Peebles primordial-plasma predictions

P. J. E. Peebles made the connection between microscopic processes and cosmological observables quantitative. His 1968 paper treated cosmological recombination as a kinetic problem. Capturing an Electron directly into the hydrogen ground state releases a photon that can ionize another atom. Net neutralization depends on escape of resonance radiation through cosmological redshift and on two-photon spontaneous emission from the $2s$ state. An equilibrium Saha equation alone does not give that history.^[ref]

This matters for an acoustic prediction because the hydrogen ionization fraction fixes the supply of free Electrons for Thomson scattering. In physical units the scattering rate per photon is ${\Gamma }_T=n_e{\sigma }_{T}c$. The cosmological visibility function describes the distribution of last-scattering times. Thus atomic physics helps determine when the photon-baryon acoustic oscillator is read out, as well as how rapidly tight coupling fails.

In 1970 P. J. E. Peebles and J. T. Yu followed adiabatic cosmological perturbations by numerically integrating the photon collision equation through cosmological recombination. Their calculation connected acoustic evolution and dissipation to residual matter structure and microwave brightness fluctuations. It did not assume that a perfect photon-baryon fluid remained valid throughout last scattering. Their illustrative cosmological models and normalization were historical choices, rather than the present Lambda-CDM model; their predicted brightness variance versus angular resolution should not be relabelled as a modern measured $C_{\ell }$ spectrum.^[ref]

The continuing idea is a forward prediction: specify initial conditions, evolve the coupled matter and radiation, project onto the sky, and compare the result with an instrument's readout. Coherent initial phases are needed for acoustic variance peaks explains why a collection of oscillating modes does not automatically produce a peaked power spectrum. The BOOMERANG acoustic-peak measurement provides a later observational test of this physical programme.

A deliberately restricted forced harmonic oscillator shows two effects of the baryon loading parameter without duplicating the full photon Boltzmann hierarchy. Use conformal time $d\eta =dt/a$ in seconds, a comoving wavenumber $k$ in inverse metres, constant $R=3{\rho }_b/(4{\rho }_{\gamma })$, and equal constant dimensionless Newtonian gauge gravitational potentials $\Phi =\Psi \ne 0$. The energy densities ${\rho }_b$ and ${\rho }_{\gamma }$ use the same units. Neglect expansion drag, Silk damping and evolution of the potentials. The photon-baryon sound speed is $c_s=c/\sqrt{3(1+R)}$. Writing ${\Theta }_0$ for the photon monopole temperature perturbation, the photon-baryon acoustic oscillator reduces toFor $y=({\Theta }_0+\Psi )/\Psi$ this gives the displayed forced equation. Constant loading and the neglected expansion drag make this a local teaching model, not a self-consistent expanding cosmology with $R$ fixed forever.

Choose $y(0)=1/3$ and $y^{\prime }(0)=0$, the static matter-era Sachs-Wolfe combination normalized by $\Psi$. With $q=k{c}_s\eta$, direct substitution givesAt $R=0$, successive extrema have equal magnitudes $1/3$. At the stipulated $R=0.6$, $y(\pi )=-23/15$ whereas $y(2\pi )=1/3$. The shifted equilibrium $y=-R$ makes alternating extrema unequal. This is an elementary illustration of how the baryon loading parameter changes acoustic amplitudes; these extrema are neither measured peak heights nor a complete Cosmic microwave background power spectrum. Comparing curves at fixed $q$ isolates the response; at fixed $k$ and $\eta$, increasing $R$ also reduces the photon-baryon sound speed and hence the phase.

For example, holding $c{\eta }_{\ast }=300\mathrm{Mpc}$ gives sound horizons $r_s=173.2\mathrm{Mpc}$ at $R=0$ and $136.9\mathrm{Mpc}$ at $R=0.6$. Their ratio is $1/\sqrt{1.6}$. Each term of the forced equation has units of inverse seconds squared because $y$ and $R$ are dimensionless and $k{c}_s$ is an inverse time. In the actual photon-baryon fluid, $R$ grows with the scale factor and the sound horizon is the integral of the evolving photon-baryon sound speed.