Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2017 / iii / Paper 311 / 1 / b

The common axial Killing vector field fixes the same sign convention for both spins. Initial rest and alignment of the separation with the symmetry axis give no orbital angular momentum. At large separation, the total axial charge is therefore $J_1+J_2$. Since axisymmetric radiation carries no axial angular momentum, all of this charge remains in the remnant after the radiation has escaped and the exterior has settled:Here the spins are signed quantities about the same axis, not their magnitudes. The conclusion assumes the exact axisymmetry stipulated throughout the merger and no remaining exterior matter carrying angular momentum; the final stationary vacuum remnant is a Kerr black hole under the usual uniqueness hypotheses.

Assume the classical black-hole area theorem applies: the null energy condition and the required global regularity or strong asymptotic predictability hypotheses hold. The disconnected initial horizon sections then give $A_f\ge A_1+A_2$. DefineFor any regular Kerr black hole, $|J_i|\le M_i^2$, so $X\ge |J_1|+|J_2|\ge |J_f|$. The irreducible mass identity obtained by inverting the Kerr area relation isIndeed, $Y=M_f^2+\sqrt{M_f^4-J_f^2}$ implies $(Y-M_f^2{)}^2=M_f^4-J_f^2$, which gives this expression. At fixed $J_f$, its derivative with respect to $Y$ is $\frac{1}{2}(1-J_f^2/Y^2)\ge 0$ on the physical branch. Therefore the area bound for an axisymmetric Kerr merger isThis uses the ideal limit of infinite initial separation, in which the initial total energy is $M_1+M_2$. At finite separation it is the initial total gravitational energy, including binding energy, that replaces this sum. The inequality is an upper limit, not a prediction or a guarantee of saturation; real mergers increase the horizon area.

Changing only a spin sign leaves $X$ unchanged, whereas the square of the final angular momentum changes. For fixed nonzero $|J_1|,|J_2|$, same-sign spins give $(|J_1|+|J_2|{)}^2$, and opposite signs give $(|J_1|-|J_2|{)}^2$. The remnant must retain more rotational energy in the same-sign case, so its minimum allowed mass is larger and the radiated-energy upper limit is smaller. Cancellation of opposite spins permits more of the initial rotational energy to be radiated while respecting the same initial total area.

For example, equal extremal initial holes have $M_1=M_2=M$ and $|J_1|=|J_2|=M^2$. Same-sign spins allow at most $(2-\sqrt{2})M$, a fraction $1-1/\sqrt{2}$ of the initial energy; opposite signs allow at most $M$, a fraction $1/2$. These are geometric bounds under exact axisymmetry, not achievable-efficiency claims.