Past exam of the physics 2 paper of the University of Oxford / 2022 / 9 / b

Apply the superposition principle to the result of part (a). If $F(a,h)=-qh/[2\pi {ϵ}_0(a^2+h^2{)}^{3/2}]$, then the exact normal electric field from the two real point charges and their image charges isFor $d\ll h$, Taylor's theorem gives $E_z=-d{\partial }_{h}F+O(d^2)$. Sincethe leading electric dipole result isThe electric dipole moment is $\mathbf{p}=-qd\hat{\mathbf{z}}$. The circle $a=\sqrt{2}h$ is the zero of the leading normal electric field and hence of the induced surface charge density. Inside it, induced surface charge density is negative; outside it, positive. The tangential electric field is zero everywhere on the grounded electrical conductor, so the leading full electric field vanishes on that circle. The corresponding dipole-induced charge on a grounded plane integrates to zero over the whole plane: the negative central region is balanced by the positive exterior.

For finite $d$, $a=\sqrt{2}h$ is only the leading-order zero. With $u=h^{2/3}$ and $v=(h+d{)}^{2/3}$, the exact zero satisfies $a^2=uv(u+v)$, giving $a=\sqrt{2}(h+d/2)+O(d^2/h)$. For example, inserting any $d>0$ in the exact expression at $a=\sqrt{2}h$ does not give zero. This is a controlled electric dipole approximation, not an exact finite-separation identity.