $x^{{\alpha }_0}{D}^{{\beta }_0}$ of maximal total degree with nonzero coefficient $c$. Applying $(\mathrm{ad}D{)}^{{\alpha }_0}(\mathrm{ad}x{)}^{{\beta }_0}$ eliminates every lower-degree term and every different term of that maximal degree. The result is the nonzero scalar $(-1{)}^{|{\beta }_0|}{\alpha }_0!{\beta }_0!c$. Thus the ideal contains $1$. Here the scalar extraction by iterated Weyl commutators uses characteristic zero. Despite simplicity, $A$ has no nonzero finite-dimensional modules: in such a representation $[D_1,x_1]=I$ would have trace $0=\dim M$, impossible over $\mathbb{C}$. Its interesting module theory is necessarily infinite-dimensional.

For a finitely generated left module $M$, choose a finite-dimensional generating subspace $M_0$ and set $M_j=F_{j}A{M}_0$. This is a good filtration of a module. Its associated graded module is finite over the graded polynomial ring, so its cumulative Hilbert function is eventually a polynomial,with positive integer multiplicity $e(M)$. These are the Bernstein growth dimension of a Weyl algebra module and its multiplicity of a filtered module. Two good filtrations bound each other after fixed shifts: lift finite homogeneous generators in one filtration, bound their degrees in the other, and use compatibility with $F_{j}A$; then reverse the roles. The growth degree and leading coefficient therefore do not depend on the good filtration of a module. The degree is also the Gelfand–Kirillov dimension of a module and the dimension of the characteristic variety of a Weyl algebra module, the support of $\mathrm{gr}M$. Since $M$ is a quotient of a finite sum of copies of $A$, $d(M)\le 2n$.

The essential lower bound is the Bernstein inequality for Weyl algebra modules:Here is a full proof. Multiplication gives a linear map $F_{j}A\to {\mathrm{Hom}}_{\mathbb{C}}(M_j,M_{2j})$. Prove it injective by induction on $j$. At $j=0$ a scalar killing $M_0\ne 0$ must vanish. If $a\in F_{j}A$ kills $M_j$, then for every generator $z$, its commutator $[a,z]\in F_{j-1}A$ kills $M_{j-1}$: both $azm$ and $zam$ are zero for $m\in M_{j-1}$. Induction gives $[a,z]=0$ for all generators. In the ordered basis, $[D_i,a]$ differentiates the $x_i$ exponents and $[x_i,a]$ differentiates the $D_i$ exponents with a minus sign. Vanishing of all these commutators in characteristic zero forces $a$ to be a scalar. It then vanishes because it kills $M_0$. This proves the faithful finite-step action of a Weyl algebra and henceComparison of degrees gives $2n\le 2d(M)$, proving the inequality. Equally, without invoking eventual polynomiality, this estimate directly bounds the Gelfand–Kirillov dimension of a module below by $n$. Right modules satisfy the same inequality through the filtration-preserving isomorphism $A\cong A^{\mathrm{op}}$, $x_i\mapsto x_i$, $D_i\mapsto -D_i$.

A nonzero finitely generated module with $d(M)=n$ is a holonomic Weyl algebra module; the zero module is conventionally included. This minimal-growth class is stable under submodules, quotient modules and extensions. For $0\to N\to M\to Q\to 0$, take the induced and quotient filtrations. Their graded sequence is exact; Noetherianity of $\mathrm{gr}A$ makes the induced filtrations good. Thus the Hilbert functions add andif both nonzero terms have the top dimension, their multiplicities add. For a holonomic Weyl algebra module, every nonzero subquotient has dimension $n$, by the upper bound inherited from $M$ and Bernstein's lower bound. Each nonzero factor in a strict chain therefore consumes positive integral multiplicity. This proves the multiplicity bounds the length of a holonomic Weyl module:In particular a holonomic module is both Noetherian and Artinian and has finite length, although its vector-space dimension is infinite. This distinction separates finite-dimensional representation theory from finite-length Weyl module theory.

The polynomial module $\mathbb{C}[x_1,\dots ,x_n]$, with $x_i$ acting by multiplication and $D_i$ by differentiation, is generated by $1$. Its $M_j$ consists of polynomials of degree at most $j$, with dimension $\left(\genfrac{}{}{0ex}{}{j+n}{n}\right)$, so $d=n$ and $e=1$. It is simple: differentiating a maximal-degree monomial of a nonzero polynomial isolates a nonzero constant, and multiplication by polynomials then generates the whole module. A second basic example is the delta moduleUsing the reverse ordered basis $D^{\beta }{x}^{\alpha }$, its vector space is $\mathbb{C}[D_1,\dots ,D_n]$; $D_i$ acts by multiplication and $x_i$ by negative differentiation. The same argument proves simplicity and holonomicity. These two examples are exchanged by the automorphism $x_i\mapsto D_i$, $D_i\mapsto -x_i$. Free modules, in contrast, have growth dimension $2n$ and are not holonomic. Thus the central organizing invariants are good filtration of a module, growth dimension, characteristic support and multiplicity, with Bernstein's estimate explaining why dimension $n$ is the natural smallest nonzero size.