Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2013 / iii / Paper 66 / 1 / a / Solution

Take $A>0$ and use primes for spatial derivatives. Two integration by parts operations in the first variation of the elastic filament's bending energy giveThus the Euler-Lagrange equation is $A{h}^{\prime \prime \prime \prime }=0$, and the fluctuation differential operator is $K=A{d}^4/d{x}^4$. In the L2 space inner product, its boundary form isThe conjugate endpoint trace pairs are $(h,h^{\prime \prime \prime })$ and $(h^{\prime },h^{\prime \prime })$. Requiring one member of each pair to vanish gives the four standard self-adjoint endpoint conditions for filament bending, applied at both ends:

Each pair annihilates the boundary form for all $u,v$ in the domain. Conversely, the remaining two endpoint traces can be chosen freely: requiring the boundary form to vanish against every such $u$ forces an adjoint-domain function $v$ to satisfy the same two conditions. This proves self-adjointness, rather than just formal symmetry, on the corresponding fourth-order Sobolev space domain.

The count four concerns these elementary homogeneous choices. Identical-end boundary conditions do not restrict all self-adjoint operators to these four possibilities. For example, $h=0$, $h^{\prime \prime }=b{h}^{\prime }$ at both ends, with any fixed real $b\ne 0$, also annihilates the boundary form: the remaining expression is $-\overline{u^{\prime }}b{v}^{\prime }+b\overline{u^{\prime }}{v}^{\prime }=0$. This Robin boundary condition supplies a continuous family beyond the four listed pairs.