Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2004 / iii / Paper 72 / 1 / Solution

Write $B_{i\alpha }={\dot{A}}_{i\alpha }$ and assume that the material constraint is regular, so $F_{,A}\ne 0$. Differentiating the constraint shows that admissible rates of the deformation gradient satisfy $F_{,A_{i\alpha }}{B}_{i\alpha }=0$. The given stress-power identity says that $W_{,A}-N^T$ annihilates this tangent hyperplane. Its orthogonal complement is the one-dimensional span of $F_{,A}$, so a Lagrange multiplier gives the constraint reaction in hyperelastic stress:The sign of $q$ is a convention; the virtual work identity determines no constitutive value for this reaction. Regularity matters: a singular equation describing the same constraint need not have a nonzero gradient.

For incompressibility, take $F=\det A-1$. Differentiating the expression using the Levi-Civita symbol givesThe middle expression is the corresponding entry of the cofactor matrix. Since $\det A=1$, the nominal stress is thereforeFor the neo-Hookean solid, $W_{,A_{i\alpha }}=\mu A_{i\alpha }$, so in the material-first convention $N=\mu A^T+q{A}^{-1}$. The identity matrix satisfies the prescribed dead loading with $q=T-\mu$, proving that the undeformed cube is always an equilibrium.

To obtain the homogeneous tensile bifurcation of a neo-Hookean cube, first seek $A=\mathrm{diag}(\lambda ,\lambda ,{\lambda }^{-2})$, with $\lambda >0$. This has unit determinant. The two distinct diagonal stress equations are $\mu \lambda +q/\lambda =T$ and $\mu {\lambda }^{-2}+q{\lambda }^2=T$. Eliminating $q$ givesThus the nontrivial branch isThe function $h(\lambda )=\lambda +{\lambda }^{-2}$ decreases on $(0,2^{1/3})$ and increases on $(2^{1/3},\infty )$, because $h^{\prime }=1-2{\lambda }^{-3}$. Its minimum is $h(2^{1/3})=3/2^{2/3}$. Above this threshold there are two positive roots ${\lambda }_{-}<2^{1/3}<{\lambda }_{+}$. For $t\ne 2$, neither root is one, and the three choices of the exceptional coordinate for each root give six distinct diagonal deformation gradients, in addition to $I$.

At $t=2$, however, ${\lambda }_{-}=1$ and the three smaller-root matrices coincide with $I$: it would be incorrect to count those as three new deformations. The requested existence of seven distinct homogeneous deformations nevertheless holds even at this value. For any unit vector $n$, putIts positive eigenvalues are ${\lambda }_{+},{\lambda }_{+},{\lambda }_{+}^{-2}$, and its determinant is one. Since $A(n)$ is an orthogonal conjugate of the diagonal solution, the same $q=\mu /{\lambda }_{+}$ gives $\mu A(n{)}^T+qA(n{)}^{-1}=TI$. Choose the six directionsTheir outer products are distinct, and ${\lambda }_{+}>2^{1/3}>1$, so the six $A(n)$ are distinct from one another and from $I$. Constant nominal stress satisfies equilibrium and the prescribed surface tractions. Hence seven distinct homogeneous equilibria exist whenever $T/\mu >3/2^{2/3}$. This is an existence count, not an exhaustive classification: rotated principal axes actually give a continuous family. The conventional seven axis-aligned positive-stretch branches coalesce to four distinct matrices at $T/\mu =2$.