Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2005 / iii / Paper 37 / 4 / b / Solution

There is a normalization error in the original PDF: the first term contains $I$ rather than $\rho$. For a normalized qubit density operator, that printed expression has trace $2(1-p)+p=2-p$, so it is not a quantum channel except at $p=1$. The intended depolarizing channel is the Pauli channel that leaves the input unchanged with probability $1-p$ and applies each nonidentity Pauli matrix with probability $p/3$, for $0\le p\le 1$. Its Kraus operators areand ${\sum }_{k=0}^3{K}_k^{†}{K}_k=I$, proving that it is trace-preserving and a completely positive map.

Write the input in its Bloch vector representation,Conjugation by a Pauli matrix keeps its own Bloch vector component and reverses the other two. More explicitly, ${\sigma }_k{\sigma }_j{\sigma }_k={\sigma }_j$ for $j=k$ and $-{\sigma }_j$ for $j\ne k$. HenceThe corrected quantum channel therefore givesThus its action isThe Bloch sphere is sent to a sphere of radius $|1-4p/3|$ about the origin of the Bloch ball. At $p=0$ the action is the identity. For $0<p<3/4$ the Bloch vector shrinks without changing direction. At $p=3/4$ every input becomes the maximally mixed density operator $I/2$. For $3/4<p\le 1$, the Bloch vector reverses direction and shrinks, reaching factor $-1/3$ at $p=1$. The reversal is compatible with complete positivity because this remains a probabilistic mixture of Pauli matrices. The parameter here is the total nonidentity-error probability, not the retention parameter used in some definitions of the quantum depolarizing channel.

For completeness, retain the PDF literally and call its output $F_p(\rho )$. The same calculation givesThis has no normalized-output Bloch ball interpretation as printed. If it is manually normalized, thenThat different transformation sends $p=0$ to $I/2$, rather than to the input, and agrees with the intended answer only at $p=1$. The literal and corrected conventions therefore cannot be silently identified.