Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2013 / iii / Paper 57 / 1 / b / i / Solution

The rotational invariance of a central-potential Hamiltonian allows a simultaneous eigenstate of energy and the two-dimensional orbital angular momentum $L_z=-i\hslash {\partial }_{\varphi }$. For a separated wavefunction $F(r)G(\varphi )$, the Laplacian in polar coordinates givesThe $\varphi$ term must be a constant; write $G^{\prime \prime }/G=-k^2$. The angular eigenfunctions can be chosen as $e^{ik\varphi }$. Single-valuedness under $\varphi \mapsto \varphi +2\pi$ imposes $e^{2\pi ik}=1$, hence $k\in \mathbb{Z}$. The radial equation in the separation of a two-dimensional central-potential eigenstate isFor a real central potential and the usual real self-adjoint radial boundary conditions, the radial equation admits a basis of real solutions: real and imaginary parts of a complex solution obey the same equation and boundary conditions. Choose a real normalized radial eigenfunction. Since the plane area element in plane polar coordinates is $rdrd\varphi$, the normalization isThis establishes the intended separated simultaneous eigenstate form. It is not the form of every stationary state. The radial equation depends on $k^2$, so the $k$ and $-k$ sectors have the same energy. For $k\ge 1$, their normalized superpositionis a single-valued stationary state with that energy but is not a single angular exponential. Quantum degeneracy is precisely why separation of variables selects a convenient eigenstate basis rather than all vectors in an energy eigenspace. The printed assertion needs this qualification. The printed polar-coordinate aid also labels a gradient component tuple as a divergence; the gradient used below is the two-dimensional vector $\hat{\mathbf{r}}{\partial }_r+\hat{\mathbf{\varphi }}{r}^{-1}{\partial }_{\varphi }$.