Since , the chain rule gives
For the radial vector field , the product rule and Einstein summation convention give
Put . Since and , the product rule gives
For the symmetric stresslet tensor ,
The final term is parallel to and drops out of the cross product, leaving
To first order in the weak fluctuation, , so
For
introduce the signs . The product rule gives
Assume that is a zero-mean stationary Gaussian random field, that its longitudinal correlation length is short compared with the envelope's evolution scale, and that the propagation distance is long compared with that correlation length. The forward Markov approximation then neglects diffraction during one correlation length. Applying the Furutsu–Novikov formula closes the last average at second order in . Define the integrated longitudinal autocorrelation function of a random field
Then
where
Writing and using the evenness of the covariance gives the equivalent expression
The derivation also assumes paraxial propagation, weak scattering, sufficient regularity to interchange differentiation and expectation, and statistical homogeneity in both coordinates. Without the short-correlation approximation, the Gaussian identity produces a nonlocal longitudinal memory integral rather than this local closed equation.
The chain rule and
give
Applying the same rule to and in the Euler-Lagrange field equation yields the exact modulated equation
Multiply this equation by . Since and are independent of the fast phase,
The product rule then rearranges the field equation into the exact modulated-wave first integral
Average this identity over one period in . Periodicity kills the first term, while differentiation of the averaged Lagrangian gives
Consequently
The same two equations follow directly from the modulated variational principle. Varying gives
which is the exact field equation above. For a variation of , use and . Integration by parts in and gives the averaged equation. Thus variation with respect to the periodic profile reproduces the local wave equation, whereas variation with respect to its slow phase gives the Whitham modulation equation for wave action.
Write
Divide by and let . Differentiability implies continuity, so . Therefore the product rule gives
To say that is twice differentiable at means that is defined in a neighbourhood of and is differentiable at ; its derivative is .
By the chain rule, near ,
Since is differentiable and is differentiable at , another use of the chain rule shows that is differentiable at . The product rule then proves that the displayed product is differentiable. Hence is twice differentiable, with the second derivative chain rule
Use the Polynomial representation of the Heisenberg Lie algebra on the infinite-dimensional polynomial ring :
The product rule gives , so this is a Lie algebra representation. It is a Faithful Lie algebra representation: if is the zero operator, applying it first to gives , and then applying the remaining operator to gives .
To prove irreducibility, let be a nonzero invariant subspace and choose a nonzero polynomial in of least degree. If its degree were positive, repeated differentiation would produce a nonzero element of smaller degree, so contains a nonzero constant. Invariance under multiplication by then puts every monomial in , and hence .
Because is a divergence-free vector field, the product rule gives
The integral of a divergence over the periodic domain vanishes. Hence integration by parts yields
This is the skew-symmetry of incompressible transport.
The regularity from part (i) makes and its first weak derivatives square-integrable. The product rule therefore holds in the distributional derivative sense:
Since , equality of mixed weak derivatives gives . Both remaining expressions belong to , so their distributional equality is an equality in that space: